Is Tom Brady The Best Football Player Ever?

[Nick Danger]

Montana
Brady
Elway
Marino
payton
sanders (Barry)
Lile Alzaido or however u spell it
rice
taylor

I can not have a debate with someone who thinks Lyle Alzado was anywhere near Lawrence Taylor's level.

[Hack Benchers]

This tom brady has NOTHING on prof soccer players, nothing!

[Earl1972]

In the regular season.

he beat brady 3 out of 4 times in the afc championship game

one of them a decade ago being very similar to the pats recent super bowl win, pats had a 21 - 3 lead, colts won i think 38 -35 with brady throwing an interception less than a minute left to clinch the win for the colts

E

[El Diablo Blanco]

peyton manning was better than him many years

if brady is the best, manning is at least top 5

E

Manning didn't beat Brady.  It's not a one-one match.  The colts D under Dungy helped a lot.  Then Denver built an amazing defense.  So yeah, manning's team with top defenses beat Brady.

Listen. I fucking can't stand Brady and I'm sticking up for him.  makes me sick.

[ChristopherA]

What about a guy like Deon Sanders?  Not saying he's the greatest player of all time, but he played both sides of the ball and was elite both ways.  Just food for thought. 

You trying to say Sanders was elite on offense? Gonna have to check some stats I sure don't remember that

[Nails]

What WR ? RB? or TE?  from this Patriot Dynasty will make it to the Hall of Fame with Brady 

[bigkid]

he beat brady 3 out of 4 times in the afc championship game

one of them a decade ago being very similar to the pats recent super bowl win, pats had a 21 - 3 lead, colts won i think 38 -35 with brady throwing an interception less than a minute left to clinch the win for the colts

E

Brady is 25-9 in the post season.  Manning is 14-13.

[Bevo]

Elway had just as many td's to interception ratio

[AbrahamG]

You trying to say Sanders was elite on offense? Gonna have to check some stats I sure don't remember that

special teams.  kick and/or punt returns.

[ChristopherA]

special teams.  kick and/or punt returns.

Oh yeah, duh. Def a beast on special teams

[AbrahamG]

Oh yeah, duh. Def a beast on special teams

I wasn't saying Sanders in the best player ever.  Merely that the best overall player is really hard to pinpoint in football.  Brady is definitely the
best QB ever. 

[Earl1972]

Manning didn't beat Brady.  It's not a one-one match.  The colts D under Dungy helped a lot.  Then Denver built an amazing defense.  So yeah, manning's team with top defenses beat Brady.

Listen. I fucking can't stand Brady and I'm sticking up for him.  makes me sick.

i know but you could say the same about all the wins brady had over manning, the pats had a great D for all of their super bowl wins

i think if they switched teams the patriots might have just as many super bowl wins

E

[Earl1972]

Brady is 25-9 in the post season.  Manning is 14-13.

it's a team game

E

[Anonymous]

i know but you could say the same about all the wins brady had over manning, the pats had a great D for all of their super bowl wins

i think if they switched teams the patriots might have just as many super bowl wins

E

Agreed. Manning would probably have 6 or 7 if he was in the pats system all these years with all those years. I doubt brady would have 1 if played in peytons shoes

We forget so quickly peyton went to the super bowl with 4 different coaches.

[Bevo]

Reggie Wayne on NFL network acknowledged Brady is better than Peyton after the SB

[Nails]

Mannings downfall was his bullshit audible every single fucking play, just run the fucking play called and shut the fuck up

[Powerlift66]

Mannings a pussy like Clemens for throwing his wife under the bus "She ordered the HGH, not me"...
He comes back from severe neck surgery after HGH order, throws 50 TD's. (I actaully like Manning though).

Just another liar who the NFL likes to protect. HGH head...

[CalvinH]

Montana
Brady
Elway
Marino
payton
sanders (Barry)
Lile Alzaido or however u spell it
rice
taylor

Alzado should be nowhere near this list.

[El Diablo Blanco]

Alzado should be nowhere near this list.

Not sure why Bruce Smith or Reggie White aren't there.

[CalvinH]

Not sure why Bruce Smith or Reggie White aren't there.

Both were a hell of a lot better then Alzado.



....Howie Long was a better player and they were on the same team.

[loco]

.

[gothorium]

.

so did tom tho
jordan cheated all 6 by refs given