Jay might win the 'relaxed' pose or whatever but when watching the video it becomes clear that ronnie is better put together. He has way more detail and shape, which does not mean he wasn't smooth or watery or whatever which he was, but Ronnie doesn't just have bigger arms, chest and back they all have more shape and detail and nice lines. Jay's whole upper body lacks striations.
Jay has always been a fridge, and he actually has quite a weak chest. He looks more striated in the ass than ever here though, so a close call by all accounts but Ronnie is bigger AND has superior shape and detail to the max, just a bit watery.