None of those two are truly great. Phil has serious flaws, like the lack of width. It is really surpising that the number one competitor can win with such flaws. That says a lot
about the 'gene pool' from which bodybuilders are recruited. Look at Phils FDB, it is getting worse. He loook stumpy and narrow.
I think Haney from 91 would smoke Phil. Put them next to each other in real life. Of course Phil has a bit more developed legs - especially hams. But that was not as prioritized at that era. And please dont mention any glutes - that is irrelevant. Phil looks best on his own. Standing in line (an not even when standing a foot in front) with the other competitors, Phil does not stand out.
Another thing. Those pics in this thread is really really doctored/sharpened. There are no such pics of Haney (or Yates)