By that comment you can not argue with OTH's advice of little to no carbs. Its his balance of those compenents thats makes "his" way work best for him and many, many others. You may stop arguing at this point.
And by the same argument my ideal will work for me and many,many others.
It does also validate the point in both cases that either my or OTHs personal combination of carbs/protein/fats diet wont be ideal for many,many others as well.
Can you agree with these things:
1) He is NOT saying its the best/only, just one of the easiest/fastest
It isnt easier or faster just because its all protein, its just the same because its a reduction in calories.
2) He is not saying that carbs are evil, just not needed
Correct, but he has already admitted he knows nothing of the importance of carbs and their protein sparing qualities.
3) He is not saying "your" method doesn't work, just his experience (and that of many others) that it takes longer
Its because the initial weight loss when you drop carbs is water, I will say again and again its calorific intake that counts, not what you put in.
4) You do not like the low carb approach and thus is the reason for arguing
Correct,
I don't like the low carb approach and no Im not arguing, he is, but Im not.