Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums

Getbig Misc Discussion Boards => Mixed Martial Arts (MMA/UFC) => Topic started by: LilPoppaPete on May 27, 2007, 08:49:07 AM

Title: .
Post by: LilPoppaPete on May 27, 2007, 08:49:07 AM
.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Thin Lizzy on May 27, 2007, 08:53:41 AM
Chuck should be thankful that Big John saved his life.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: the shadow on May 27, 2007, 09:25:46 AM
Chuck should be thankful that Big John saved his life.
yeeeeees :D..rampage was kicking the living shit out of chuck..chuck should thank big john from saving him from further embarassment
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: gmflex on May 27, 2007, 09:32:19 AM
chuck was about 2 maybe 3 punches away from getting KO'd
would of been great too see that :-\
you guys should check out their 1st fight in 2003/ Pride ;D
the ref didn't stop it ;D
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: the shadow on May 27, 2007, 09:34:24 AM
chuck was about 2 maybe 3 punches away from getting KO'd
would of been great too see that :-\
you guys should check out their 1st fight in 2003/ Pride ;D
the ref didn't stop it ;D

hahahahaah yes.liddell was bleeding like a bitch at the end..big john should have let rampage punch him more..
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Thin Lizzy on May 27, 2007, 10:03:39 AM
Big John stopped the fight at exactly the right time. Chuck legs had gone dead, and, while he wasn't completely unconscious, he was defenseless.

I've said this before, with MMA blowing up, the last thing the sport needs is a serious injury or death because a ref didn't get in there on time.

In boxing, when a fighter goes down, the other fighter, unless he's deranged, will step away and ref will begin the count. If the fighter doesn't get up by 10, that's it. There's no decision for the ref. In MMA, you're allowed to hit a downed fighter, so, the ref ALWAYS has a decision to make. Some are easier than others. That's why you'll always have more second guessing of refs in MMA.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Earl1972 on May 27, 2007, 10:06:59 AM
Just saw the fight...

If that was anybody but Liddell, I'd say yeah, call it over; but I honestly think Liddell could've found a way to get up from that beating...  He just recovers quickly and is crafty.  Based on the strategy Chuck was employing, however (i.e., running), I think he'd've lost anyway (you'll never beat Jackson by running from him - that was terrible strategy by Chuck - ); I just don't think he should've lost on the fight being called too soon.  For all the major media attention the fight gathered, I further think this fight can only be viewed as a major disappointment for the UFC.  Thoughts, anyone?  Am I completely wrong about Chuck being able to snake out of that beating?

you and MAYBE chuck are the only ones that think this

E
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: jbflift on May 27, 2007, 11:17:25 AM
Chuck did not have a prayer of getting back up.  I thought Chuck  would have been a little more durable.  He was just way too exposed trying to box Rampage.
I would love to see Chuck use some of his grappling and collegiate wrestling experience.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: americanbulldog on May 27, 2007, 12:07:52 PM
Just saw the fight...

If that was anybody but Liddell, I'd say yeah, call it over; but I honestly think Liddell could've found a way to get up from that beating...  He just recovers quickly and is crafty.  Based on the strategy Chuck was employing, however (i.e., running), I think he'd've lost anyway (you'll never beat Jackson by running from him - that was terrible strategy by Chuck - ); I just don't think he should've lost on the fight being called too soon.  For all the major media attention the fight gathered, I further think this fight can only be viewed as a major disappointment for the UFC.  Thoughts, anyone?  Am I completely wrong about Chuck being able to snake out of that beating?

Chuck was out after the elbow, and was awoken with the last punch.  He was clearly on queer street when BJM stepped in.  No way he could've came back to win.  It is ALWAYS Chuck's strategy to retreat and counterpunch.  He does it nearly every fight until he hurts someone, then he jumps on them.  This definitely isn't a major disappointment for Zuffa.  In Page, they got a charismatic pitch guy who excels at giving entertaining interviews.  They can get behind him and build him like they did Chuck. 
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: americanbulldog on May 27, 2007, 12:19:57 PM
No doubt, 'Page' will be very marketable.  I just wish they could get a good 'war' to really push UFC/MMA forward on one of these high-profile fights.   

They got Shogun, prolly will have Kang soon, and Hollywood.  Talent is rich in the 185 and 205 category.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: 20inch calves on May 27, 2007, 02:00:19 PM
ufc sucks. like i said before the ppv;s are a waste of money.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: blinky on May 27, 2007, 03:05:58 PM
he stoppage was a good call. if you watch youll see chucks arms to totally limp out to his sides...meaning he couldnt defend himself anymore so stopping it was right.

i watched a replay on one of our sports channels last night and at one point just after it was stopped it shows chuck sitting on the ground his guys all around him. his eyes were definately not focused and you could see him ask someone "what happened".


good stoppage by big john
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Journeyman on May 27, 2007, 05:39:25 PM
Chuck was out after the elbow, and was awoken with the last punch.  He was clearly on queer street when BJM stepped in.  No way he could've came back to win.  It is ALWAYS Chuck's strategy to retreat and counterpunch.  He does it nearly every fight until he hurts someone, then he jumps on them.  This definitely isn't a major disappointment for Zuffa.  In Page, they got a charismatic pitch guy who excels at giving entertaining interviews.  They can get behind him and build him like they did Chuck. 

that is exactly what happened agree 100%
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Petrucci on May 28, 2007, 05:59:30 AM
he stoppage was a good call. if you watch youll see chucks arms to totally limp out to his sides...meaning he couldnt defend himself anymore so stopping it was right.



agree completely. Chuck was dead, it doesnt matter if it was for just seconds...he was completely out of this world at that moment. arms and legs completely numb

 Man, for now on Rampage is on my favorite fighters list!!! HAHAHAHAHA

 Finally someone put that Chuck on his place...on the ground, koŽed...And the most beautiful thing: he was beat on his own game!!! HAHAHAHHAAH

 
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: thewickedtruth on May 28, 2007, 07:44:59 AM
chuck went limp on the floor when rampage pounced for a few seconds...that's a knockout no matter how long
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Scimowser on May 28, 2007, 08:24:12 AM
as much as i like Chuck, he was out of it and could have been seriously hurt had Big John decided to let it go for a few more seconds. He was limp, couldnt focus and certainly couldnt defend himself. A fantastic win for Rampage, however i dont like his chances in his next fight! Looks like Chucks gonna have to wait for that rematch again
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Richard2004 on May 28, 2007, 08:52:23 PM
Just saw the fight...

If that was anybody but Liddell, I'd say yeah, call it over; but I honestly think Liddell could've found a way to get up from that beating...  He just recovers quickly and is crafty.  Based on the strategy Chuck was employing, however (i.e., running), I think he'd've lost anyway (you'll never beat Jackson by running from him - that was terrible strategy by Chuck - ); I just don't think he should've lost on the fight being called too soon.  For all the major media attention the fight gathered, I further think this fight can only be viewed as a major disappointment for the UFC.  Thoughts, anyone?  Am I completely wrong about Chuck being able to snake out of that beating?

I disagree, based upon the fact that Chuck's eyes were glazed over when John finally got him up off of his flat back onto one shoulder, and Chuck was looking in the direction of the camera...I've been there and have seen that look too many times (!) in fighters.  Rampage was all over Chuck after he dropped him with that right hook and was "grounding and pounding" Chuck unmercilessly when John pulled him off...and, oh yes, Chuck did "go flat" as Joe/Randy astutely observed/commented.

What shocked me was that Rampage beat Chuck at his own game...stand-up punching!??  I assumed Chuck was THE BEST in that area of the game!??

Observations...Chuck seemed to be relatively soft around his mid-section this time...Chuck was blinking in the stare-down...Rampage was the aggressor from the very start and, even though Chuck likes you to come after him and specializes in counter-punching, Chuck seemed to be "backing off much more" than usual.

Again, to beat Chuck at his OWN game of "toe-to-toe slugging it out"...that is REALLY something!
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: realkarateblackbelt on May 28, 2007, 09:10:36 PM
Chuck rarely "slugs it out" with anyone. He was fed a steady stream of good wrestlers with sub-par standup skills. It was easy for him to look good against them.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: americanbulldog on May 28, 2007, 11:21:51 PM
I disagree, based upon the fact that Chuck's eyes were glazed over when John finally got him up off of his flat back onto one shoulder, and Chuck was looking in the direction of the camera...I've been there and have seen that look too many times (!) in fighters.  Rampage was all over Chuck after he dropped him with that right hook and was "grounding and pounding" Chuck unmercilessly when John pulled him off...and, oh yes, Chuck did "go flat" as Joe/Randy astutely observed/commented.

What shocked me was that Rampage beat Chuck at his own game...stand-up punching!??  I assumed Chuck was THE BEST in that area of the game!??

Observations...Chuck seemed to be relatively soft around his mid-section this time...Chuck was blinking in the stare-down...Rampage was the aggressor from the very start and, even though Chuck likes you to come after him and specializes in counter-punching, Chuck seemed to be "backing off much more" than usual.

Again, to beat Chuck at his OWN game of "toe-to-toe slugging it out"...that is REALLY something!


Chuck couldn't sprawl and brawl with someone who wasn't shooting.  Rampage stood in the pocket and was loading up to throw bombs.  Just like he did in the first fight.  Page's big slams are incidental.  He isn't a classic freestyle wrestler who will shoot a double from four feet away.  (Din Thomas shot off of a cross was a thing of beauty, BTW)

Page was already in Chuck's head.  He wanted nothing to do with Page's power in his hands, on a right cross that Q threw, Chuck raised his left arm in a "wing" block and scampered backwards.  On the bodyhook, he didn't cover with his right and ate the perfect counter in the right hook.  Chuck is succeptible to a flash KO, just watch his Pele fight from IVC. 

Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Faust on May 29, 2007, 01:01:55 AM
Observations...Chuck seemed to be relatively soft around his mid-section this time...Chuck was blinking in the stare-down...
Yes...
Wtf was up with that gut?
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: LatsMcGee on May 29, 2007, 02:17:23 AM
Chuck was dead in the water and he should thank McCarthy for pulling him out of the pool. 

So how about on the Rampage/Henderson card we see Chuck/Wand and Shogun/Machida.  I'd drop 50 to see that.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Logan32 on May 29, 2007, 11:00:31 AM
Chuck rarely "slugs it out" with anyone. He was fed a steady stream of good wrestlers with sub-par standup skills. It was easy for him to look good against them.

I think it is funny when people keep saying this. Prior to Rampage coming to the UFC and Pride being bought who were the top contenders in the UFC? Grapplers and BJJ guys. Also Randy Couture who is mainly grappler knocked down a 265lbs heavyweight (yea I knwo it was Tim S but hey). There is no doubt that Rampage deserved to win, he caught him plain and simple. And besides I recall Chuck "slugging" it out with Metzger, Overeem and Belfort? Rampage is a beast....
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Faust on May 29, 2007, 01:05:27 PM
I think it is funny when people keep saying this...
Rampage is a beast....
Funny how a lot of people suddenly jump on page's bandwagon.

Silva and Shogun slugged it out with page and destroyed him. Don't get me wrong, Quinton is very good, but i wouldn't call him dominant. Too many guys out there can beat him. Interesting division, i don't think rampage will hold the belt for long though.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Petrucci on May 29, 2007, 01:24:07 PM
I think it is funny when people keep saying this. Prior to Rampage coming to the UFC and Pride being bought who were the top contenders in the UFC? Grapplers and BJJ guys. Also Randy Couture who is mainly grappler knocked down a 265lbs heavyweight (yea I knwo it was Tim S but hey). There is no doubt that Rampage deserved to win, he caught him plain and simple. And besides I recall Chuck "slugging" it out with Metzger, Overeem and Belfort? Rampage is a beast....

the victory against Belfort was really a matter of point of view, and even like that, he won by points...he just had ONE good moment on fight wich was decisive in judges opinions for what it seems...
 Belfort at that time had just got out of a Reality Show here in Brazil, more or less like Big Brother...he was there for like 1 or 2 months (i dont recall exactly) and he got the fight right after leaving there...He wasnt prepared for the fight, but the contract was very clear about when the fight was going to take place...He accepted it...and we saw what hapenned...
 Not saying that Chuck would not win in other circumstances, but if Belfort was really prepared for that fight, the result could be a lot different
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Logan32 on May 29, 2007, 02:18:23 PM
Funny how a lot of people suddenly jump on page's bandwagon.

Not jumping on the Rampage bandwagon always liked the way he fought. I watched the Silva fight and until Wandy got him in the clinch I would say it was pretty even (IMHO). I should have rephrased my initial comment Rampage looked like a beast Saturday night. Personally I think styles make fights and Rampage just has a style that will beat Chuck 8 out of 10 times. Unless Liddell spends some time working on his striking defense I don't see this outcome changing. Interestingly I think style wise Shogun and Wandy are a better matchup for Liddell (again IMHO). Anyway I was not trying to say that Q is the second coming just giving him his "props" on the win.

I agree that he might not be holding the belt for long Henderson is extremely tough. Good hands, good defense, great takedowns....

the victory against Belfort was really a matter of point of view,

I did not know and that is a fantastic point. Unfortunately we will never know what the outcome would have been ... Great thing about the internet someone can always provide insight into these things..
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: americanbulldog on May 29, 2007, 04:20:27 PM
Not jumping on the Rampage bandwagon always liked the way he fought. I watched the Silva fight and until Wandy got him in the clinch I would say it was pretty even (IMHO). I should have rephrased my initial comment Rampage looked like a beast Saturday night. Personally I think styles make fights and Rampage just has a style that will beat Chuck 8 out of 10 times. Unless Liddell spends some time working on his striking defense I don't see this outcome changing. Interestingly I think style wise Shogun and Wandy are a better matchup for Liddell (again IMHO). Anyway I was not trying to say that Q is the second coming just giving him his "props" on the win.

I agree that he might not be holding the belt for long Henderson is extremely tough. Good hands, good defense, great takedowns....

I did not know and that is a fantastic point. Unfortunately we will never know what the outcome would have been ... Great thing about the internet someone can always provide insight into these things..

Page's kryptonite is the muay thai plum.  It got him KOed by Wandy twice, broke his ribs against Shogun, and allowed Ninja to make the fight close (I thought Ninja won, btw and I love Page)
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: realkarateblackbelt on May 30, 2007, 04:20:23 AM
I never jumped on his bandwagon. I was never on the "Chuckwagon" in the first place.
He's good but he's always been overrated.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: SinCitysmallGUY on May 30, 2007, 01:09:38 PM
Yes...
Wtf was up with that gut?

Where the hell have you people been, Chuck always shows up with that GUT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: Bluto on May 30, 2007, 02:33:04 PM
chucks in shape thats just the way he looks not everyone got a sixpack and of those who do that doesnt say much about general conditioning
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: americanbulldog on May 30, 2007, 04:17:06 PM
chucks in shape thats just the way he looks not everyone got a sixpack and of those who do that doesnt say much about general conditioning


Can you say GH belly. 
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: cheeksmaliod on May 30, 2007, 04:26:30 PM
Chuck rarely "slugs it out" with anyone. He was fed a steady stream of good wrestlers with sub-par standup skills. It was easy for him to look good against them.

Finally someone realizes this, name one good stand up fighter Liddell has beaten.  The light heavyweight is a crap division anyways.  A good boxer like Frank Mir or Ian Freeman or the pitbull or Rizzo would destroy Chuck Liddell and thats probally why they went up in weight to where the real competition is, the heavyweight division.
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: americanbulldog on May 30, 2007, 06:22:47 PM
Finally someone realizes this, name one good stand up fighter Liddell has beaten.  The light heavyweight is a crap division anyways.  A good boxer like Frank Mir or Ian Freeman or the pitbull or Rizzo would destroy Chuck Liddell and thats probally why they went up in weight to where the real competition is, the heavyweight division.

Frank Mir is a good boxer?  Ian Freeman?  Rizzo is just as much a counterfighter as Liddell.  Andrei's chin wouldn't last.  With the advent of Pride MWs (UFC LHWs), this is the richest division in MMA. 
Title: Re: Big John McCarthy called it too soon!
Post by: SinCitysmallGUY on June 01, 2007, 12:53:33 PM
Finally someone realizes this, name one good stand up fighter Liddell has beaten.  The light heavyweight is a crap division anyways.  A good boxer like Frank Mir or Ian Freeman or the pitbull or Rizzo would destroy Chuck Liddell and thats probally why they went up in weight to where the real competition is, the heavyweight division.

The HW division was pure shit, Sylvia, Mir, The pitbull, all of these guys are decent fighters but I wouldnt say that they are class A fighters.