Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums

Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: Army of One on March 24, 2014, 07:40:16 PM

Title: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 24, 2014, 07:40:16 PM
In all sports Ive watched. I can only think of one athlete who was simply godlike in his abilities, and literally surpassed his hype, and that's Michael Jordan.Whenever his team had the equal or best record in the playoffs, they won.Jordan raised his scoring in the playoffs and took his game to next level, remaining the best u til he retired from the bulls.

bolt has been disappointing since his world record, seemingly coasting on natural abilities

Federer has lost his advantage whenever nadal , murray and dkokovic raised their game

Don't know enough about Gretzky , but from what I've read a peak Lemoiux was just as good

Babe Ruth played with stiffs, some fat dude in the twenties being the best, come on

Anyone who is being real watching football (soccer) knows its way too much of a team game for one player to dominate, sans short spells from pele, maradonna and messi

Bubka was dominant so I read,maybe someone can clarify but its a simple sport of planting a pole and launching, sure it's difficult to attain but I can see why someone can master it and be dominant

F1 is all down to the car

Ali lost too many times to make a case, same with Robinson
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Icelord on March 24, 2014, 07:43:20 PM
Kobe and LeBron also lived up the hype.

Tiger Woods too other than during his post-divorce slump.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: AlphaMaleDawg on March 24, 2014, 07:43:57 PM
Your post is a complete joke. Ever heard of Lebron James, or is he also a failure?
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Grape Ape on March 24, 2014, 07:49:14 PM
Mike Trout is off to an incredible start.

And yeah, Woods and Lebron.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: doison on March 24, 2014, 07:50:47 PM
You could probably add Tommy Brookens from the '84 Detroit Tigers to that list
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 24, 2014, 07:55:33 PM
Kobe and LeBron also lived up the hype.

Tiger Woods too other than during his post-divorce slump.

Lol no, Lebron got to the finals then average like 20 ppg on 35% against the spurs and lost.the next time he got to the finals he averaged around 18ppg on 35% getting shut down by a 40 yr old Jason Kidd  and scrub Stephenson and lost again.He needed to team with up with 2 other first options in free agency to win anything.Going 2-2 in NBA finals against teams that arnt even classed as legendary is shit.

Kobe?these are the players Kobe has played with in his career, and he only has 5 titles?

Nash\van exel\gary Payton
Eddie jones\ Mitch Richmond
Lamar odom\ Glenn rice\antwan Jamison \artest\ariza
Malone\gasol\rodman\horry\horace grant
Shaq\howard\bynum

the lakers have underachieved with all the talent they brought in, and thats largely due to Bryant completely sucking balls when his game isn't on,  if he isn't scoring then he is a non factor.give a 26+ old Jordan those teammates until he retires and its 8+ championships.If Kobe was on the bucks he'd just be another dominique Wilkins.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: el numero uno on March 24, 2014, 07:56:34 PM
Ronnie Coleman was pretty close, too bad he couldn't break Lee Haney's record.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Icelord on March 24, 2014, 07:57:02 PM
Lol no, Lebron got to the finals then average like 20 ppg on 35% against the spurs and lost.the next time he got to the finals he averaged around 18ppg on 35% getting shut down by a 40 yr old Jason Kidd  and scrub Stephenson.Going 2-2 in NBA finals against teams that arnt even classed as legendary is shit.

Kobe?these are the players Kobe has played with in his career, and he only has 5 titles?

Nash\van exel\gary Payton
Eddie jones\ Mitch Richmond
Lamar odom\ Glenn rice\antwan Jamison \artest\ariza
Malone\gasol\rodman\horry\horace grant
Shaq\howard\bynum

the lakers have underachieved with all the talent they brought in, and thats largely due to Bryant completely sucking balls when his game isn't on,  if he isn't scoring then he is a non factor.give a 26+ old Jordan those teammates until he retires and its 8+ championships.If Kobe was on the bucks he'd just be another dominique Wilkins.
Lebron was recruited out of high school and is one of the highest paid and best-performing athletes in the NBA, witness his being bought out from one team to another. Kobe held the Lakers afloat as a one man tour de force. Focusing on one bad season or the fact that some other guy from 20 years ago had more trophies is basically a red herring.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: beakdoctor on March 24, 2014, 07:57:54 PM

I would say Barry Sanders was one of the best atheletes I ever saw.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Red Hook on March 24, 2014, 08:09:37 PM
Jordan wasnt what you make him out to be you cant compare individual sports with team sports jordan had the best team around him that helps a lot.


What the fuck are you talking about?

Here is a list of Jordan's teammates, tell anybody that belongs as a starter on any other team except pippin?  ::)

http://www.michaeljordansworld.com/teammates.htm

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: polychronopolous on March 24, 2014, 08:11:37 PM
Sugar Ray Robinson
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Rambone on March 24, 2014, 08:19:12 PM
Bo knows

(http://www.vpfunworld.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/bo.jpg)
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: BB on March 24, 2014, 08:20:39 PM
I think a case could still be made for Ali, if we acknowledge that he simply fought past his prime, all of the real loses came in a narrow block when he was well up in boxing years.

Robinson is well deserving of his status too, simply because of the era and number of fights. There are huge blocks of time were he was fighting decent fighters literally every week or two, and manages around a 86% victor rate in those fights, Also like Ali, the majority of the losses come late in  boxing life (mainly in 1965), which was his 25th year in boxing.

Marciano is certainly legacy worthy too.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Bevo on March 24, 2014, 08:22:00 PM
Never cared about Jordan nor his shoes that Hebrews and stupid white guys go crazy after
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 24, 2014, 08:46:30 PM

What the fuck are you talking about?

Here is a list of Jordan's teammates, tell anybody that belongs as a starter on any other team except pippin?  ::)

http://www.michaeljordansworld.com/teammates.htm



This.On an individual talent basis Kobes teammates are about 1000 leagues above Jordans.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: ismoseppo on March 24, 2014, 08:48:32 PM
for a skinny rag doll of a guy Gretzky accomplished amazing things
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 24, 2014, 08:50:15 PM
for a skinny rag doll of a guy Gretzky accomplished amazing things

Don't know too much about him, how many times was he MVP?how many championships?was he far and away the best player in the league for 10+ years?
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: XFACTOR on March 24, 2014, 08:54:24 PM
Tom Brady. Drafter very low nobody expected much, I'd say he's a good example.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: polychronopolous on March 24, 2014, 08:55:09 PM
for a skinny rag doll of a guy Gretzky accomplished amazing things

No doubt about it.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: visualizeperfection on March 24, 2014, 08:59:09 PM
Mike Trout is off to an incredible start.

And yeah, Woods and Lebron.


Yes sir!

angels baseball ftw
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: thulsaDOOM210 on March 24, 2014, 09:05:35 PM
Bo knows

(http://www.vpfunworld.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/bo.jpg)

The Prostars Trifecta of Jordan, Jackson and Gretzky all lived up to all the hype.  ;)
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Bear232 on March 24, 2014, 09:15:58 PM




Walter payton
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: knny187 on March 24, 2014, 09:18:35 PM
A young Tyson under Rooney and D'Amato was impressive.

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Coach is Back! on March 24, 2014, 09:39:58 PM
Bo knows

(http://www.vpfunworld.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/bo.jpg)

Yup, beat me too it.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: thulsaDOOM210 on March 24, 2014, 10:15:40 PM
A young Tyson under Rooney and D'Amato was impressive.



Whoah!! Nostalgia setting in! Good to see ya runnin it back man and yes, I'm thinkin there never was a man more deserving of the phenom moniker. Melted confidence with his entrance and stare down. Took manhood with his skills......AS A TEEN!!
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Oggie Oglethorpe on March 24, 2014, 11:15:12 PM
Don't know too much about him, how many times was he MVP?how many championships?was he far and away the best player in the league for 10+ years?

Wayne Gretzky was the most dominant player in any team sport ever. Far more dominant than Jordan.

Mario Lemieux was not better than WG, and Bobby Orr is the second greatest hockey player ever.

Gretzky has set scoring records that (without a major rule change) will never be broken.

He has more assists than the next person in the All-Time scoring list has total points.

In his prime that guy didn't put up nice scoring numbers...he put up numbers that looked like bowling averages. Yet he was about 5'-11" and 165 lbs soaking wet.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 25, 2014, 04:20:50 AM
Almost impossible to compare team players. It took Jordan a good number of years to win a title and he certainly didn't do it on his own. The simple fact of having Jackson on the bench was already a big plus. Individual sports: sure, Bubka was dominant but so has been Edwin Moses, Abebe Bikila and a bunch of others. I'd have to go with Ray Sugar Robinson. His record at some point was 127W-1L-2D. Unreal and those were tough fighters back then, fighting every other week.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: _aj_ on March 25, 2014, 04:25:46 AM
for a skinny rag doll of a guy Gretzky accomplished amazing things

Gretzky looked like he was playing around with the rest of the NHL. His dominance was unparalleled in sport, IMHO.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Grape Ape on March 25, 2014, 04:27:40 AM
Tom Brady. Drafter very low nobody expected much, I'd say he's a good example.

He's not a good example - By your ow  definition he didn't have any hype.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: visualizeperfection on March 25, 2014, 04:29:43 AM
He's not a good example - By your ow  definition he didn't have any hype.

I guess he surpassed the very limited hype.

xfactor is kind of right.

but not on purpose.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Grape Ape on March 25, 2014, 04:31:30 AM
Lol no, Lebron got to the finals then average like 20 ppg on 35% against the spurs and lost.the next time he got to the finals he averaged around 18ppg on 35% getting shut down by a 40 yr old Jason Kidd  and scrub Stephenson and lost again.He needed to team with up with 2 other first options in free agency to win anything.Going 2-2 in NBA finals against teams that arnt even classed as legendary is shit.

Kobe?these are the players Kobe has played with in his career, and he only has 5 titles?



This is a ridiculous argument.  Lebron was hyped as being one of the potentiallyf greatest players ever.   And now he is considered the best in the league and on his way to being one of the best ever.  Of course he's living up to the hype.  Dissecting individual games or putting you own negative context on it doesn't change that.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Grape Ape on March 25, 2014, 04:32:54 AM
I guess he surpassed the very limited hype.

xfactor is kind of right.

but not on purpose.

He had zero pre NFL hype.  If he threw one career TD he would have surpassed it.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: visualizeperfection on March 25, 2014, 04:34:12 AM
He had zero pre NFL hype.  If he threw one career TD he would have surpassed it.

I did mention it was very limited  :)

now the only thing bigger than his ego are the cock he routinely devours.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: BigCyp on March 25, 2014, 04:36:06 AM
English guys who know too much about American sports are very suspicious individuals.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: doison on March 25, 2014, 04:37:38 AM
Wayne Gretzky was the most dominant player in any team sport ever. Far more dominant than Jordan.

Mario Lemieux was not better than WG, and Bobby Orr is the second greatest hockey player ever.

Gretzky has set scoring records that (without a major rule change) will never be broken.

He has more assists than the next person in the All-Time scoring list has total points.

In his prime that guy didn't put up nice scoring numbers...he put up numbers that looked like bowling averages. Yet he was about 5'-11" and 165 lbs soaking wet.

He was given the nickname of the "great one" at age 9....
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: visualizeperfection on March 25, 2014, 04:39:22 AM
English guys who know too much about American sports are very suspicious individuals.

Football is the Universe's sport.

The real football btw, the American variety  :)

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 25, 2014, 04:41:44 AM
English guys who know too much about American sports are very suspicious individuals.

Are you implying that Getbig might be hosting a few chaps who think as themselves as brutally heterosexual and are quick to switch from a Premier League game to an NBA one 'cause those scantily clad ballers play a much more masculine sport?
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: gee38 on March 25, 2014, 05:04:47 AM
Bolt has done this with ease

as has Phil 'The Power' Taylor

 ;D
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: BigCyp on March 25, 2014, 05:15:41 AM
Football is the Universe's sport.

The real football btw, the American variety  :)



Maybe my friend, but Army of One doesn't just 'happen' upon the sports that are filled with 90% big black men with very loose shorts
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Melkor on March 25, 2014, 05:15:51 AM
Wayne Gretzky - obvious
Walter Payton - same, never underperformed
Leo Messi has surpassed the hype (remember when he first arrived on the scene people thought he would be great - now, year in year out he continues to amaze)
Cristiano Ronaldo - as much as I don't like him, nobody ever thought he would surpass the initial hype he got when he joined Man Utd
Mike Tyson - I'm his biggest fan (during that early run he had, best heavyweight ever) BUT he didn't live up to the hype. He was supposed to become the most successful boxer of all time but he didn't, his career effectively ended after the Michael Spinks fight.

What about those who never lived up to the hype?
Braylon Edwards? Ryan Leaf? Francis Jeffers? Freddy Adu?
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: BigCyp on March 25, 2014, 05:16:48 AM
Bolt has done this with ease

as has Phil 'The Power' Taylor

 ;D

Hahaha yes The Power is a legend

Not too sure about the number of kisses Adrian The Jackpot Lewis is giving out in between sets though  :-X
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Quickerblade on March 25, 2014, 05:17:17 AM
Lol no, Lebron got to the finals then average like 20 ppg on 35% against the spurs and lost.the next time he got to the finals he averaged around 18ppg on 35% getting shut down by a 40 yr old Jason Kidd  and scrub Stephenson and lost again.He needed to team with up with 2 other first options in free agency to win anything.Going 2-2 in NBA finals against teams that arnt even classed as legendary is shit.

Kobe?these are the players Kobe has played with in his career, and he only has 5 titles?

Nash\van exel\gary Payton
Eddie jones\ Mitch Richmond
Lamar odom\ Glenn rice\antwan Jamison \artest\ariza
Malone\gasol\rodman\horry\horace grant
Shaq\howard\bynum

the lakers have underachieved with all the talent they brought in, and thats largely due to Bryant completely sucking balls when his game isn't on,  if he isn't scoring then he is a non factor.give a 26+ old Jordan those teammates until he retires and its 8+ championships.If Kobe was on the bucks he'd just be another dominique Wilkins.

Great post. I agree with most of it. I cannot comment on Lebron yet, his not even 30 yet.
But Kobe being another Dominique Wilkins is spot on.

Jordan was definitely a freak, huge ball hog too, I remember they used to air Chicago bull games on Australian TV, I would watch the full game, then you realise the NBA is a great marketing machine, they put together a 50 second highlight reel of Jordan doing circus shots, buzzer beaters, dunks in traffic and swishing 3's from 33 feet.
Then you watch the full game and you see he was stoppable,

 I remember Vernon Maxwell stopping him one on one, he just demanded the ball enough to keep trying...if that was another player they would be benched. (same as Kobe)
But Jordan was amazing, 6 championships proves that.

Lebron is timid, if he just fucked off twitter and focused on being a on being great he could score 50 a game, physically his amazing. Lebron is not as selfish as Jordan, if he was, I think we would see a better player.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 25, 2014, 05:19:22 AM

Leo Messi has surpassed the hype (remember when he first arrived on the scene people thought he would be great - now, year in year out he continues to amaze)


Messi hasn't surpassed the hype somehow. He's been contending for "the best player ever title" for a few years now. Yet, he has underperformed with the Argentina team for now.
If he doesn't win a world cup before he retires, this will stick.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: visualizeperfection on March 25, 2014, 05:23:47 AM
Maybe my friend, but Army of One doesn't just 'happen' upon the sports that are filled with 90% big black men with very loose shorts

All I'm trying to say is that any sport with a median gear use that is shy of a gram a week isn't really a sport at all.


Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Quickerblade on March 25, 2014, 05:24:52 AM
Wayne Gretzky - obvious
Walter Payton - same, never underperformed
Leo Messi has surpassed the hype (remember when he first arrived on the scene people thought he would be great - now, year in year out he continues to amaze)
Cristiano Ronaldo - as much as I don't like him, nobody ever thought he would surpass the initial hype he got when he joined Man Utd
Mike Tyson - I'm his biggest fan (during that early run he had, best heavyweight ever) BUT he didn't live up to the hype. He was supposed to become the most successful boxer of all time but he didn't, his career effectively ended after the Michael Spinks fight.

What about those who never lived up to the hype?
Braylon Edwards? Ryan Leaf? Francis Jeffers? Freddy Adu?
Mike Tyson is so lucky his fights were filmed.
he was thermo-nuclear but his prime was short lived, but it was against bums and no names. Marketing machine at its best.
Mike tysons name will outlast Floyd mayweathers name, Floyd's fight are boring, Tyson would have boring fights too then he would deliver that knockout punch everybody was waiting for. you could make a highlight reel of Derrick Coleman, doing massive dunks, hitting 3's , blocking shots, post moves, hook shots and it would make you believe he was the best power forward ever.. he was not even top 20. Its all about highlight reels.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: snx on March 25, 2014, 06:12:05 AM
No one will ever touch Gretzky. He is as dominant (relative to any peer who played in the NHL) as you will find in the big 4 sports.

Lemieux had one year (and only one year) where he started sniffing Gretzky numbers. Gretzky holds records for most goals in a season, most assists in a season, and is the only man to have scored over 200 pts in a season (he did it 4 times).

Gretzky has more career assists than anyone else has career points.

Gretzky was the fastest man to 1000 points. He's also the second fastest man to score 1000 points again (and no one else has ever scored 2000 points).

He was easily the most dominant hockey player of all time. No one even comes close. He was hyped as a kid, for sure. But no one would have ever picked that kind of sheer dominance.

You could say his teammates in Edmonton made him great (they surely did....Coffey, Fuhr, Messier, Anderson, Kurri....all HOF'ers). But then, one need only look at what Gretzky did for Bernie Nicholls in L.A. to see that truly, he made everyone around him great. He took the Kings, a perennial basement dwelling team that was forgotten after the Flames/Oilers rivalries in the Smythe division at the time, and made them true contenders for the cup.

Gretzky is the single greatest and most dominant athlete the big four sports have ever seen.

Ruth and Bonds were great, but not THAT much greater than their peers, when you compare Gretzky to Lemieux or Orr (the only two hockey players one might think to compare to Gretzky). Gherig, Foxx, Cobb, and Williams...all very dominant players who could have laid claim to being GOATS. And even if you don't agree with me on the runners-up (Williams, Gherig, etc....), you can at least agree that Bonds was a modern-day Ruth (statistically speaking) and therefore, Ruth truly can't be a run-away, far-and-away GOAT, because Bond's modern-day numbers are so close to what Ruth did. So clearly, Ruth is not the run-away dominant force in baseball, because Bonds is right there with him.

You could say Jordan was great (and he certainly was), but was he that much better than Wilt Chamberlain? I don't think so. Chamberlain was truly a masterfully dominant force in the NBA without peer...arguments could be made that he was more dominant than Jordan during his time period, but I'll let basketball afficianados argue that.

In football, it's so tough to argue sheer dominance due to the very selective nature of each position and how much each position is allowed to impact all parts of a game. If we only looked at skill positions, I would say Jerry Rice is the most dominant player of all time at his position. He is so many light years ahead of the Chris Carters, Marvin Harrisons and Tim Browns of the world. There has never been a skill position in football that has had its record books so dominantly re-written, when we look at what Jerry Rice did.


So, in my humble opinion, there have been 2 truly game-changing players in the big 4 sports that have been supremely dominant over their peer group so as to truly be called the greatest of all time:

1. Wayne Gretzky
2. Jerry Rice


I would not put Jordan in that elite two-some. Wilt Chamberlain lays too great a claim to being basketball's GOAT, in my opinion, to count Jordan as being far and away the most dominant player in his sport, the way Gretzky and Jerry Rice were.

My two cents. I'm sure I'll get lit up here!
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Quickerblade on March 25, 2014, 06:28:29 AM


You could say Jordan was great (and he certainly was), but was he that much better than Wilt Chamberlain? I don't think so. Chamberlain was truly a masterfully dominant force in the NBA without peer...arguments could be made that he was more dominant than Jordan during his time period, but I'll let basketball afficianados argue that.



I would not put Jordan in that elite two-some. Wilt Chamberlain lays too great a claim to being basketball's GOAT, in my opinion, to count Jordan as being far and away the most dominant player in his sport, the way Gretzky and Jerry Rice were.

My two cents. I'm sure I'll get lit up here!

I wont light you up, but have to disagree.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: polychronopolous on March 25, 2014, 06:30:38 AM
No one will ever touch Gretzky. He is as dominant (relative to any peer who played in the NHL) as you will find in the big 4 sports.

Lemieux had one year (and only one year) where he started sniffing Gretzky numbers. Gretzky holds records for most goals in a season, most assists in a season, and is the only man to have scored over 200 pts in a season (he did it 4 times).

Gretzky has more career assists than anyone else has career points.

Gretzky was the fastest man to 1000 points. He's also the second fastest man to score 1000 points again (and no one else has ever scored 2000 points).

He was easily the most dominant hockey player of all time. No one even comes close. He was hyped as a kid, for sure. But no one would have ever picked that kind of sheer dominance.

You could say his teammates in Edmonton made him great (they surely did....Coffey, Fuhr, Messier, Anderson, Kurri....all HOF'ers). But then, one need only look at what Gretzky did for Bernie Nicholls in L.A. to see that truly, he made everyone around him great. He took the Kings, a perennial basement dwelling team that was forgotten after the Flames/Oilers rivalries in the Smythe division at the time, and made them true contenders for the cup.

Gretzky is the single greatest and most dominant athlete the big four sports have ever seen.

Ruth and Bonds were great, but not THAT much greater than their peers, when you compare Gretzky to Lemieux or Orr (the only two hockey players one might think to compare to Gretzky). Gherig, Foxx, Cobb, and Williams...all very dominant players who could have laid claim to being GOATS. And even if you don't agree with me on the runners-up (Williams, Gherig, etc....), you can at least agree that Bonds was a modern-day Ruth (statistically speaking) and therefore, Ruth truly can't be a run-away, far-and-away GOAT, because Bond's modern-day numbers are so close to what Ruth did. So clearly, Ruth is not the run-away dominant force in baseball, because Bonds is right there with him.

You could say Jordan was great (and he certainly was), but was he that much better than Wilt Chamberlain? I don't think so. Chamberlain was truly a masterfully dominant force in the NBA without peer...arguments could be made that he was more dominant than Jordan during his time period, but I'll let basketball afficianados argue that.

In football, it's so tough to argue sheer dominance due to the very selective nature of each position and how much each position is allowed to impact all parts of a game. If we only looked at skill positions, I would say Jerry Rice is the most dominant player of all time at his position. He is so many light years ahead of the Chris Carters, Marvin Harrisons and Tim Browns of the world. There has never been a skill position in football that has had its record books so dominantly re-written, when we look at what Jerry Rice did.


So, in my humble opinion, there have been 2 truly game-changing players in the big 4 sports that have been supremely dominant over their peer group so as to truly be called the greatest of all time:

1. Wayne Gretzky
2. Jerry Rice


I would not put Jordan in that elite two-some. Wilt Chamberlain lays too great a claim to being basketball's GOAT, in my opinion, to count Jordan as being far and away the most dominant player in his sport, the way Gretzky and Jerry Rice were.

My two cents. I'm sure I'll get lit up here!

As freaky as Gretzkys numbers are...

Babe Ruth's 90+ wins as a pitcher and 714 home runs is THE most unbreakable career stat in all of sports.

We'll all be dead and buried and nobody will ever have come close to it.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Voice of Doom on March 25, 2014, 06:48:17 AM
Jordan
Pele
Gretzky
Jackie Robinson
Tiger
Joe Montana
Payton
Klose
Ronaldo (Brazilian)
Zidane
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 25, 2014, 06:52:37 AM
Jordan
Pele
Gretzky
Jackie Robinson
Tiger
Joe Montana
Payton
Klose
Ronaldo (Brazilian)
Zidane

Zidane (and I'm French) was never that dominant. Not in the way Pelé or Maradona were and not even like prime time (before knee injuries) Ronaldo was.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: CalvinH on March 25, 2014, 06:52:42 AM
Lawrence Taylor you dimwits >:(

2nd choice in the draft and changed the game.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: polychronopolous on March 25, 2014, 07:02:22 AM
Lawrence Taylor you dimwits >:(

2nd choice in the draft and changed the game.

Overcame a Boston Crab submission hold and headbutt from the top ropes to beat Bam Bam Bigelow at Wrestlemania as well.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: SuperTed on March 25, 2014, 07:08:54 AM
English guys who know too much about American sports are very suspicious individuals.

I've noticed.
Army of Cum is apparently a Brit yet is alarmingly knowledgeable about American Sports.
Think we might have an undercover Yank in our mists. Possibly a spy. :o

Get him!! >:(

 ;D
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: BigCyp on March 25, 2014, 07:12:19 AM
I've noticed.
Army of Cum is apparently a Brit yet is alarmingly knowledgeable about American Sports.
Think we might have an undercover Yank in our mists. Possibly a spy. :o

Get him!! >:(

 ;D


Yes, he's a very suspicious individual to say the least.

When he used to post as db2341 years back, he came across as a Yank and never mentioned the U.K. at all, now he says he's from up the road to me?

Maybe he's trying to throw the authorities off the scent
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: El Diablo Blanco on March 25, 2014, 07:13:38 AM
Many have.

Jamarcus Russell
Greg Oden
Ryan Leaf
Samuel Dalambert
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: CalvinH on March 25, 2014, 07:17:47 AM
Overcame a Boston Crab submission hold and headbutt from the top ropes to beat Bam Bam Bigelow at Wrestlemania as well.


Lol ;D
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: snx on March 25, 2014, 07:19:15 AM
Many have.

Jamarcus Russell
Greg Oden
Ryan Leaf
Samuel Dalambert

You can add Tony Mandarich to that illustrious list.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: tom joad on March 25, 2014, 07:38:05 AM
Mike Trout is off to an incredible start.

Mike Trout is, and will continue to be, the man.

I was curious about his hype so I see that Trout was drafted 25th overall in 2009 (with the Angels' compensation pick from the Yankees for NY signing Mark Teixeira ... I hope Trout can go his whole career without wearing Yankee pinstripes haha.)

Before the 2010 season, Trout was considered the Angels' 3rd best prospect and 85th in all of baseball by Baseball America.  He climbed to the top of the prospects list months later.

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: El Diablo Blanco on March 25, 2014, 07:39:36 AM
Mike Trout is, and will continue to be, the man.

I was curious about his hype so I looked this up ...

Trout was drafted 25th overall in 2009 ... with the Angels' compensation pick from the Yankees for NY signing Mark Teixeira ... I hope Trout can go his whole career without wearing Yankee pinstripes haha.

Before the 2010 season, Trout was considered the Angels' 3rd best prospect and 85th in all of baseball by Baseball America.  He climbed to the top of the prospects list months later.



Yet the money given to Hamilton and Pujols who is a liar about his true age will make it hard for the Angels to give Trout what he's worth on the market.
Pujols is closer to 40 but claims to be in his early 30's.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: tom joad on March 25, 2014, 08:10:15 AM
Yet the money given to Hamilton and Pujols who is a liar about his true age will make it hard for the Angels to give Trout what he's worth on the market.
Pujols is closer to 40 but claims to be in his early 30's.

also, Pujols probably went off the sauce after signing his big contract with the Angels.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: funk51 on March 25, 2014, 08:14:57 AM
In all sports Ive watched. I can only think of one athlete who was simply godlike in his abilities, and literally surpassed his hype, and that's Michael Jordan.Whenever his team had the equal or best record in the playoffs, they won.Jordan raised his scoring in the playoffs and took his game to next level, remaining the best u til he retired from the bulls.

bolt has been disappointing since his world record, seemingly coasting on natural abilities

Federer has lost his advantage whenever nadal , murray and dkokovic raised their game

Don't know enough about Gretzky , but from what I've read a peak Lemoiux was just as good

Babe Ruth played with stiffs, some fat dude in the twenties being the best, come on

Anyone who is being real watching football (soccer) knows its way too much of a team game for one player to dominate, sans short spells from pele, maradonna and messi

Bubka was dominant so I read,maybe someone can clarify but its a simple sport of planting a pole and launching, sure it's difficult to attain but I can see why someone can master it and be dominant

F1 is all down to the car

Ali lost too many times to make a case, same with Robinson
babe ruth, jimmy brown, wilt chamberlain,oscar robertson,barry bonds,hank aaron, willie mays, jimmy foxx,derek jeter,yogi berra,bill russell just to name a few
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: SilverSpoon on March 25, 2014, 10:20:40 AM
How about Federer?
Eddy Merckx?
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Yanin on March 25, 2014, 10:24:28 AM
Money mayweather?
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: ESFitness on March 25, 2014, 11:03:36 AM
comparing kobe's era and jordans era is apples & oranges.

it's a different game now. all flash and no defense.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Hulkotron on March 25, 2014, 11:12:56 AM
Jordan didn't have a huge amount of hype actually.

He was a really good player in college but he wasn't "Michael Jordan" yet.  Nobody was predicting he would go on to be the best player in the history of the game. 
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 25, 2014, 11:13:43 AM
comparing kobe's era and jordans era is apples & oranges.

it's a different game now. all flash and no defense.

It actually started with Jordan's era and only got worst. Actually, it was the league's desire to protect Jordan and promote a more offense oriented approach that led them to  have refs whistling for nothing. They got tired of the Pistons winning the way they did. The pussification of the NBA started then.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Melkor on March 25, 2014, 01:01:28 PM
Messi hasn't surpassed the hype somehow. He's been contending for "the best player ever title" for a few years now. Yet, he has underperformed with the Argentina team for now.
If he doesn't win a world cup before he retires, this will stick.

Yeah that's a good point I never really think of Messi and Argentina, he should've just played for Spain...

But at the same time, I've found that international football has become very strange in the last ten years or so. Not sure what it is but players just don't seem to perform for their countries like they do their club (could be the ridiculous wages). There have been no stand out players at the last few major tournaments - not since Ronaldo in 2002 anyway. Messi like you mentioned is an example but also Cristiano Ronaldo, Ronaldinho when he was on form years ago never played well at world cups. Teams like France, Italy, Argentina, Brazil have just disappeared.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: UPINTHEMGUTS on March 25, 2014, 01:06:02 PM
Jordan didn't have a huge amount of hype actually.

He was a really good player in college but he wasn't "Michael Jordan" yet.  Nobody was predicting he would go on to be the best player in the history of the game. 

Nobody can predict that while a player is in college. But make no mistake, Jordan had a lot of hype. He was the 3rd pick in the draft. After a handful of games, he was the most popular player in the NBA as a rookie. He was so good and popular that many NBA veterans were jealous of him. A lot of players phased him out during his first all star game and refused to pass him the ball.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: kh300 on March 25, 2014, 01:08:19 PM
Bo Jackson. Jordan was given a gift to play single A baseball. He sucked dick.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Hulkotron on March 25, 2014, 01:17:04 PM
Nobody can predict that while a player is in college. But make no mistake, Jordan had a lot of hype. He was the 3rd pick in the draft. After a handful of games, he was the most popular player in the NBA as a rookie. He was so good and popular that many NBA veterans were jealous of him. A lot of players phased him out during his first all star game and refused to pass him the ball.

You can't say "after a handful of games, he was the most popular player in the NBA as a rookie" and call it hype. He was popular early on because it was quite evident he was the most exciting and maybe already most talented player in the league.  That's not hype, that's just playing good.  He had no more hype coming into the league than any other high draft pick gets every year, outside of LeBron and perhaps Wilt Chamberlain (I wasn't alive back then).
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: YngiweRhoads on March 25, 2014, 01:21:24 PM
(http://img2-3.timeinc.net/ew/dynamic/imgs/080227/semi-pro_l.jpg)
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Skeletor on March 25, 2014, 01:24:21 PM
Ayrton Senna
Sebastien Loeb
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: UPINTHEMGUTS on March 25, 2014, 01:37:11 PM
You can't say "after a handful of games, he was the most popular player in the NBA as a rookie" and call it hype. He was popular early on because it was quite evident he was the most exciting and maybe already most talented player in the league.  That's not hype, that's just playing good.  He had no more hype coming into the league than any other high draft pick gets every year, outside of LeBron and perhaps Wilt Chamberlain (I wasn't alive back then).

I just meant that it only took a small amount of games during his first year played before the mega hype began to build. I disagree about Jordan not having a lot of hype before he came to the NBA. There were expectations of his ability to translate well on the NBA level. He played three years at North Carolina and it was pretty apparent that he was special. Which makes drafting Sam Bowie ahead of him all the more laughable. But those two teams wanted big men instead of drafting a guard.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: SilverSpoon on March 25, 2014, 01:38:22 PM
I just meant that it only took a small amount of games during his first year played before the mega hype began to build. I disagree about Jordan not having a lot of hype before he came to the NBA. He played three years at North Carolina and it was pretty apparent that he was special. Which makes drafting Sam Bowie ahead of him all the more laughable.

The only person able to keep Michael Jordan under 20 points a game was Dean Smith.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: UPINTHEMGUTS on March 25, 2014, 01:42:30 PM
The only person able to keep Michael Jordan under 20 points a game was Dean Smith.

My feelings exactly. When he was a rookie in the NBA he was a one man show. He averaged over 42 minutes a game and put up crazy numbers. At NC he played on a stacked team with Worthy and Perkins and didn't play as many minutes. But it was apparent that when he played, he had special talent. If Dean Smith would've allowed Jordan to play outside of his scheme and create his own shot more, his hype would've exploded even more before the draft. And if the Bulls were drafting #1 that year, they still would've taken Jordan.

Just my opinion.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 25, 2014, 01:52:56 PM
You can't say "after a handful of games, he was the most popular player in the NBA as a rookie" and call it hype. He was popular early on because it was quite evident he was the most exciting and maybe already most talented player in the league.  That's not hype, that's just playing good.  He had no more hype coming into the league than any other high draft pick gets every year, outside of LeBron and perhaps Wilt Chamberlain (I wasn't alive back then).

What I don't get is why he didnt have more hype, or wasn't chosen before Bowie.watching the Olympic and pre Olympic warmups that summer before the draft, and the way he schooled the nba stars when the Olympic team played them for  warmups.watching it now it was clear his reflexes, 1st step,lateral speed, vertical jump, quickness, ball handling, jump shot etc were on another level, seriously he was almost catlike in his athletic abilities.How could anyone not see it?




Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: UPINTHEMGUTS on March 25, 2014, 01:58:46 PM
What I don't get is why he didnt have more hype, or wasn't chosen before Bowie.watching the Olympic and pre Olympic warmups that summer before the draft, and the way he schooled the nba stars when the Olympic team played them for  warmups.watching it now it was clear his reflexes, 1st step,lateral speed, vertical jump, quickness, ball handling, jump shot etc were on another level, seriously he was almost catlike in his athletic abilities.How could anyone not see it?






Chicago did. Like I already said, if there were drafting #1 that year they still would've taken Jordan with the first pick. But Houston and Portland needed and wanted big men, that's why they chose Olajuwan and Bowie ahead of him. Portland already had Clyde Drexler at shooting guard and wanted a big fella since Bill Walton didn't amount to shit because of injuries.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Melkor on March 25, 2014, 02:23:28 PM
Overcame a Boston Crab submission hold and headbutt from the top ropes to beat Bam Bam Bigelow at Wrestlemania as well.

 ;D Brilliant.

What's more, did it all while high as hell on crack.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Bevo on March 25, 2014, 03:01:19 PM
Maybe my friend, but Army of One doesn't just 'happen' upon the sports that are filled with 90% big black men with very loose shorts

 ;D
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Rome on March 25, 2014, 05:30:52 PM
There's a fella named Lebron James who is just as good if not better than his pre NBA hype. No one predicted his abilities as a passer and basically becoming 6' 8" point guard.
No one.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Hulkotron on March 25, 2014, 05:33:20 PM
There's a fella named Lebron James who is just as good if not better than his pre NBA hype. No one predicted his abilities as a passer and basically becoming 6' 8" point guard.
No one.

One of the smarter getbiggers
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: ChopperRider on March 25, 2014, 05:45:12 PM
There's a fella named Lebron James who is just as good if not better than his pre NBA hype. No one predicted his abilities as a passer and basically becoming 6' 8" point guard.
No one.

Magic Johnson was just as good as Lebron, neither rank as the greatest of all-time.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 25, 2014, 05:54:10 PM
There's a fella named Lebron James who is just as good if not better than his pre NBA hype. No one predicted his abilities as a passer and basically becoming 6' 8" point guard.
No one.

Since when?his passing was hyped before he even entered the nba, as was his ability to be able to play point gaurd.he bombed out of his first 2 finals appearances, and was only saved last year by a complete meltdown from the spurs in the final 30 seconds and a Ray Alan 3 pointer, otherwise he'd have been going home after game 6.Jordan never let it go to a game 7 in any of his 6/6 finals.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Oggie Oglethorpe on March 25, 2014, 06:16:59 PM
For a little perspective, a quick comparison can be made.

NHL record for goals prior to expansion = 58 by Bobby Hull
MLB record for home runs = 61 by Roger Maris

Generally a goal equates to a HR, even though baseball plays 162 games and hockey plays 82. For the two sports an assist and an RBI are comparable, except with baseball's longer schedule players will have twice as many RBI's as hockey players will.

NHL record for assists prior to Gretzky = 102 by Bobby Orr
MLB record for RBIs = 191 by Hack Wilson

Gretzky's records (92 goals in a season and 163 assists in a season) would roughly be the equivalent of a baseball player hitting 100 home runs and having 300 RBIs.

Think about that for a minute.

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: K-1 on March 25, 2014, 06:30:12 PM
I can honestly say I didn't think this guy would be any good at all. First player drafted out of high school since Darryl Dawkins in 1975. I felt he was too skinny and would get pushed around. He wasn't intimidated by anybody, kicked ass and took names at 18-19 yrs old vs all the big men.

(http://pic.pimg.tw/cyc0320/1317922028-306470777.jpg)
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Marty Champions on March 25, 2014, 06:34:03 PM
christian laettner back to back duke champion chips and olympic gold medal winner
will perdue 5 nba rings
danny ferry
Quin Snyder
michel jorden
kevin mchale
larry bird
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: no one on March 25, 2014, 06:35:47 PM

in my mind, the true greats can win games by themselves, consistently, time and again. they have elevated themselves to a point of ability that no one can forsee anyone following in their footsteps in that profession, or another talent of that level coming along in our lifetime.

1. wayne gretzky. wiki his name and see his body of work. some would argue that he was protected by the league. i grew up watching him. he wasnt protected by any one other than marty mcsorley. he made scoring goals and play making look effortless. you had to see him play to know what i mean. i dont even have the words to explain it. it was as if god himself touched the shoulder of gretzky. there will never be another wayne gretzky.

2. michael jordan. if you had a chance just to watch him play you'd know there will never EVER be another jordan. EVER.

3. mike tyson in his prime before cus died. he was a phenom. nobody will ever step in the ring with that much power, anger, speed and pure ability all in the same package. there will never be another prime mike tyson. he was so scary he admitted most of his fights were won before he even got in the ring. that is pure dominance.

4. ray lewis. some say LT. nobody was more feared then RL in his prime. nobody has been more feared since. nobody has now, back in the day, or since that kind of closing speed or could go sideline to sideline like ray lewis. i honestly cannot see another football player coming along regardless of position that was a dominant as ray lewis. most players rely on a supporting cast to win games- RL could win games by himself.

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: visualizeperfection on March 25, 2014, 06:44:04 PM
in my mind, the true greats can win games by themselves, consistently, time and again. they have elevated themselves to a point of ability that no one can forsee anyone following in their footsteps in that profession, or another talent of that level coming along in our lifetime.

1. wayne gretzky. wiki his name and see his body of work. some would argue that he was protected by the league. i grew up watching him. he wasnt protected by any one other than marty mcsorley. he made scoring goals and play making look effortless. you had to see him play to know what i mean. i dont even have the words to explain it. it was as if god himself touched the shoulder of gretzky. there will never be another wayne gretzky.

2. michael jordan. if you had a chance just to watch him play you'd know there will never EVER be another jordan. EVER.

3. mike tyson in his prime before cus died. he was a phenom. nobody will ever step in the ring with that much power, anger, speed and pure ability all in the same package. there will never be another prime mike tyson. he was so scary he admitted most of his fights were won before he even got in the ring. that is pure dominance.

4. ray lewis. some say LT. nobody was more feared then RL in his prime. nobody has been more feared since. nobody has now, back in the day, or since that kind of closing speed or could go sideline to sideline like ray lewis. i honestly cannot see another football player coming along regardless of position that was a dominant as ray lewis. most players rely on a supporting cast to win games- RL could win games by himself.



Great list. Especially on Ray.

I played linebacker prior to D end. Ray was my hero. Motivator/murderer etc.

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: K-1 on March 25, 2014, 06:45:49 PM
Another one. Anybody remember back in the day every college football Saturday espn had a "faulk watch" during the games monitoring how many yards he was rushing for? Got the league and shredded it. Def lived up to the hype. Hall of fame.

(http://i.cdn.turner.com/si/multimedia/photo_gallery/1107/marshall.faulk.rare.photos/images/faulk-sdsu-pose.jpg)
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: UPINTHEMGUTS on March 25, 2014, 06:56:34 PM
Yeah Faulk was a monster. Can't imagine that San Diego state was the only school to offer him a full scholarship. Suprising choice of college since he's coming from New Orleans and SEC country.

Should've won the Heisman over Gino Toretta in 1992.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Pray_4_War on March 25, 2014, 07:03:31 PM
The premise of this thread is wrong.  Jordan wasn't hyped coming into the league anywhere near what Kobe and Lebron were.  Jordan got showered with attention based on his play.  Later on in his career he became an icon once he started winning titles.  Kobe and Lebron on the other hand were labeled as possible Jordan level talents and they both then lived up to that hype.  They had shoe deals before they played a game in the NBA.  Jordan hit a clutch shot in the 1982 NCAA Championship but he wasn't setting the world on fire in college.  When he hit the NBA people had no idea how good he would become.  Apples and oranges.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 25, 2014, 07:05:24 PM
I can honestly say I didn't think this guy would be any good at all. First player drafted out of high school since Darryl Dawkins in 1975. I felt he was too skinny and would get pushed around. He wasn't intimidated by anybody, kicked ass and took names at 18-19 yrs old vs all the big men.

(http://pic.pimg.tw/cyc0320/1317922028-306470777.jpg)

Kemp didnt go to college either, though he enrolled but never went
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: K-1 on March 25, 2014, 07:36:06 PM
Kemp didnt go to college either, though he enrolled but never went

The Reign Man.....that dude brought it to the rim like no other

(http://media.giphy.com/media/wJgeG1Yy2QCI0/giphy.gif)
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: K-1 on March 25, 2014, 07:46:54 PM
Yeah Faulk was a monster. Can't imagine that San Diego state was the only school to offer him a full scholarship. Suprising choice of college since he's coming from New Orleans and SEC country.

Should've won the Heisman over Gino Toretta in 1992.

yep that 92 ceremony was a straight up robbery. I think faulk mentioned everybody wanted to turn him into a wr except san diego st going into college. smh. Dude was awesome. I remember that one pro bowl he made the D look like absolute clowns...smh. Ultra Running Back.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Danimal77 on March 25, 2014, 08:55:48 PM
for a skinny rag doll of a guy Gretzky accomplished amazing things

I'll second that.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Oggie Oglethorpe on March 25, 2014, 08:58:53 PM
in my mind, the true greats can win games by themselves, consistently, time and again. they have elevated themselves to a point of ability that no one can forsee anyone following in their footsteps in that profession, or another talent of that level coming along in our lifetime.

1. wayne gretzky. wiki his name and see his body of work. some would argue that he was protected by the league. i grew up watching him. he wasnt protected by any one other than marty mcsorley. he made scoring goals and play making look effortless. you had to see him play to know what i mean. i dont even have the words to explain it. it was as if god himself touched the shoulder of gretzky. there will never be another wayne gretzky.

2. michael jordan. if you had a chance just to watch him play you'd know there will never EVER be another jordan. EVER.

3. mike tyson in his prime before cus died. he was a phenom. nobody will ever step in the ring with that much power, anger, speed and pure ability all in the same package. there will never be another prime mike tyson. he was so scary he admitted most of his fights were won before he even got in the ring. that is pure dominance.

4. ray lewis. some say LT. nobody was more feared then RL in his prime. nobody has been more feared since. nobody has now, back in the day, or since that kind of closing speed or could go sideline to sideline like ray lewis. i honestly cannot see another football player coming along regardless of position that was a dominant as ray lewis. most players rely on a supporting cast to win games- RL could win games by himself.


Good list.....except Gretzky was protected by Dave Semenko initially, who was twice as nasty as Marty.

(1) Gretzky
(2) Ali
(3) Jerry Rice
(4) Edwin Moses
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Quickerblade on March 25, 2014, 09:33:52 PM

2. michael jordan. if you had a chance just to watch him play you'd know there will never EVER be another jordan. EVER.

3. mike tyson in his prime before cus died. he was a phenom. nobody will ever step in the ring with that much power, anger, speed and pure ability all in the same package. there will never be another prime mike tyson. he was so scary he admitted most of his fights were won before he even got in the ring. that is pure dominance.


I wish we could meet up and talk about this for hours.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: knny187 on March 25, 2014, 09:42:23 PM
in my mind, the true greats can win games by themselves, consistently, time and again. they have elevated themselves to a point of ability that no one can forsee anyone following in their footsteps in that profession, or another talent of that level coming along in our lifetime.

1. wayne gretzky. wiki his name and see his body of work. some would argue that he was protected by the league. i grew up watching him. he wasnt protected by any one other than marty mcsorley. he made scoring goals and play making look effortless. you had to see him play to know what i mean. i dont even have the words to explain it. it was as if god himself touched the shoulder of gretzky. there will never be another wayne gretzky.

2. michael jordan. if you had a chance just to watch him play you'd know there will never EVER be another jordan. EVER.

3. mike tyson in his prime before cus died. he was a phenom. nobody will ever step in the ring with that much power, anger, speed and pure ability all in the same package. there will never be another prime mike tyson. he was so scary he admitted most of his fights were won before he even got in the ring. that is pure dominance.

4. ray lewis. some say LT. nobody was more feared then RL in his prime. nobody has been more feared since. nobody has now, back in the day, or since that kind of closing speed or could go sideline to sideline like ray lewis. i honestly cannot see another football player coming along regardless of position that was a dominant as ray lewis. most players rely on a supporting cast to win games- RL could win games by himself.



Good list but I would go with Three other Linebackers.

LT - Changed the way offense had to block.

Butkus - just dominated everything

Lambert - my all time favorite. Not the biggest guy but intimidated everyone and was a major part of the best defense in football history. The Steel Curtain. This guy was so intense in the day, would be ejected by today's game standard.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Quickerblade on March 25, 2014, 09:50:28 PM
Mike tyson.

I have to say he looked good against bum fighters, he looked ridicilous knocking them out senseless.
His fights were hand picked. If he did what he did in the 80's to Lennox lewis i would have him as the best ever.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: nzmusclemonster on March 25, 2014, 10:46:31 PM
Phil Taylor.

End of thread.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: jr on March 25, 2014, 11:13:39 PM
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Bradman (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Bradman)

Sir Donald George Bradman, AC (27 August 1908 – 25 February 2001), often referred to as "The Don", was an Australian cricketer, widely acknowledged as the greatest Test batsman of all time.[1] Bradman's career Test batting average of 99.94 is often cited as the greatest achievement by any sportsman in any major sport.

Batting Average:


Rank   Batsman   Career average   
1   Don Bradman   99.94   
2   Graeme Pollock   60.97   
3   George Headley   60.83   
4   Herbert Sutcliffe   60.73   
5   Eddie Paynter   59.23   
6   Ken Barrington   58.67   
7   Everton Weekes   58.61   
8   Wally Hammond   58.45   
9   Garfield Sobers   57.78   
10   Jack Hobbs      56.94   
11   C.L. Walcott   56.68   
12   L. Hutton           56.67   
13   Jacques Kallis   55.37   
14   G.E. Tyldesley   55.00   
15   C.A. Davis      54.20   
16   V.G. Kambli      54.20   
17   G.S. Chappell   53.86   
18   Dudley Nourse   53.81   
19   Sachin Tendulkar   53.78   
20   B.C. Lara      52.88   

World sport context

Wisden hailed Bradman as, "the greatest phenomenon in the history of cricket, indeed in the history of all ball games".[1] Statistician Charles Davis analysed the statistics for several prominent sportsmen by comparing the number of standard deviations that they stand above the mean for their sport.[238] The top performers in his selected sports are:[239]

Athlete   Sport   Statistic   Standard deviations

Bradman   Cricket   Batting average   4.4
Pelé         Association football   Goals per game   3.7
Ty Cobb    Baseball   Batting average   3.6
Jack Nicklaus   Golf   Major titles   3.5
Michael Jordan   Basketball   Points per game   3.4

The statistics show that "no other athlete dominates an international sport to the extent that Bradman does cricket".[2] In order to post a similarly dominant career statistic as Bradman, a baseball batter would need a career batting average of .392, while a basketball player would need to score an average of 43.0 points per game.[239] The respective records are .366 and 30.1.[239]

Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: nzmusclemonster on March 26, 2014, 01:04:19 AM
Career games
Player   Pld   Won   Draw   Lost   Win%   Ave   
Phil Taylor   1648   1444   25   179   87.62

16 time world champion

and he's a getbigger:

Indecent assault conviction
In 1999, following an exhibition match in Fife, Scotland, Taylor returned to his van accompanied by two women, aged 23 and 25, who subsequently accused him of indecent assault. Taylor denied the charges but in May 2001 he was found guilty and fined £2,000.[202] As a result of his conviction, Taylor's MBE nomination was annulled before he was awarded it.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on March 26, 2014, 02:50:35 AM
Career games
Player   Pld   Won   Draw   Lost   Win%   Ave   
Phil Taylor   1648   1444   25   179   87.62

16 time world champion

and he's a getbigger:

Indecent assault conviction
In 1999, following an exhibition match in Fife, Scotland, Taylor returned to his van accompanied by two women, aged 23 and 25, who subsequently accused him of indecent assault. Taylor denied the charges but in May 2001 he was found guilty and fined £2,000.[202] As a result of his conviction, Taylor's MBE nomination was annulled before he was awarded it.


So darts. Let's just throw in curling at this point. Who's the best ever and what kind of hype did he have to face?
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Hulkotron on March 26, 2014, 04:50:56 AM
Jordan was like watching a super hero in real life.  I've heard Gretzky was the same (I don't follow/watch hockey).  LeBron might be as good as Jordan but even if he wins more Finals/MVPs/etc he will never be the spectacle/phenomenon that Jordan was.

Also look up Don Bradman if you've never heard of him (Cricket player).  His career batting average was something like five or six standard deviations above the mean for hall-of-fame players  :o

Edit: I see jr just posted about him sorry
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: nicorulez on March 26, 2014, 08:45:29 AM
NBA:

Michael Jordan
Lebron James
Larry Bird
Kareem
Magic Johnson
Dr. J (Julius Irving)
Bill Russell

Baseball:

Ty Cobb
Babe Ruth
Barry Bonds
Cy Young
Roger Clemons
Willie Mays
Hank Aaron

Football:

Walter Payton
Peyton Manning (disregard his SB losses, dude is a stud)'
John Elway
Emmit Smith
Joe Montana
Jerry Rice

Tennis:

Bjorn Borg
John McEnroe
Rod Laver
Pete Sampras
Andre Agassi
Roger Federer
Rafael Nadal
Djokovic
Serena Williams
Steffi Graf
Martina Navratilova
Chris Evert
Monica Seles (pre-stabbing)

Hell the list goes on and on. There are phenomenal athletes who even exceed the hype. I am just giving a smattering. Every sport has iconic figures; pick one and it is obvious. Greatness is probably born and not made.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: cannon_fodder on March 26, 2014, 11:33:04 AM
Valentino Rossi
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Megalodon on March 26, 2014, 11:35:46 AM
Anna Kournikova is one of the few athletes that exceeded the hype.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: hipolito mejia on March 26, 2014, 11:41:31 AM
I know Jordan will go down in history as the only athlete that after been recognized as the best ever in basketball,  to admit that his fav sport is baseball all he ever wanted to be was a baseball player......
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: ChristopherA on March 26, 2014, 12:30:29 PM
Ricky Carmicheal. Thread over
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: no one on March 26, 2014, 01:30:51 PM
I wish we could meet up and talk about this for hours.

i'll be in LV for memorial day. we'll smash coronas and debate.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: ChopperRider on March 26, 2014, 01:37:34 PM
Ricky Carmicheal. Thread over

Definately the GOAT on a dirty bike.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Quickerblade on March 26, 2014, 04:07:53 PM
i'll be in LV for memorial day. we'll smash coronas and debate.

I will be in LAX, If you want to meet me, I will be at the Qantas lounge, I convince you hype and marketing makes them look more talented then they are.. but it wont be a argument as I agree with most of your points.

Side note: they are talented.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 27, 2014, 01:34:02 AM
If Gretzky was so good , why don't people say like "he's like the wayne Gretzky of pool", always seems to be Michael Jordan who gets reserved for this statement when talking about the god of an activity
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: hipolito mejia on March 27, 2014, 03:36:04 AM
NBA:

Michael Jordan
Lebron James
Larry Bird
Kareem
Magic Johnson
Dr. J (Julius Irving)
Bill Russell

Baseball:

Ty Cobb
Babe Ruth
Barry Bonds
Cy Young
Roger Clemons
Willie Mays
Hank Aaron

Football:

Walter Payton
Peyton Manning (disregard his SB losses, dude is a stud)'
John Elway
Emmit Smith
Joe Montana
Jerry Rice

Tennis:

Bjorn Borg
John McEnroe
Rod Laver
Pete Sampras
Andre Agassi
Roger Federer
Rafael Nadal
Djokovic
Serena Williams
Steffi Graf
Martina Navratilova
Chris Evert
Monica Seles (pre-stabbing)

Hell the list goes on and on. There are phenomenal athletes who even exceed the hype. I am just giving a smattering. Every sport has iconic figures; pick one and it is obvious. Greatness is probably born and not made.


You forgot A Rod in baseball the fact that he was a gold glove SS. and 600 plus HRS  makes him superior that  any other ball player.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: no one on March 27, 2014, 04:41:43 AM
If Gretzky was so good , why don't people say like "he's like the wayne Gretzky of pool", always seems to be Michael Jordan who gets reserved for this statement when talking about the god of an activity

hockey doesn't have the market or following basketball had esp in the 80's/90's.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: The Ugly on March 27, 2014, 05:49:42 AM
Ted.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Simple Simon on March 27, 2014, 05:56:15 AM
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Bradman (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Bradman)

Sir Donald George Bradman, AC (27 August 1908 – 25 February 2001), often referred to as "The Don", was an Australian cricketer, widely acknowledged as the greatest Test batsman of all time.[1] Bradman's career Test batting average of 99.94 is often cited as the greatest achievement by any sportsman in any major sport.

Batting Average:


Rank   Batsman   Career average   
1   Don Bradman   99.94   
2   Graeme Pollock   60.97   
3   George Headley   60.83   
4   Herbert Sutcliffe   60.73   
5   Eddie Paynter   59.23   
6   Ken Barrington   58.67   
7   Everton Weekes   58.61   
8   Wally Hammond   58.45   
9   Garfield Sobers   57.78   
10   Jack Hobbs      56.94   
11   C.L. Walcott   56.68   
12   L. Hutton           56.67   
13   Jacques Kallis   55.37   
14   G.E. Tyldesley   55.00   
15   C.A. Davis      54.20   
16   V.G. Kambli      54.20   
17   G.S. Chappell   53.86   
18   Dudley Nourse   53.81   
19   Sachin Tendulkar   53.78   
20   B.C. Lara      52.88   

World sport context

Wisden hailed Bradman as, "the greatest phenomenon in the history of cricket, indeed in the history of all ball games".[1] Statistician Charles Davis analysed the statistics for several prominent sportsmen by comparing the number of standard deviations that they stand above the mean for their sport.[238] The top performers in his selected sports are:[239]

Athlete   Sport   Statistic   Standard deviations

Bradman   Cricket   Batting average   4.4
Pelé         Association football   Goals per game   3.7
Ty Cobb    Baseball   Batting average   3.6
Jack Nicklaus   Golf   Major titles   3.5
Michael Jordan   Basketball   Points per game   3.4

The statistics show that "no other athlete dominates an international sport to the extent that Bradman does cricket".[2] In order to post a similarly dominant career statistic as Bradman, a baseball batter would need a career batting average of .392, while a basketball player would need to score an average of 43.0 points per game.[239] The respective records are .366 and 30.1.[239]


Arguably Tony McCoy ranks up there
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/horse-racing/24855097
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: SuperTed on March 27, 2014, 06:28:25 AM
Audley Harrison.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Simple Simon on March 27, 2014, 06:29:31 AM
Audley Harrison.

Thread end.

No ones gonna top that.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: ChopperRider on March 27, 2014, 06:32:52 AM
Thread end.

No ones gonna to that.

Melvin "Vince" Goodrum
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 27, 2014, 06:45:19 AM
Audley Harrison.

Fraudley should be locked up for taking that bbc contract
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: The Grim Lifter on March 27, 2014, 06:45:43 AM
Don Bradman

Federer is still up there in the best era ever

Tyson fought anyone and at 20 he won the heavyweight belt by way of 2nd round knock out then killed everyone until he partied too much
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Army of One on March 27, 2014, 06:47:18 AM
Don Bradman

Federer is still up there in the best era ever

Tyson fought anyone and at 20 he won the heavyweight belt by way of 2nd round knock out then killed everyone until he partied too much

Federer was great no doubt, but feasted for years on a weak era, a peak nadal and djokovic are/were just as good
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: The Grim Lifter on March 27, 2014, 07:05:52 AM
Federer was great no doubt, but feasted for years on a weak era, a peak nadal and djokovic are/were just as good

Federer still beats Djok, when Djok had that crazy run a few years ago Fed was the only one who could knock him off.

Federer was playing awesome at the Aussie open, he mentally just can't play Nadal i've seen it a number of times. He just does dumb things and loses his cool like Nadal can out rally him and he goes for stupid winners like he doesn't know what to do.

I seriously think Federer could win an open this year if not all 3 if he doesn't play Nadal going on that form at the Aussie open. He mentally would have it over Warinka too or maybe not now but if anyone has it over him it's Federer.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: Sam on March 27, 2014, 01:12:20 PM
Fraudley should be locked up for taking that bbc contract

..Along with the BBC for giving him it.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: The_Punisher on March 27, 2014, 03:25:53 PM
In all sports Ive watched. I can only think of one athlete who was simply godlike in his abilities, and literally surpassed his hype, and that's Michael Jordan.Whenever his team had the equal or best record in the playoffs, they won.Jordan raised his scoring in the playoffs and took his game to next level, remaining the best u til he retired from the bulls.

bolt has been disappointing since his world record, seemingly coasting on natural abilities

Federer has lost his advantage whenever nadal , murray and dkokovic raised their game

Don't know enough about Gretzky , but from what I've read a peak Lemoiux was just as good

Babe Ruth played with stiffs, some fat dude in the twenties being the best, come on

Anyone who is being real watching football (soccer) knows its way too much of a team game for one player to dominate, sans short spells from pele, maradonna and messi

Bubka was dominant so I read,maybe someone can clarify but its a simple sport of planting a pole and launching, sure it's difficult to attain but I can see why someone can master it and be dominant

F1 is all down to the car

Ali lost too many times to make a case, same with Robinson


yes indeed.....this man always meet expectation as a player and he lived up to the hype.....I remember games 7 in the playoffs between Indiana pacers and Chicago bulls and Larry bird was coaching the pacers at that time.....this was one of the most hyped game 7 playoffs game and Jordan had a subpar game, but his intensity, his will to win was unmatched.....he had only 17 points in the game, but he was yelling, puffing at anyone of his teammates who would not match his intensity and remind them of what's at stake......I'd say Jordan lived for the Hype
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: flinstones1 on March 27, 2014, 03:37:37 PM
alot of guys say .albert puljos was a bust but most dont realize he  wasn't drafted until the 13th round.
Title: Re: Is Jordan the only athlete that ever lived up to or surpassed the hype?
Post by: wild willie on March 27, 2014, 04:04:46 PM
two of the biggest busts in nfl history........Lawrence Phillips and trev alberts.