In defense of Branch Warren's NY win

[SirTraps]

The argument that Branch won because he had more mass is bullshit, Branch won because these contests are fixed and corrupt.

      Branch looked like shit.

[Iraclese]

Agreed!!

[HowieW]

One of Branch's flaws: he is just TOO muscular.

Sounds weird, but it is true.  Even pro bodybuilders who are 5'6 are not meant to be THAT big.  Muscularity is a flaw in and of itself sometimes.  Lee Haney himself would not look good at 300 pounds.

Sadly, not too many in the modern era of bodybuilding "get that". A physique that is too big and thick, even if it is all lean muscle is not a great physique . Overall flow and body line is a key trait to a great physique. Having said that at least Branch did have a bloated, "pregnant" waist and legs that are the best overall in the pros. He is impressive when seen in person.    Howard