How to fix mens physique:
- add weight limit
- drop the "too big" or "too ripped" requirements
- remove that ridiculous fucking shorts, switch to good old posing trunks. trunks, NOT thongs.
Bodybuilding is highly controversial and subjective even though we do have quite objective factors like level of muscularity or condition which are 90% of judges decision. In mens physique there is no obvious metric to use to asses one bodybuilder's quality.
It is highly illogical to say that you need to be as good as possible at X and Y and then put contraints like X<100 and Y<200. Mens physique is all about getting as close to the "ideal" muscularity and "ideal" condition. Problem is, no one really knows that the ideal level is and most importantly it is impossible to set an ideal and impossible for every judge to have same ideal. This is why this is not a real competition, it is a beauty contest.
If you want to limit bodybuilders, put objective limits that will FORCE other limits. For example weight limit makes it impossible to become overly muscular. If you use oldschool posing trunks no one will care about "shredded glutes" because no one will see them.