Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: Stavios on February 19, 2008, 11:36:20 AM
-
Before comparing the pics, I had in mind that Dexter was much more complete and would most likely win the Arnold Classic. But after those comparaisons, I think Phil is just as complete ( even from the back !) and much freakier !!
Dexter only wins the Abs and tighs and the Rear lat spread, I give all the other poses to Phil
-
Ching Chong Walla Walla Bing Bang
-
I was thinkin dexter would win also, after seeing those, i'm not so sure. Its actually probably going to be a race for second between those two. Kamali has first place locked down. He's coming in his best condition EVER ;D
-
Anyone think that Heath needs a fuller chest? It seems narrow to me.
Otherwise, if he can come in with this conditioning, I think Heath has a great chance of taking the Arnold and making a strong showing in the top three at the Olympia.
-
I feel sorry for Dex, game over!
-
Anyone think that Heath needs a fuller chest? It seems narrow to me.
Otherwise, if he can come in with this conditioning, I think Heath has a great chance of taking the Arnold and making a strong showing in the top three at the Olympia.
hopefully, phil heath can spread his clavicle bones by 4 inches for the Arnold.
-
It will be close, dex is holding his own next to phil, i like dexters side chest shot better then phils, you also have to remember phil is about 15lbs heavier then dex.
-
Dex looks better overall. Bodypart for bodypart it's heeth.
-
It will be close, dex is holding his own next to phil, i like dexters side chest shot better then phils, you also have to remember phil is about 15lbs heavier then dex.
I tought Dexter was 230 ?
Tomanator said that Phil was 230 onstage at the Ironman
-
Dexter, like Wolf, has high lats and mediocre calves. But nobody has Wolf's width.
-
I tought Dexter was 230 ?
Tomanator said that Phil was 230 onstage at the Ironman
I doubt dex competes at 230lbs, more like 220lbs max. Phil was in the upper 230's on stage.
-
Nah Dex looks better. Phil has a better most muscular though. Plus that was Phils best ever conditioning. You have to make sure you get pics with Dex's best ever as well.
-
Phil is better.
-
also dex has a way better abs and thight pose then phil, phils abs r not very pleasing to the eye.
-
Remember the Ironman lighting is deceiving as said on PBW. Its more about conditioning this time not size. You can't deny though that Phil's arms, calves, and overall size is superior to Dexter's in those shots. Can't wait to see if Kai and Melvin chisels their new mass like Phil has.
-
also dex has a way better abs and thight pose then phil, phils abs r not very pleasing to the eye.
Phils abs are not very pleasing to the eye??? Maybe to yours only, nuthing wrong with them to me ;D
-
Dex is much drier than heath in the pics.
-
Dex is much drier than heath in the pics.
Maybe Dex used a bigger towel.
-
no way does dex look drier than phil. From the front look at phils leg detail compared to dex
-
Good post. Definitely going to be a battle and who shows up on top of their game.
-
no way does dex look drier than phil. From the front look at phils leg detail compared to dex
I think Phil has set a new standard for dryness, the only person to have had this type of dryness is Pavol Jablonicky, but he was no where near as freaky as Phil
-
Nah Dex looks better. Phil has a better most muscular though. Plus that was Phils best ever conditioning. You have to make sure you get pics with Dex's best ever as well.
I tried to be the most non-biased possible while choosing the pics
I don't feel Dexter really has a "Best ever", he always looks the same
his best condition was at the 2003 Olympia but he was a little smaller too
I think it will be very close between them !
-
The major factor is the Dex have very poor thigh sweep while Phil have great legs.Unless Phil screws up his conditon and Dex comes in dialed it will be game over for Dex.
-
I give the edge to Phil, but like Dexter's ab and side-chest shots.
-
I say Phil. His lower body is much better than Dexter.
-
Damn, that's tough. Good photos though. I'm gonna have to go with Phil. Not by much, but that's my choice.
Conditioning: Same
Size: Phil
Shape: Dexter
*Phil has calves & Dexter doesn't. If it comes down to the wire, that will play a factor at the ASC.
-
*Phil has calves & Dexter doesn't. If it comes down to the wire, that will play a factor at the ASC.
A reminisce of Arnold vs. Chet at the '66 NABBA Universe.
-
Before comparing the pics, I had in mind that Dexter was much more complete and would most likely win the Arnold Classic. But after those comparaisons, I think Phil is just as complete ( even from the back !) and much freakier !!
Dexter only wins the Abs and tighs and the Rear lat spread, I give all the other poses to Phil
Good job puttin' this together. Thanks for doin' the work :)
-
judging by those pics Heath would win.
-
Good job puttin' this together. Thanks for doin' the work :)
No problemo :D
-
I think Phil will take it unless Melvin dials it in perfect;
but he is known for ham/glute conditioning problems.
He looked huge though with his 2 week AC preview.
I am with Bob and Dan when they said Phil has everything
Dexter has and then some.
I don't think however good Phil is @ the Arnold the pics will
look as good because the lighting at the Ironman has always
been better than at the Arnold.
-
I think Phil has set a new standard for dryness, the only person to have had this type of dryness is Pavol Jablonicky, but he was no where near as freaky as Phil
andres munzer...he is dead though.
-
Mr. Phil "Red Bird Chicken" Heath would win!!
-
Last year the judges didnt play into the hype and Phil got 5th. He has put it on quick but it aint mature. Cycles please. Melvin is the dark horse in the show. If he is better than his last O showing...he should win. Dont tell me Phil has better structure. Again...Phil is good but this is complete overkill.
1. Dex or Melvin
3. Phil or Warren
5. Badell or somebody
Phil edged Badell like he did Charles at the CO Pro.
-
Phil is better in those photos. But, let's be fair. The Dex photos are last year. Last year photos of Phil would not compare to Dex's.
-
Phil is better in those photos. But, let's be fair. The Dex photos are last year. Last year photos of Phil would not compare to Dex's.
yeah but let's be fair
wheter it is 2004-2005-2006-2007-2008, Dexter looks the same
-
yeah but let's be fair
wheter it is 2004-2005-2006-2007-2008, Dexter looks the same
yes and no.
he goes up so slow, you don't see the change.
also a guy like him, with that metabolism, he cant put on size so easily...probably inches up 2-4 pounds a year at best...this is why he LOOKS the same year after year. although he comes in slightly heavier each time.
props to him for not ruining his shape.
although he's not improving as quickly as some other guys do.
its 50/50.
one one side...its more and more quality to his muscles.
-
yeah but let's be fair
wheter it is 2004-2005-2006-2007-2008, Dexter looks the same
Just what a was about to say, dexter have not done any progress in about 5 years...game over amigo!