I think a Jewish girl would be interesting, a real clash of style and flavor.
Lmao...and a whole lot of attitude, Division.
Oh yeah...and a nose to go right along with that.
For me, it's an entire look and set of mannerisms, expressions, movement, attitude. There are some guys who are nice to look at but I wouldn't want to actually go out with them (these are usually the pretty boys; I feel uncomfortable around them, like I have to be on my best behavior and not dribble water down my chin or trip in my heels...the typical, day-to-day stupid things I do). I personally like green eyes, but that's just because I think they are so pretty. But any color eyes will do if the eyes are very expressive and have a certain look and appeal to them.
I like strong features and almost a rough appearance. I like if something is just slightly out of place. Some sort of imperfection that actually adds to the whole look and appearance of the guy. It makes him seem more human.
I personally like a taller guy (most of the guys I've gone out with have been 5'11" to 6'3"), but I think that has to do with my attempt to even out the gene pool for future little Jodi's that might inhabit this place one day (the thought scares me too). I like more of the Men's Fitness type of muscular than the bodybuilding type...small waist, flaring shoulders, cute shelf booty, thick quads.
At the end of the day, though, if he opens his mouth and what comes out is stupid, then the door is slammed shut on him. And if he doesn't have a sense of humor (especially a dry one), then he won't go far with me. So it should go without saying that while the looks will attract me in the first place, the personality and intellect will become the "make or break" factors.