Frank McGrath or Arnold?

[Matt C]

Which physique do you prefer?

Please try not to let your biases prevent you from objectively judging the physiques in question here.

This IS a serious question.  Arnold's reputation shouldn't play a role in determining who has the more competitive physique.

[body88]

Arnold...



Why did you use the pictures you did for Arnold? Those look to be about the best shots of Frank I have ever seen. Those are def not pictures that show Arnold in his best shape.

[davidpaul]

steven berkoff owns them both,

and hes a way better actor than arnold could ever be.

[NeoSeminole]

Frank no doubt

[GoneAway]

Both have amazing physiques. Hard to say who's more competitive.

[alexxx]

Standarts and drugs have changed since Arnold ruled the bodybuilding world. Now a guy that would win 30 years ago can barely get to the Olympia. But nonetheless Arnold would stay on top could he compete today.

[Zach Trowbridge]

This picture is phenomenal.  Great taper for a guy of his size.

[logical?]

Frank. Better tris, delts, waistline imho.

[KTMckay]

Arnold is thee bodybuilding god.

[body88]

Better pictures since the first ones suck shit.

[KTMckay]

Heres some more of the legend himself

[logical?]

Heres some more of the legend himself

Cool pics.

Now all you need to do is post the best pics of Frank so we can have a balanced comparison.

[KTMckay]

heres some pics i dont see often..

[KTMckay]

 

[KTMckay]

If i had a goal for arm size this would be it.

[MisterMagoo]

frank. arnold had some poses he looked amazing in, but some he didn't look good in at all. mcgrath, though small, is more complete. and you can all just cram it if you're going to respond with "i guess that's why he won seven olympias you're an idiot lol" and whatnot.

[NeoSeminole]

frank. arnold had some poses he looked amazing in, but some he didn't look good in at all. mcgrath, though small, is more complete. and you can all just cram it if you're going to respond with "i guess that's why he won seven olympias you're an idiot lol" and whatnot.

exactly, bodybuilding today is not like it was 40 yrs ago. You cannot win today with only the front double biceps, side chest, and most muscular.

[KTMckay]

exactly, bodybuilding today is not like it was 40 yrs ago. You cannot win today with only the front double biceps, side chest, and most muscular.

Youre fool ths is Arnold Not some 6th tier. think straight

[logical?]

Youre fool ths is Arnold Not some 6th tier. think straight

Arnold was Arnold, 30 years ago. Arnold would be some 6th tier today, if that.

[Bast175]

frank hasn't won anything

[NeoSeminole]

Arnold was Arnold, 30 years ago. Arnold would be some 6th tier today, if that.

that was my point. I'm not really sure why he called me a fool. Arnold was great for his time, but he's too small and imbalanced to compete with today's top pros. Arnold is like a lighter version of Gunter (with even smaller legs). How many shows has Gunter won?

[canadaphiliac]

The only picture where Arnold looks better is the side chest because way back in the day they, being the collective of competetive bodybuilders at that time, posed it differently in a way which I feel is much better than how they do today.

[Bast175]

that was my point. I'm not really sure why he called me a fool. Arnold was great for his time, but he's too small and imbalanced to compete with today's top pros. Arnold is like a lighter version of Gunter (with even smaller legs). How many shows has Gunter won?

Not really.  Arnold had standout biceps and chest.

[Dorian01]

Someone's actually telling the truth about Arnold's beach physique. This won't go well.

[Bast175]

Someone's actually telling the truth about Arnold's beach physique. This won't go well.

yea all the guys at the beach look like this: