Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: jaejonna on October 13, 2006, 11:13:12 AM
-
http://snappoll.com/poll/138336.php (http://snappoll.com/poll/138336.php)
The choices are listed and you can only vote once.
Lets get to the bottom of this !!!!
The Loser of the POLL will be forced to give back the sandow and award it to Tom Platz for his 1981 tour De force physique.
(((and yes i noticed i spelled return wrong...sorry )))
-
Dickerson, clearly.
-
Anyone who votes Cutler worse than Columbo with gyno and no legs is a blatent hater/jelous he beat Ronnie. Same goes for Dickerson ::)
Why is Doz not on this list for his final O showing? He was a mess. Arnold is for 81.
-
Jason Cutler
-
Dickerson, clearly.
I woudn't use the word "worst" but maybe "boring"?? I wasn't around for the dickerson era but even if i do find a little bit to read on it, its usually boring. It is kind of hard to believe he is one of the 11 men to hold the title (if you look at all the others)
-
Dickersons stong points...legs, conditioning, posing
Dickerson had major flaws....Torn Pec, Torn Bicep, Undersized, closet queer (at the time)
-
Jason Cutler
Jay Cutler was worse than Columbo? AHAHAHAHA!!! Hey Ronnie. How are things in Texas?
-
dickerson is gay??
-
Columbo - 1981.
-
dickerson is gay??
as the day is long
Oh yeah I didnt put Dorian on there because he is one of the greatest. I voted Dickerson, I think Franco 81, then Cutler round out the worse. Samir being on there is just to fill a space. He may be top 5 conditions of a Mr O winning physique.
-
as the day is long
Oh yeah I didnt put Dorian on there because he is one of the greatest. I voted Dickerson, I think Franco 81, then Cutler round out the worse. Samir being on there is just to fill a space. He may be top 5 conditions of a Mr O winning physique.
Gotcha... I have no problem with people not liking Jay's physique. But to vote dickerson or columbo better is blatent hater/jelous Jay bear Ronnie status.
Columbo was in a wheel chair for christs sakes lol.
-
you thought dorian was the worst ever??
-
you thought dorian was the worst ever??
No. I think he should be on the list for his last showing if Arnold was for 81. Doz was all fucked up his last time out.
The outcome of this is crap anyway. The haters are pissed Ronnie lost. To say columbo/dickerson where better than Cutler in any sense is laughable. Columbo was in a wheelchair his win. Dickerson weighed like 125 ::) With various tears and a giant elbow.
-
I agree with the fact that Doz should have been beaten his last time on stage but he was definatly one of the best.
-
Yes Body88...i would actuall put Arnold 80 in front of this year's Jay in terms of worse mr. O. the thing is that back in the day the conditioning vs mass diffrences was not as big as it is today. People were getting away with being the top 3 in conditioning and top 5 in mass to claim a Pro win. Now the conditioned ppl are soo much more outmassed by the big guys that its really judging two diffrent creatures up there. Jay this year must of been the Top 3 in Mass(Ronnie, Markus,Jay), and Top 5 in conditioning.(Rockel, Dexter, Alves,Paco, Jay) But judges give more points for being big than being ripped.
Jay Cutler 27% 6
Chris Dickerson 27% 6
Franco Columbo 27% 6
Arnold (1980 Version) 14% 3
Frank Zane 5% 1
Larry Scott 0% 0
Samir Bannout 0% 0
total votes: 22
(22 votes so far, 50 votes makes a poll valid).
-
I agree with the fact that Doz should have been beaten his last time on stage but he was definatly one of the best.
I agree. That is why I was asking why no doz but the Arnold of 81.
-
Yes Body88...i would actuall put Arnold 80 in front of this year's Jay in terms of worse mr. O. the thing is that back in the day the conditioning vs mass diffrences was not as big as it is today. People were getting away with being the top 3 in conditioning and top 5 in mass to claim a Pro win. Now the conditioned ppl are soo much more outmassed by the big guys that its really judging two diffrent creatures up there. Jay this year must of been the Top 3 in Mass(Ronnie, Markus,Jay), and Top 5 in conditioning.(Rockel, Dexter, Alves,Paco, Jay) But judges give more points for being big than being ripped.
Like I said. I have NO problem with guys not liking Jay's physique. No problem with them not thinking he is a bad Mr O. But to say he is the worst Mr O ever. Or worse than Dickerson or Columbo is a crock of shit.
I would like to know the basis Franco was better with no legs, zero condition and massive gyno? This pole is crooked.
-
Whats worse is that even though Jay in respect to other Mr. O's may be considered to be not that 'great'.
He was the obvious winner last september.
-
Whats worse is that even though Jay in respect to other Mr. O's may be considered to be not that 'great'.
He was the obvious winner last september.
Ok, well I dont know how this pole will go. But I do not think anyone in there right mind could call Jay the worst Mr O ever with Franco and Dickerson in the running.
Maybe if they where not on this list. But not with those two hacks on there.
I bet Matt t and co are making gimmicks as we speak to vote twice.
-
Franco.
Sorry but in the fans opinion the extra boobs didn't help.
-
dickerson is gay??
Oh yes
Dick-A-Son ;)
-
.
I bet Matt t and co are making gimmicks as we speak to vote twice.
They would have to go to another computer on a diff. IP address to vote again..this poll is legit.
-
Anyone who votes Cutler worse than Columbo with gyno and no legs is a blatent hater/jelous he beat Ronnie. Same goes for Dickerson ::)
Why is Doz not on this list for his final O showing? He was a mess. Arnold is for 81.
no way in hell jay should even be on that list..jeajonna or what ever your name is your a lame assbitch..i would say frank zane was the worst mr olympia along with dickerson..i would say jay is the all time greats.after a 22yr gap he dethroned a mr olympia during his reign...NUFF SAID
-
They would have to go to another computer on a diff. IP address to vote again..this poll is legit.
I dont think you are crooked. I think people are voting Cutler since they where angry to see Ronnie lose. You also have dissed jay mad times since he won. Which is fine. So I did a pole also to make sure.
-
no way in hell jay should even be on that list..jeajonna or what ever your name is your a lame assbitch..i would say frank zane was the worst mr olympia along with dickerson..i would say jay is the all time greats.after a 22yr gap he dethroned a mr olympia during his reign...NUFF SAID
Shadow, I respect your views and also believe that Jay won the O fair and square. However, TO ME PERSONALLY...his wide waist and watery back justify his place among worst Mr. Olympias..He is not the WORST, but because ppl were mentioning his name I placed him on the poll to guage the current temperment.
-
Jay Cutler was worse than Columbo? AHAHAHAHA!!! Hey Ronnie. How are things in Texas?
Cutler is also taking about 10,000 mgs more:) Different times my friend. To compare the two is ludacris.
PB
-
agreed.
-
Jay Cutler was worse than Columbo? AHAHAHAHA!!! Hey Ronnie. How are things in Texas?
Pretty gooood! 8)
-
Cutler is also taking about 10,000 mgs more:) Different times my friend. To compare the two is ludacris.
PB
Jay Cutler did not have zero leg defintion(Franco had more than bad condition he had absolutly zero cuts), massive gyno , weighed way under 200 lbs and had a best friends running the show.
This pole is a chance for the Ronnie Riders to cry. Period. This is not the worst Mr O ever. To claim he is is stupid.
-
Whats worse is that even though Jay in respect to other Mr. O's may be considered to be not that 'great'.
He was the obvious winner last september.
not so obvious on October 8th
-
It goes like this
Haney
Ronnie
Arnold
Doz
Zane
Cutler
Samir
Anything out of that lineup is Subjective. Anyone who says Dickerson or Columbo are better are haters and mad jay beat Ronnie. Those are the facts!
-
I always admired Franco's physique and strength but a Mr.O title holder he was not.
-
I always admired Franco's physique and strength but a Mr.O title holder he was not.
Same here. he was a beast. Looked great in pi. But he fucked his legs up before he won that Mr O. He was def the worst mr O ever.
-
Chris Dickerson was the first gay/black Mr. O. He bought shame to the game. On the one hand he was a representative of the sport and on the other hand he was secretly bending over behind Weider headquarters.
Franco made a lousy Mr. O in 81 but at least he doesn't chug down "teh cock".
-
Funny how Dickerson is slammed for being Gay but when Rusty "Magnum P.I" Jeffers posed for gay men was "OK"
After he clearly beat/owned Chick.
-
Same here. he was a beast. Looked great in pi. But he fucked his legs up before he won that Mr O. He was def the worst mr O ever.
fucked up his legs??
-
fucked up his legs??
Frano competed in the wsm and destroyed his leg moving a fridge. He won that O with a fucked up leg. He couldent even squat leading up to the contest. He had absolutly no cuts or condition in his legs. On top of the massive gyno and his best friend running the show.
He was also like 5'4. I am sorry the best body on earth is not 5'4.
-
Squatting or any leg workout before a competition doesn't put definition in your legs. diet and conditioning does....
Judges just handed the trophy to Franco before they ever got on stage, thanks to an Arnold threat......
-
Squatting or any leg workout before a competition doesn't put definition in your legs. diet and conditioning does....
Judges just handed the trophy to Franco before they ever got on stage, thanks to an Arnold threat......
Correct. But Franco suffered a devesting leg injury before the contest. not being able to squat/workout his quads caused him to lose more size in his quads while dieting. Not to mention the guy could barley work out in general.
He was a great bb. But he was def the worst mr O of that lot. If not him Dickerson.
-
what was Arnold's threat??
-
Funny how Dickerson is slammed for being Gay but when Rusty "Magnum P.I" Jeffers posed for gay men was "OK"
After he clearly beat/owned Chick.
Yeah but Chris Dickerson liked being "slammed". It worked out beautifully.
-
you thought dorian was the worst ever??
Every morning he thanks the BB gods for Dickerson & Columbu.
-
what was Arnold's threat??
Well bro I don't want to go all 240 on shit... but I believe that Arnold influenced Joe and the judging staff on giving his little buddy the trophy as Arnold had issues with the other competers..
I say this because Joe and the IFBB stock market was @ a huge high then with the personality and charisma of Arnold @ the helms so to speak. If there was in anyway a problem or if Arnold didn't get his way it could have reprecussions on Joe and the IFBB.
But who knows?? I might be talking out my balloon knot right??
-
nono i can see where your coming from, if true thats a shame.
-
My opinion as worst Mr. Olympia is.....
*drum roll*
Dorian Yates. :-X
-
the worst?
Zane the swimmer(pick any year)
Franco
Cutler and Bannout( Bannout was balanced there just wasn't anything outstanding about him. NO WOW factor at all) :-\
-
Regardless of who is worst....remember the main facts. The mass monsters of today will dwarf the guys of yesteryear due to the increasingly HIGHER DOSES and more AVAILABLE drugs to them. They were good in their time. The politics of BBDG then are no different then the politics of BBDG now. Today bbdr's have a huge variety of drugs to their diposal. Do not underestimate the extreme doses taken by pros today compared to those of yesteryear.
PB
-
That is why I was asking why no doz but the Arnold of 81.
bc you are wrong about dorian.
besides, its arnold of 80, not 81.
-
The worst Mr. Olympia of all time would have been articulaShawn Ray if he had mistakenly won it by convincing the judges to take him seriously.
-
bc you are wrong about dorian.
besides, its arnold of 80, not 81.
I was typing fast while at work. People knew what I meant you twit. Doz belongs on that list for his last win. He looked like total shit. This coming from a Yates fan.
Hope this helps.
-
bc you are wrong about dorian.
besides, its arnold of 80, not 81.
Hell, Arnold of 1980 is better than Dorian any year. But I could be biased. ;D
-
1-columbu
2-jay culter
the rest were amazing..except maybe the later years of dorian..his back was still amazing though
-
1-columbu
2-jay culter
the rest were amazing..except maybe the later years of dorian..his back was still amazing though
you think chris dickersuck was amazing??
-
lol i've never even seen pics of him
hes that black guy right...mr. O before dorian
-
lol i've never even seen pics of him
hes that black guy right...mr. O before dorian
::)
-
Whats worse is that even though Jay in respect to other Mr. O's may be considered to be not that 'great'.
He was the obvious winner last september.
He isnt that great. He beat Ronnie Coleman when he was off. Any preview and any bb fan, writer, or current IFBB pro would tell you Cutlers only chance of beating Ronnie is when Ronnie beats himself. Think about it overall. Does Jay have a better physique when BOTH are 100 percent? Hell no. Jay is a phenomenal bodybuilder but if you take Ronnie out of the picture and put Jay up against the other top physiques in bodybuilding its as plain as the eye can see that he is beatable. Ronnie in his peak was flat out unbeatable and dont bring the bullshit up about calves and abs. So what? Turn to the rear and he WAS lights out. Cutler took 6 years to get his back up to par. But Cutler isnt the worst Mr. O ever. He has won too many legit pro shows to be considered the worse.
-
Columbo - 1981.
Without question in 1981 his winning the O was the absolute worst of all time. Now in the 70's he desrved his top spots, but after the knee injury, his quads were horrible.
-
Cutler won fair and square this year at the Olympia. I dunno about the next 2 or 3 shows though ---- he didn't look as good, and Markus and Ronnie had improved greatly.
911 was an Inside Job (http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-5946593973848835726&q=loose+change&hl=en)
-
Franco Columbu was by far the worst, that 81 Olympia was a joke. I feel for Danny Padilla and Tom Platz, because they could of easily won that competion. Some say it was the best Platz ever looked.
-
Yates was the worst : he killed the BBing evolution, towards the degradation
-
Here's my list of worst:
1. Columbo - no question. He should never have been Mr. O
2. Dickerson - too small
3. Dorian - post bicep tear
Here's my list of the best Mr. Olympia physique (ignoring drug usage and era in which champion competed)
1. Ronnie - 1998-99
2. Dorian - 1993
3. Arnold - 1974
4. Haney
5. Cutler - 2006
6. Samir - 1983
7. Sergio
8. Zane
9. Larry Scott
10. Dickerson
11. Franco
-
cutler and colombu are the worst olympias ever..then comes larry scott.
-
Chris Dickerson: Huge elbow, puny arms.
-
his elbow is kind of freaky.....
but so were his calves.
-
Dickerson sucked.
But Jay Cockler isn't very much better either.
Personally, i hate that british white trash asshole Dorian. Never seen anyone uglier in my life, well except Miss Karen and TA that is.
-
easily the worst.
how many guyys do you have at your gym that are at least this muscular??....about 5 at mine.
-
easily the worst.
how many guyys do you have at your gym that are at least this muscular??....about 5 at mine.
hahaa, candidate, you are fat asshole!!
Zane is THE chick magnet!! Send Dorian, Coleman and Zane to a beach and see who's body scores the most chicks!
Zane is a god!
-
hahaa, candidate, you are fat asshole!!
Zane is THE chick magnet!! Send Dorian, Coleman and Zane to a beach and see who's body scores the most chicks!
Zane is a god!
what does picking up "chicks" have to do with bodybuilding??
thanks for proving my point, jackass.
-
hahaa, candidate, you are fat asshole!!
Zane is THE chick magnet!! Send Dorian, Coleman and Zane to a beach and see who's body scores the most chicks!
Zane is a god!
What's funny....
is Zane has been with the same girl (Christine) right out of High School.
I would bet....he's never been with another.
-
what does picking up "chicks" have to do with bodybuilding??
thanks for proving my point, jackass.
picking up chicks, well...
i think BB is about the most pleasing bodies, aesthetics and a healthy sportive look.
Zane has all that, he was lean and nice to look at.
-
picking up chicks, well...
i think BB is about the most pleasing bodies, aesthetics and a healthy sportive look.
Zane has all that, he was lean and nice to look at.
bodybuilding is about who can bring the most excaggerated form of the human body possible.
-
I don't understand... why isn't "Ronnie Coleman" one of the choices?
-
bodybuilding is about who can bring the most excaggerated form of the human body possible.
no. definetly not.
Otherwise your fat ass must be mr olympia.
-
I don't understand... why isn't "Ronnie Coleman" one of the choices?
He's too small & too pretty