Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Bodybuilding Boards => Nutrition, Products & Supplements Info => Topic started by: Lugar on December 17, 2006, 08:13:32 AM
-
Good preworkout? Why do most shun fruit? Is this something that should be nixed in a diet to get ripped and massive? Little insight would be great.....is an apple the best choice of fruit when trying to stay/get lean? Maybe 8-10 weeks out?
-
Good preworkout? Why do most shun fruit? Is this something that should be nixed in a diet to get ripped and massive? Little insight would be great.....is an apple the best choice of fruit when trying to stay/get lean? Maybe 8-10 weeks out?
I eat fruit for one BIG reason, it kills the sweet tooth, I find if i eat fruit after a workout, i don't go looking for junk later on.
-
you want to stay or get lean? ??? ::)
-
Good preworkout? Why do most shun fruit? Is this something that should be nixed in a diet to get ripped and massive? Little insight would be great.....is an apple the best choice of fruit when trying to stay/get lean? Maybe 8-10 weeks out?
Lugar, man, I respect U and U are too smart and have been around 2 long to ask this question:
1) Post work out you want SIMPLE carbs (dextrose, maltodextrin, sucrose, white flour); FRUCTOSE is not a simple sugar, plain and simple;
2) FRUCTOSE (aka FRUIT SUGAR) at any time, is not a good choice, I've posted the research before, you can't get lean on SUGAR.
C'mon man. I respect U and your prior posts. What gives??????
-
apples are good pre workout. i your buking, eat it with some oatmeal about an hour and a half before you train...if your cutting, just eat the apple, and do it about 20 minutes before you train.
-
see why i get confused???
-
see why i get confused???
I owe you an apology- I misread your post and thought you were talking about post workout options. I still say, however, that for pre-workout you can get the type of carbs you need to sustain a workout (salad, cruciferous vegetables, sweet potato)without consuming fructose.
-
all good....so fructose is truly a no-no in the bodybuilding world.......dropped it as of today..thnx.
-
all good....so fructose is truly a no-no in the bodybuilding world.......dropped it as of today..thnx.
I don't think there is a consensus necessarily. The pro-fruit lobby will probably weigh in later. But look at it this way, there are other ways to get the type of carbs that fruit provides without fructose, so why risk it?
-
Lets say I do pro fat preworkout....like a blend and some nuts......what is your thoery on a dext/pro DURING shake...?
-
Lets say I do pro fat preworkout....like a blend and some nuts......what is your thoery on a dext/pro DURING shake...?
I worry about having a energy crash if I was to spike insulin with dextrose during the workout. I would stick to whey during and then immediate dextrose/maltodextrin whey pwo.
-
I'd be curious to know what changes you have made since June.
-
Lugar, man, I respect U and U are too smart and have been around 2 long to ask this question:
1) Post work out you want SIMPLE carbs (dextrose, maltodextrin, sucrose, white flour); FRUCTOSE is not a simple sugar, plain and simple;
2) FRUCTOSE (aka FRUIT SUGAR) at any time, is not a good choice, I've posted the research before, you can't get lean on SUGAR.
C'mon man. I respect U and your prior posts. What gives??????
FRUCTOSE is NOT a simple sugar? It is a MONOSACCHARIDE, therefore a simple sugar, plain and simple.
-
I think he meant High GI sugar. Simple/complex really does not tell the whole story when it comes to carbs.
-
Does that mean that sugars may have high/ low GI, regardless of their complexity? The problem is that there is so much misinformation on the Internet, especially with definitions. Do you know any reliable sources?
-
Lugar, man, I respect U and U are too smart and have been around 2 long to ask this question:
you can't get lean on SUGAR.
Getting lean is the last thing someone in this condition should think about.
-
The pro-fruit lobby will probably weigh in later. But look at it this way, there are other ways to get the type of carbs that fruit provides without fructose, so why risk it?
all good....so fructose is truly a no-no in the bodybuilding world.......dropped it as of today..thnx.
OMG people! :o You have got to be kidding! :o Eliminating fruit from ones normal daily diet is absurd. We’re not talking about contest prep (in which everything changes). Fruit is very nutritious, full of vitamins, minerals, fiber, low in calories, loaded with important phytochemicals (micronutrients that are beneficial to bodybuilders). When you eliminate fruit from your diet, you not only eliminate the fructose and other sugars that fruit contains, but you also eliminate beneficial nutrients that help support growth.
Yes, when you take in fructose, it must first travel to the liver before it can be converted to glycogen. The problem arises when your liver glycogen levels are full. At this point, fructose gets converted to fat and is stored. Since it’s hard to know when your liver glycogen stores are full, many misinformed people avoid fruit altogether. Such extreme measures is actually counterproductive. Eat it first thing in the morning, when your liver glycogen levels are low (because your body has used them as an energy source while you slept). With low liver glycogen levels, your body looks to your muscles and begins to break them down for energy. When you eat fruit immediately upon waking, you provide your body with an alternate energy source, which helps end muscle catabolism.
Midnite, quite frankly, I’m surprised, I thought you had a better understanding of overall nutrition, however, this statement worries me FRUCTOSE (aka FRUIT SUGAR) at any time, is not a good choice
Lugar, as mentioned numerous times before, by several people, you’ve got bigger issues than worrying about eating a piece or two of fruit a day.
-
OMG people! :o You have got to be kidding! :o Eliminating fruit from ones normal daily diet is absurd. We’re not talking about contest prep (in which everything changes). Fruit is very nutritious, full of vitamins, minerals, fiber, low in calories, loaded with important phytochemicals (micronutrients that are beneficial to bodybuilders). When you eliminate fruit from your diet, you not only eliminate the fructose and other sugars that fruit contains, but you also eliminate beneficial nutrients that help support growth.
Yes, when you take in fructose, it must first travel to the liver before it can be converted to glycogen. The problem arises when your liver glycogen levels are full. At this point, fructose gets converted to fat and is stored. Since it’s hard to know when your liver glycogen stores are full, many misinformed people avoid fruit altogether. Such extreme measures is actually counterproductive. Eat it first thing in the morning, when your liver glycogen levels are low (because your body has used them as an energy source while you slept). With low liver glycogen levels, your body looks to your muscles and begins to break them down for energy. When you eat fruit immediately upon waking, you provide your body with an alternate energy source, which helps end muscle catabolism.
Midnite, quite frankly, I’m surprised, I thought you had a better understanding of overall nutrition, however, this statement worries me
Lugar, as mentioned numerous times before, by several people, you’ve got bigger issues than worrying about eating a piece or two of fruit a day.
Great explanation.
-
Completely agree with Princess L, unless you have a very specific reason eg. competition to worry about you should not eliminate something as important as fruit from your diet!
-
Lugar, as mentioned numerous times before, by several people, you’ve got bigger issues than worrying about eating a piece or two of fruit a day.
I'm glad someone else is also telling him this as well.
-
I'm getting much better...actually up 10lbs since that last pic.....toned down cardio to just a walk in the morning with the dog....my theory is why not get the BEST food for all aspects.....We all want to be big, and lean too...if I can keep SOME of my cuts during my bulking phase it'll be a lot easier to cope with mentally....which I am doing thus far......so, if an apple preowrkout with my protein shake will blur my cuts a little more than let's say a fat source like almonds or peanuts and or a different carb source, like oats or even dry oats, then that's the route I'd like to go.....staying cut while eting an apple or two jsut doesnt seem to go hand in hand...
My other half of the equation is the DURING shake....I agree about the insulin rush/crash, but am wondering what experiences people have had...esp. if you can't get a meal in for 1-2 hours post.......
-
I used to avoid fruit when training for competition. However, in 12 months, I have lost 30lbs of fat, gained some muscle and got in near competition shape. I was, and still am eating raisins for breakfast, blueberries mid morning, a glass of Diet V8 Splash with added fiber powder before lunch, and an apple at lunch time. Do not fear fruit. It's good for ya.
-
I;m not saying I am avoiding or scared of fruit...I'm just saying and others are agreeing that there are BETTER sources of carbs to stay lean/shredded........no one ths far says they eat fruit daily and maintain sub 10%......
-
I;m not saying I am avoiding or scared of fruit...I'm just saying and others are agreeing that there are BETTER sources of carbs to stay lean/shredded........no one ths far says they eat fruit daily and maintain sub 10%......
Well, here you go: I eat fruit daily and my body fat is 8%.
-
pic?
-
Midnite, quite frankly, I’m surprised, I thought you had a better understanding of overall nutrition, however, this statement worries me
Thanks for the (sort of) compliment. Hey, I learn something on this board every day. And one thing I've learned since I started on this board, is there's always someone who knows something you don't. So I'm reading everything everyone has to say and taking it all in. If I can get complex carbs, fiber, vitamins, antoi-xoxidents minerals, etc. from vegetables, which I eat plenty of, why not avoid fructose in the form of fruit?
-
pic?
No, no pic. I'm not at liberty to reveal my identity. I'd get in trouble here at work so I must remain anonymous. Just give it a try like I did. As I said, I used to avoid fruit too. As I learned more about nutrition, I saw no good reason why something as healthy as fruit could ruin my competition diet. I gave it a try and it worked.
-
No, no pic. I'm not at liberty to reveal my identity. I'd get in trouble here at work so I must remain anonymous. Just give it a try like I did. As I said, I used to avoid fruit too. As I learned more about nutrition, I saw no good reason why something as healthy as fruit could ruin my competition diet. I gave it a try and it worked.
I did not know you competed. Like I said above, I'm always learning on this board and you know I respect your opinion. So I'm curious, can't I get all of the benefits of fruit by vegetable consumption and in the meantime avoid fructose?
-
I did not know you competed. Like I said above, I'm always learning on this board and you know I respect your opinion. So I'm curious, can't I get all of the benefits of fruit by vegetable consumption and in the meantime avoid fructose?
In my opinion, vegetables are better since they are lower in calories than fruit so you can eat more and not worry about going over your daily calorie limit. With fruit, I do have to watch my portions. I just hate vegetables. I wish I liked vegetables more. Broccoli and green beans are great for you, but I hate them.
-
In my opinion, vegetables are better since they are lower in calories than fruit so you can eat more and not worry about going over your daily calorie limit. With fruit, I do have to watch my portions. I just hate vegetables. I wish I liked vegetables more. Broccoli and green beans are great for you, but I hate them.
I agree that if you're not consuming vegetables for reasons of taste or whatever, then fruit consumption in moderation would be part of a healthy bodybuilding diet. I am interested in whether anyone has an opinion on the board that fruit provides something desirable that vegetables can't. I posed that question to Princess above and I'm interested in her response or if anyone else wants to weigh in.
-
I'm getting much better...actually up 10lbs since that last pic.....toned down cardio to just a walk in the morning with the dog...
This is a good start.
Thanks for the (sort of) compliment. Hey, I learn something on this board every day. And one thing I've learned since I started on this board, is there's always someone who knows something you don't. So I'm reading everything everyone has to say and taking it all in. If I can get complex carbs, fiber, vitamins, antoi-xoxidents minerals, etc. from vegetables, which I eat plenty of, why not avoid fructose in the form of fruit?
Read this again
Yes, when you take in fructose, it must first travel to the liver before it can be converted to glycogen. The problem arises when your liver glycogen levels are full. At this point, fructose gets converted to fat and is stored. Since it’s hard to know when your liver glycogen stores are full, many misinformed people avoid fruit altogether.
Glycogen storage in avg. body
From Costill & Wilmore's Physiology of Sport & Exercise, 2nd Ed:
Liver glycogen: 110g
Muscle glycogen: 250g
Glucose in body fluids: 15g
Note: the typical midsize fruit has 7g fructose, up to 12g or so if you go for a big banana.
I agree that if you're not consuming vegetables for reasons of taste or whatever, then fruit consumption in moderation would be part of a healthy bodybuilding diet. I am interested in whether anyone has an opinion on the board that fruit provides something desirable that vegetables can't. I posed that question to Princess above and I'm interested in her response or if anyone else wants to weigh in.
Interesting question. I’m sure the answer is out there somewhere, but I’m too lazy to look for it right now. All of my resource material is in another room.
Here are some tidbits…
http://www.mdsupport.org/library/antiox.html
http://altmedicine.about.com/cs/supplements/a/antioxidants.htm
16 FAMOUS PHYTOS
Currently, these are the most popular phytos that are known for their powerful antioxidant, anticancer, and heart disease protective properties. We call them "phytomins."
PHYTOMINS FOOD SOURCE Carotenoids (alpha carotene, beta carotene, and lutin) yellow-orange fruits and vegetables: carrots, cantaloupe, papaya, pumpkin, squash, sweet potatoes, broccoli, dried apricots, asparagus, kale, green leafy vegetables, peppers Lycopene tomatoes, tomato paste, tomato juice, guava, pink grapefruit, watermelon Beta cryptozanthin tangerines, papaya, oranges, peaches, mangoes, nectarines Flavonoids soy, green tea, tomatoes, sweet potatoes, cruciferous vegetables, citrus fruits, red wine, red grapes, onions Indoles cruciferous vegetables Sulforaphane cruciferous vegetables Isoflavones legumes (beans, peas, lentils), soy products Allicin garlic, onions Genistein soy products (e.g., tofu) Polyphenols green tea Anthocyanins wild blueberries, bilberries, black berries, Limonoids citrus fruits Sterols cruciferous vegetables, cucumbers, squash, sweet potatoes, soy foods, eggplant, whole grains, tomatoes Capsaicin chili peppers Elegiac acid Strawberries Lignans nuts and seeds.
TOP TWELVE PHYTO FOODS
While nearly all plant foods contain health-promoting phytochemicals, the following are the most phyto-dense food sources:
1. Soy
2. Tomato
3. Broccoli
4. Garlic
5. Flax seeds
6. Citrus fruits
7. Melons: cantaloupe, watermelon
8. Pink grapefruit
9. Blueberries
10. Sweet potatoes
11. Chili peppers
12. Legumes: beans, and lentils
Honorable mention: green tea, red grapes, papaya, carrots, kale, nuts and seeds, eggplant, artichoke, cabbage, brussel sprouts, onions, apples, cauliflower, dried apricots, pumpkin, squash, spinach, mangos, and shiitake mushrooms.
-
Good post Princess....although I am still a tad iffy on whther to include fruits as part of a precontest diet or photoshoot, it appears they are extremely benefitial in more ways then one. Do they tend to make yuou hold more water than let's say, yams, sweet tators, oats......what is your view on them? Berries and apples? I switched to peanuts and almonds preworkout with my protein shake for sustained energy and because of the neg. reps that fructose got, but it appears I should go back? Thoughts?
-
Interesting question. I’m sure the answer is out there somewhere, but I’m too lazy to look for it right now. All of my resource material is in another room.
I never thought I would see the day. I had taken your tirelesss research efforts for granted.
-
Good post Princess....although I am still a tad iffy on whther to include fruits as part of a precontest diet or photoshoot, it appears they are extremely benefitial in more ways then one. Do they tend to make yuou hold more water than let's say, yams, sweet tators, oats......what is your view on them? Berries and apples? I switched to peanuts and almonds preworkout with my protein shake for sustained energy and because of the neg. reps that fructose got, but it appears I should go back? Thoughts?
For the short duration of a precontest diet, then it's wise to cut the fruit, but only around the 6 week out mark. Berries are an excellent source of phytonutrients and antioxidants. Fructose is not the only sugar in fruit btw.
-
tirelesss research efforts
The things I do for my fellow GBr's :-*
-
For the short duration of a precontest diet, then it's wise to cut the fruit, but only around the 6 week out mark.
Why?
-
For the short duration of a precontest diet, then it's wise to cut the fruit, but only around the 6 week out mark. Berries are an excellent source of phytonutrients and antioxidants. Fructose is not the only sugar in fruit btw.
I guess my theory is, why take in anything (aside from a good cheat or two) off season, when you wouldnt during precomp? Just seems to better choices, ie. rice, beans, oats......im not a huge fan and wont run from fruit, lol, but I am not going to make it a staple pretraining as my trainer advises....
Although, it was rated number 1, for something....fiber, vitam, mineral content?
-
I always eat an apple after my workout. After the first workout meal I eat one tomatoe and one orange.
Simple carbs and antioxidant are necessary to promote a good recovery!
-
Top 10 food choices to optimize results from training
http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?topic=116970.msg1693330#msg1693330
-
I always eat an apple after my workout. After the first workout meal I eat one tomatoe and one orange.
Simple carbs and antioxidant are necessary to promote a good recovery!
Apples: A great source of pectin; a natural fiber that is essential to healthy regulation of blood fats and cholesterol profiles. However, this material also helps stabilize blood glucose (and insulin) levels.
-
Apples: A great source of pectin; a natural fiber that is essential to healthy regulation of blood fats and cholesterol profiles. However, this material also helps stabilize blood glucose (and insulin) levels.
By the way, though I eat fruit, I never eat it post workout. Post workout I have a protein blend (Whey + Casein + Egg) and 20g glutamine powder. If what you are looking for post workout is an insulin response, apples or anything high in fiber is not a good choice.
-
Thanks for the "10 foods..." link, loco. And you, Princess L - good stuff.
Oh Midnight, I'm so disappointed. ;)
-
You are welcome!
-
Oh Midnight [sic], I'm so disappointed. ;)
I guess I'll have to find the strength to go on, somehow . . .
-
You should eat some fruit for the fiber and the nutrients.