I will admit that in the front relaxed, and front double biceps pose Jay Cutler's waist is MASSIVE, he has not V-Taper in these poses what so ever. But he kills, slaughters, a lot of these dude's from back shots like the back double biceps and lat spread. He came in pretty good condition, pretty full and his asymmetry should be balanced by his size and thickness.
Just like you BASh Cutler for lacking a small waist you could just as easily bash Dexter for being smaller and having extremely high lat insertions, yet you rarely hear anyone talk about that. Symmetry is extremely important but so is size, Cutler lacks a small waist (symmetry) and Dexter lacks (size) which makes them even to judge fairly