I know plenty of atheists. They are good people, in fact some are better at abiding by the laws of God and man that more than a few Christians, Jews or Buddists that I have known.
For the greater part I judge people on an individual basis. I am not God and in the end if God exists and we require judgment I suspect He will judge according to His wisdom and with fairness for all concerned. If I, a simple man can discern between good and evil, right and wrong and what is just and fair over that which is unjust and unfair, well how much more the one who created all of this?
We may well be made in the image of God, but each of us paints our own portrait. It would appear that some people bought a paint by numbers set. Not saying who or what they may or may not believe in, just that it is so.
Butterbean, if you read this give me a PM as I may have some "sermons" that might interest you. Thanks!