Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: che on January 18, 2013, 04:20:03 PM
-
Here next to one of the widest bodybuilders ever ''The Fridge''
(http://fitnessfreak24.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/Phil-Heath-Jay-cutler-Posing.jpg)
(http://obama.net/wp-content/uploads/philheath_jaycutler.jpg)
(http://fitnessfreak24.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/jay-cutler-phil-heath.jpg)
I've never heard anyone say : Branch Warren is narrow
(http://i.imgur.com/BGaym.jpg)
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-jp_VmX9fNTE/T-HzcchFplI/AAAAAAAAE2U/667ywRQllsM/s400/phil.jp)
Next to Dexter , narrowest Mr Olympia ever ::)
(https://i1.ytimg.com/vi/4mw5YioyS0Y/mqdefault.jpg)
(http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-TiY9EB_qQHg/UA3DFIrBRtI/AAAAAAAAIyA/s166CFXmjXA/s640/Mr.+Olympia+2010+(107).jpg)
Kai Greene
(http://pics.musculardevelopment.com/photos/transferred/_PB74017wtmk.JPG)
(http://fitness.dwaynekilbourne.com/files/2012/10/Phil_Heath_Kai_Greene_Mr_Olympia.jpg)
Haters gonna hate
(http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m4p23iOFBT1qeaj38o1_500.jpg)
(http://i.imgur.com/hQVyV.jpg)
(http://24.media.tumblr.com/fd6833c5854bfd53aaceac3c4a8600dc/tumblr_mg02szqNHb1qjz6zwo1_500.jpg)
(http://24.media.tumblr.com/c54016a9527be4254d640c2bfc123318/tumblr_mgbn5iGqdb1qfio18o1_500.jpg)
-
Ugh, Saturday morning and I'm on the internet.. :'(
You've got a point.. somewhat.
I was genuinely curious about what you were saying, so I took a look in photoshop and indeed, I discovered that the total width of Phil is in parity.
What you're seeing below is Phil's width compared to Cutlers (no zoom, in that picture he really is wider, though perspective may be the reason).
The second image is why you are wrong. It is his chest compared with Cutler's. As you can see, he IS more narrow, it's just in the torso (and you can see that I didn't even do Cutler justice, on the right side, I cut him a bit wrong).
Think about that for a second. In that photo he's wider than cutler yet his chest is significantly less wide. I did not in any way modify the image.
When I look at Phil, I don't see a balanced physique. I see giant, impressive arms, small shoulders compared them and a very narrow chest width.
Hope that lays to rest what you're saying which was valid but not quite the right focus.
(http://i48.tinypic.com/o3828.jpg)
-
:D
-
Ugh, Saturday morning and I'm on the internet.. :'(
You've got a point.. somewhat.
I was genuinely curious about what you were saying, so I took a look in photoshop and indeed, I discovered that the total width of Phil is in parity.
What you're seeing below is Phil's width compared to Cutlers (no zoom, in that picture he really is wider, though perspective may be the reason).
The second image is why you are wrong. It is his chest compared with Cutler's. As you can see, he IS more narrow, it's just in the torso (and you can see that I didn't even do Cutler justice, on the right side, I cut him a bit wrong).
Think about that for a second. In that photo he's wider than cutler yet his chest is significantly less wide. I did not in any way modify the image.
When I look at Phil, I don't see a balanced physique. I see giant, impressive arms, small shoulders compared them and a very narrow chest width.
Hope that lays to rest what you're saying which was valid but not quite the right focus.
I didn't say Phil was wider than Jay , what I'm trying to say is that the difference is minimal .
-
Nonsense.. phil has loads of round muscle definitely.. pics can cast an illusion i have seen this guy up close and live
(http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTKOwCbWc7qeRwrvJfuYUBRKTYozoT_meCDJPM6tPtLY0BPxsUPEu0RhMvT)
mr olympia the biggest baddest physique on earth is directly in front of this woman...
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/6CB2644F-F8A4-4DEE-AABD-18B6A6D23399-157-00000007FDE539EB.jpg)
....
-
haha meso destroying che's thread with minimal effort
the guy is a small, gay man with muscles.
of course the difference is "minimal". the difference between ronnie coleman and dan hill is "minimal" too, from a normal person's perspective. another reason why "pro-bodybuilding" is incredibly pathetic: the entire affair is about making a mountain out of a molehill.
-
illusion
That's what bodybuilding is all about .
BTW great pics to prove your point ,ha ha.
-
those pics with the women i took myself... last yr
phil has superb round muscles.... they just hang off him but he is narrow.... for a pro and mr o...
I don't care what pics are posted black and white in the gym.... nicely angled or the magic shot out of a million shown whatever... Ive seen him with my own eyes... narrow... his arms and delts look ridiculous that I will say
-
I didn't say Phil was wider than Jay , what I'm trying to say is that the difference is minimal .
I didn't misinterpret what you said - I didn't think you said that Phil was wider than Jay.
But you did ask the reader to compare widths (to debunk that Heath is narrow) and that is what I did. Then I had a think about how yes, the width is similar, or larger in that photo and why he still looks narrow - and figured it out.
IE, what you were trying to say is irrelevant to the question of if he is narrow.
I could go right through every single one of those photos you posted and post the comparison of chest size and just about every single angle, he's significantly smaller in surface area.. That is primarily why Heath is "narrow". He has a narrow chest. I'm still skeptical that he is truly as wide as Jay, but you understand the implication, right? If he is truly as wide as Jay, he has a very narrow chest. If Jay is actually wider and that photo doesn't show it, he has an extremely narrow chest compared to Jay.
Either way, Phil Heath is narrow. That is a fact.
-
That's what bodybuilding is all about .
BTW great pics to prove your point ,ha ha.
I agree... phil casts a spectacular illusion....
he does have great muscle shape and insertions....
-
Seen Phil up close.. He is narrow as hell.. Makes his head look enormous lol.. Great shape.. Great insertions..but narrow bone structure.. I.e. rib cage and clavicles.. Look at his college basketball pics to see how truly narrow he was.. Made great improvements, after all , he is mro.. But it is what it is..
I have seen jay in person.. Wide as a glider...
-
He will be at the LA Fitness expo tomorrow and Sunday at the convention center
Anyone in LA go to subway get a coupon and get in for $10
See Phil upfront and in person
U will get your $10 in shitty supplament samples
-
Shoulders like a Brook Trout!
-
I'm not buying into this conspiracy.
Verdict: Phil is still narrow for a Mr. O
-
(http://oi54.tinypic.com/ipp46x.jpg)
(http://anabolismo.files.wordpress.com/2010/07/alexey-lesukov-phil-heath-kl1.jpg)
(http://www.europeanbodybuilding.com/tl_files/galerien/PhilHeath_RobertBurneika/DSC_0122.JPG)
(http://pics.musculardevelopment.com/photos/transferred/BOB_9707wtmk.JPG)
-
(http://oi54.tinypic.com/ipp46x.jpg)
(http://anabolismo.files.wordpress.com/2010/07/alexey-lesukov-phil-heath-kl1.jpg)
(http://www.europeanbodybuilding.com/tl_files/galerien/PhilHeath_RobertBurneika/DSC_0122.JPG)
lights out
-
If you don't see the narowness in Phil, you don't have an eye for physiques and their proportions.
-
Phil Heath is not narrow, you guys think that cause you are comparing him to Ronnie and Jay, the 2 widest bodybuilders. Phil is wider then Dex and maybe even Branch, no on calls them narrow.
He gives the illusion of being narrow from certain angles cause his shouders wrap into his chest and his chest is long verdically making his clavicles look narrow, that's it.
Compared to Markus and other 280 lb behomoths who wouldn't look narrow when your competition weight is 240 lb
-
getbig made me aware of the concept of narrowness and i found out i'm narrow
i was happier before realizing this
-
you know that jay cutler is not a very wide bodybuilder either, big ron always was superior to little bay butler.
-
Phil Heath is not narrow, you guys think that cause you are comparing him to Ronnie and Jay, the 2 widest bodybuilders. Phil is wider then Dex and maybe even Branch, no on calls them narrow.
He gives the illusion of being narrow from certain angles cause his shouders wrap into his chest and his chest is long verdically making his clavicles look narrow, that's it.
Compared to Markus and other 280 lb behomoths who wouldn't look narrow when your competition weight is 240 lb
They are ~5" shorter though bro
-
you know that jay cutler is not a very wide bodybuilder either, big ron always was superior to little bay butler.
ronnie is narrower than jay
wolf is wide
-
All blind Here?
Ronnie was narrow too.
So were levrone, Wheeler, ray,
Wide is like Dennis Wolf or ruhl
Average is like nasser, Yates,
Phil is Not just narrow, he is tiny
Skeleton of a small Woman with 30iu gh 500iu Insulin Daily muscle
-
(http://bodybuilding-blog.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/SNAG-0057_03.jpg)
-
(http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-7pwsaAa-Ong/T-ikOpF9OGI/AAAAAAAAFvw/66UXT7g0G5U/s1600/Joel+Stubbs+(3).jpg)
-
:)
-
(http://oi54.tinypic.com/ipp46x.jpg)
(http://anabolismo.files.wordpress.com/2010/07/alexey-lesukov-phil-heath-kl1.jpg)
(http://www.europeanbodybuilding.com/tl_files/galerien/PhilHeath_RobertBurneika/DSC_0122.JPG)
(http://pics.musculardevelopment.com/photos/transferred/BOB_9707wtmk.JPG)
Thank you for proving my point,E-Kul .
(http://t0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ6_KSCVBOZ6Qu-rYm5F-DX3ohPZ-5i0lbwWeaKm1x8jQs6g70TKkUPSM_a3A)
(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=214359.0;attach=250791;image)
(http://bodybuilding.nolimit.cz/image/11456152)
(http://4.bp.blogspot.com/_SlFz_gKpmM8/TMma8gx93DI/AAAAAAAAADM/7Dt11XQcboM/s320/Ronnie_Coleman_and_Wife_in_2009.jpg)
-
what does an over the hill retired coleman have to do with .. phil heath being narrow??? ??? ??? ??? ???
This is Mr olympia now
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
ill tell you now if heath showed up at that expo... in a tshirt arms covered no one would dream he was mr o the worlds most impressive and best physique.... it was cold and phil was the one of the only pro guys in a tank vest
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
-
what does an over the hill retired coleman have to do with .. phil heath being narrow??? ??? ??? ??? ???
This is Mr olympia now
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
ill tell you now if heath showed up at that expo... in a tshirt arms covered no one would dream he was mr o the worlds most impressive and best physique.... it was cold and phil was the one of the only pro guys in a tank vest
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
i only see a what appears to be a male model standing up, talking to a female, and Phil's arm sticking out, as he is in the background and is sitting on a stool.
-
the male model is a card board cut out...
pil is sittng on a stool is rms akimbo and a normal woman is standing in front of him and we cant see him....
mr olympia..
that would not happen with coleman jay yates kai...
so when people post these wonderful angled gym shots saying phil isnt narrow... i say thats silly talk... i have seen this guy up close... round muscles yes full yes.... good genetics hell yes..... good width for a pro ....or mr O hell no .... 1000 times
-
... i have seen this guy up close..
You act like you're the only one that seen Phil up close ::)
Did you say narrow ?
(http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_mC1TEdZ4gks/SwewLeX6HiI/AAAAAAAACkY/skURKEfpOR0/s1600/Ronnie+coleman+at+2002+mr+olympia.JPG)
(http://img43.imageshack.us/img43/9132/bigron0.jpg)
(http://images.t-nation.com/forum_images/auto/r/786x0/1/c/1cfa5_ORIG-224497_10150264570092671_502187670_8242167_455167_n.jpg)
(http://www.t-nation.com/img/photos/2009/09-086-training/01.jpg)
(http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTAF0ZsFnU5ExBD-Au3lgkbKWfQN-9dljgk9KCaDgXJBTnA-lrbrEC3efT6jw)
-
You act like you're the only one that seen Phil up close ::)
Did you say narrow ?
(http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_mC1TEdZ4gks/SwewLeX6HiI/AAAAAAAACkY/skURKEfpOR0/s1600/Ronnie+coleman+at+2002+mr+olympia.JPG)
(http://img43.imageshack.us/img43/9132/bigron0.jpg)
(http://images.t-nation.com/forum_images/auto/r/786x0/1/c/1cfa5_ORIG-224497_10150264570092671_502187670_8242167_455167_n.jpg)
(http://www.t-nation.com/img/photos/2009/09-086-training/01.jpg)
(http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTAF0ZsFnU5ExBD-Au3lgkbKWfQN-9dljgk9KCaDgXJBTnA-lrbrEC3efT6jw)
have you seen phil....
coleman has the worst posture ever..... he atnds with his shoulders pinched... this is a known fact..... everyone knows coleman in reality is wide.....
but i fail to see how this has anything to do with a thread discussing phils width or lack .....
i have more pics i can post from that event but i wont belabour a point....
what i will say is... if phil disnt have those arms... 90% of people on his bandwagon would hop off....
because when you look past the arms.... well....
anyway... Ill leave you to it
meso
-
You act like you're the only one that seen Phil up close ::)
Did you say narrow ?
(http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_mC1TEdZ4gks/SwewLeX6HiI/AAAAAAAACkY/skURKEfpOR0/s1600/Ronnie+coleman+at+2002+mr+olympia.JPG)
(http://img43.imageshack.us/img43/9132/bigron0.jpg)
(http://images.t-nation.com/forum_images/auto/r/786x0/1/c/1cfa5_ORIG-224497_10150264570092671_502187670_8242167_455167_n.jpg)
(http://www.t-nation.com/img/photos/2009/09-086-training/01.jpg)
(http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTAF0ZsFnU5ExBD-Au3lgkbKWfQN-9dljgk9KCaDgXJBTnA-lrbrEC3efT6jw)
again ronnie had declining and not very long cavlicles
but he still one of the GOATs while heath is like 2012 version of aaron baker
-
have you seen phil....
coleman has the worst posture ever..... he atnds with his shoulders pinched... this is a known fact..... everyone knows coleman in reality is wide.....
but i fail to see how this has anything to do with a thread discussing phils width or lack .....
i have more pics i can post from that event but i wont belabour a point....
what i will say is... if phil disnt have those arms... 90% of people on his bandwagon would hop off....
because when you look past the arms.... well....
anyway... Ill leave you to it
meso
its funny, I've seen some guys develop that "pinched shoulder posture..
And they walk with a rocking motion, and their belly pushed out.
-
what does an over the hill retired coleman have to do with .. phil heath being narrow??? ??? ??? ??? ???
This is Mr olympia now
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
ill tell you now if heath showed up at that expo... in a tshirt arms covered no one would dream he was mr o the worlds most impressive and best physique.... it was cold and phil was the one of the only pro guys in a tank vest
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
BRO ARE YOU HIGH OR SOMETHING? Can you not see that the girl is waaaaaaaaaaaaay closer to the camera, Kovaks can be sitting on that stool and we wouldn`t see him. woooooooooooooooooosh
-
I just saw Phil Heath about 7 hours ago and shook his hand at the LA fitness expo, I saw jay cutler last year.... Cutler last year was out of the Olympia .... Cutler looked more impressive to me
Jay Cutler was impressive in person, he was legit bodybuilder badass
Phil didn't look very impressive in his basketball shorts and t-shirt, Phil is known to cruise during the offseason maybe during Olympia training he looks more massive ???
Here is a pic off instagram I found from today's LA Fitness Expo, no that's not me, maybe tito24 maybe
(http://distilleryimage7.s3.amazonaws.com/7d13dfaa629911e2bc0822000a1f9737_7.jpg)
-
a few more i found of people posted on instagram
(http://distilleryimage7.s3.amazonaws.com/cdf6755462a311e2b07922000a1fbd9b_7.jpg)
(http://distilleryimage6.s3.amazonaws.com/258cd742629d11e2877022000a9f1278_7.jpg)
(http://distilleryimage8.s3.amazonaws.com/bc63eb38627f11e2b7ab22000a1f90e7_7.jpg)
-
I just saw Phil Heath about 7 hours ago and shook his hand at the LA fitness expo, I saw jay cutler last year.... Cutler last year was out if Olympia .... Cutler looked more impressive to me
Jay Cutler was impressive in person, he was legit bodybuilder badass
Phil didn't look very impressive in his basketball shorts and t-shirt, Phil is known to cruise during the offseason maybe during Olympia training he looks more massive ???
Here is a pic off instagram I found from today's LA Fitness Expo, no that's not me, maybe tito24 maybe
(http://distilleryimage7.s3.amazonaws.com/7d13dfaa629911e2bc0822000a1f9737_7.jpg)
Yeah, that's "cruising Phil" not "Olympia Phil".
-
nice guy , and friendly phil is ... good dude, would buy a T-shirt from him,
https://zk964.infusionsoft.com/app/storeFront/showProductDetail?productId=89 (https://zk964.infusionsoft.com/app/storeFront/showProductDetail?productId=89)
(https://d1yoaun8syyxxt.cloudfront.net/zk964-vnzmokfzyvdzlioeymrjxgnhcmuhesej-v2)
-
che have you ever seen phil in person?? And its well known branch is one of the most narrow guys in bodybuilding nothing new..
-
jay is not wide either
-
What is unique about Phil Heath is that his forearms are bigger than most people's upper arms, and bigger than many bber's upper arms (even when he is "cruising").
-
yes i give him that, but other than his forearms hes just another bodybuilder.
-
BRO ARE YOU HIGH OR SOMETHING? Can you not see that the girl is waaaaaaaaaaaaay closer to the camera, Kovaks can be sitting on that stool and we wouldn`t see him. woooooooooooooooooosh
no phil was sitting behind the desk the girl was directly in front not far in front ... and no a wider bodybuilder wouldnt be completlety shadowed like that....
-
Ronnie is a freak. enough said. thats why he won 8 of them.
-
what does an over the hill retired coleman have to do with .. phil heath being narrow??? ??? ??? ??? ???
This is Mr olympia now
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
ill tell you now if heath showed up at that expo... in a tshirt arms covered no one would dream he was mr o the worlds most impressive and best physique.... it was cold and phil was the one of the only pro guys in a tank vest
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/BE8023D1-A56A-44AE-B9C5-50C409B0B63E-157-00000007D17C9F2F.jpg)
haha this pic says it all! narrow as fuck....che's ok but he's off his rocker on this one. dude is as narrow as they come
-
he is not crusing, he is plain narrow, and even more narrow dieted down
-
no phil was sitting behind the desk the girl was directly in front not far in front ... and no a wider bodybuilder wouldnt be completlety shadowed like that....
The black male model is a cardboard cut out, correct?
-
this just in, bodybuilders are usually small people to start out with
-
this just in, bodybuilders are usually small people to start out with
lol good point
-
this just in, bodybuilders are usually small people to start out with
TBH it is to someones advantage on stage to have a small bone structure. Smaller bone structures make winning physiques.
-
NARROW as it gets but still a worthy Olympia
-
(http://distilleryimage4.s3.amazonaws.com/f8666380639811e2af9822000a1f9331_7.jpg)
(http://distilleryimage7.s3.amazonaws.com/5c1498bc635711e28e5722000a9f195f_7.jpg)
(http://distilleryimage3.s3.amazonaws.com/5d31d4d6636511e2974122000a9e2969_7.jpg)
(http://distilleryimage0.s3.amazonaws.com/b074b2b662b211e2996722000a9f18fe_7.jpg)
-
big fat nose?
-
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/339dfdd8637011e2a1bd22000a9f1361_7_zpscee8dbb0.jpg)
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/f8666380639811e2af9822000a1f9331_7_zps9b0739d5.jpg)
(good arms and forearms)
(http://i6.photobucket.com/albums/y225/lucas78/fw0l79_zps62087e8f.jpg)
:-\
-
just to add
(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=455456.0;attach=501365;image)
-
compared with some of the fbbers with great structure even kai looks narrow.
(http://i1123.photobucket.com/albums/l542/criscolumbus/758681159_424280770962562_958425962_n_123_1048lo_zps70eb9a6b.jpg)
AFAIK you cant really change significantly the span of your clavicles even with GH so guys that were narrow when skinny can only become wider with delt growth but there are limits for that.