Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: Sherief Shalaby on September 12, 2008, 12:00:14 AM
-
1 or 2??..
-
jay looks like he's holding alot more than water in that second pic.
-
1, alot drier and harder, lats don't look as full but better condation overall.
-
jay looks like he's holding alot more than water in that second pic.
So u like the first pic.?
-
1, alot drier and harder, lats don't look as full but better condation overall.
I agree..
-
1
-
In the first pic its Nasser.
-
is that dillet?
-
I see where this is going ;)
-
I see where this is going ;)
LOL.. So now it's clear the first is Nasser (who was known for his "bad" back).. And here everybody sees his back better than Jay Cutler's back (the current Mr. Olympia and whose back has been chosen by flex mag. as one of the best ever!!!).. By the way Jay's pic. is from the last Mr. Olympia!!!..
-
is that dillet?
Nooooo,.. Dillet's back was not that wide.. By the way like Nasser, Dillet's main weakness was his back ..
-
jay condition always sucks
-
Not the best pic of Jay but Jay had a much better back than Nasser for sure.
-
Both have different strengths in that pic. Jay's lats own Nasser's, however Nasser's lower back details owns Jay's. It's about even.
-
Both have different strengths in that pic. Jay's lats own Nasser's, however Nasser's lower back details owns Jay's. It's about even.
Not the best pic of Jay but Jay had a much better back than Nasser for sure.
The point of the thread is not to simply compare who has a better back between the two, but to show that Nasser's worst bodypart is comparable to the current Mr. Olympia's best (or one of his best) bodyparts. What does that tell you about the competition in the late 90's compared to today?
-
the second back is joel stubbs.
-
The point of the thread is not to simply compare who has a better back between the two, but to show that Nasser's worst bodypart is comparable to the current Mr. Olympia's best (or one of his best) bodyparts. What does that tell you about the competition in the late 90's compared to today?
Exactly man.. You got me right.. If I wanted to show Nasser's superiority over Jay I would simply put legs or chest or arms comparisons.. But as you say even Nasser's worst body part can be comparable with the same body part of the current Mr. Olympia.. By the way at his best I know that Jay's back would be better than Nasser's but this is the only muscle he can beat Nasser at.. Nasser was much better in all the other muscles with no exception..
-
Nice try terrorist, but they hold the pose entirely differently so it is very difficult to compare. But Jay has nassoil by a mile. Nassoil was a has been, Jay is Mr. O, something Nassoil will never be...
-
+1 on joel stubbs.
-
Jay's rear lat spread is shit, it always has been. It never has any detail.
His back double bi is his money shot and it's also the pose he ruined his physique to get.
-
yeah, joel stubbs
-
thats not joel stubbs.
-
Funny how the initial replies were supportive of the "left pic" but once it got revealed that it's Nasser vs. Jay the replies changed 180 degrees ;)
-
watch them on video or live and see how completely flat nassers back looks and the fact that jays looks turtle shell thick 8)
-
Nice try terrorist, but they hold the pose entirely differently so it is very difficult to compare. But Jay has nassoil by a mile. Nassoil was a has been, Jay is Mr. O, something Nassoil will never be...
Hold it differently so u can't compare!!!.. LOL.. At least u can compare their conditions stupid kid..
-
Funny how the initial replies were supportive of the "left pic" but once it got revealed that it's Nasser vs. Jay the replies changed 180 degrees ;)
Believe me I was expecting this :)..
-
Exactly man.. You got me right.. If I wanted to show Nasser's superiority over Jay I would simply put legs or chest or arms comparisons.. But as you say even Nasser's worst body part can be comparable with the same body part of the current Mr. Olympia.. By the way at his best I know that Jay's back would be better than Nasser's but this is the only muscle he can beat Nasser at.. Nasser was much better in all the other muscles with no exception..
With a name like Sherrif..Why am I not surprised? Believe it or not..This is all about race..You "people " don't have many success stories.. So you kill the shit out of anyone who you think,,has accomplished anything.. In this case ..A drug induced idiot..who happens to be of your nationality.
-
With a name like Sherrif..Why am I not surprised? Believe it or not..This is all about race..You "people " don't have many success stories.. So you kill the shit out of anyone who you think,,has accomplished anything.. In this case ..A drug induced idiot..who happens to be of your nationality.
For starters Nasser and I are not of the same race, he's half Arab and half Slavic, and I'm East Indian. Yes, we share the fact that we are both Muslims, but still using your logic I should also be a fan of Mostafa Muhammad, Ahmed Haider, Mo Benaziza, even King Kamali. How do you explain that? There's a lot more to Nasser that makes us fans of his, yet some people always have to bring race into the equation.
-
Oh since you brought up Mustafa, im just going to say that he is better than nasser. He has no weakness. I don't care what you say.
I agree, Mustafa was a much better bodybuilder. He got robbed many times.
-
I agree, Mustafa was a much better bodybuilder. He got robbed many times.
So what would cause him to get robbed? Are you finally admitting that there are judging biases, which would imply that Yates would not the better bodybuilder simply due to contest placings?
-
you are all wrong
the first pic has bad quality so it automatically looks better...if the first pic had the same quality it would be another story...
-
Funny how the initial replies were supportive of the "left pic" but once it got revealed that it's Nasser vs. Jay the replies changed 180 degrees ;)
There is some truth to this to be fair.
-
For starters Nasser and I are not of the same race, he's half Arab and half Slavic, and I'm East Indian. Yes, we share the fact that we are both Muslims, but still using your logic I should also be a fan of Mostafa Muhammad, Ahmed Haider, Mo Benaziza, even King Kamali. How do you explain that? There's a lot more to Nasser that makes us fans of his, yet some people always have to bring race into the equation.
Honestly ..If there is anything about him that's admirable...? I've yet to see it ..Therefore,I thought the only logical thing would be race or religion. There are way more accomplished bodybuilders out there ..Why him Specifically? Like I always say..Great men do great things..You Nassoil members are always talking about this "great man ...What has he done that makes him so great?
-
So what would cause him to get robbed? Are you finally admitting that there are judging biases, which would imply that Yates would not the better bodybuilder simply due to contest placings?
Its next to impossible to fix a contest , if you knew how they were judged you'd know this.
-
Its next to impossible to fix a contest , if you knew how they were judged you'd know this.
Horrible... when the obsessed fans have to make up excuses for their crushes ..
-
With a name like Sherrif..Why am I not surprised? Believe it or not..This is all about race..You "people " don't have many success stories.. So you kill the shit out of anyone who you think,,has accomplished anything.. In this case ..A drug induced idiot..who happens to be of your nationality.
With a name like "Worm" I prefer to leave u die with ur tiny brain than trying to clarify anything to you.. I am sorry to say that but I am really fed up with ppl like you who just come to say stupid things.. MAN TRY TO THINK BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING!!!.. U c I am racist just coz I feel that Nasser's back was better than Jays!!!.. In another comparison I said that Dorian at his best would beat Nasser at his best and by the way some other stupid kids accused me of being Dorian blind follower!!..
-
Nasser had an underdeveloped lowerback for a man of his size. It killed him in back poses.
End of story.
-
hahaha post a pic of jay in decent condition and he kills nasser's shit hole of a back. ;D
-
Funny how the initial replies were supportive of the "left pic" but once it got revealed that it's Nasser vs. Jay the replies changed 180 degrees ;)
you're assuming that we didnt know who they were!
i said left pic, and i still say left pic; jay is very smooth. the picture on the left does have much higher contrast though, to be fair.
-
yeah, joel stubbs
This is Joel and the Xman and darrem Charles -
-
1 or 2??..
You can't base who has a better back on one single picture from varying quality , lighting and scale , you have to break down the back into all the groups individually and the assess them as a whole and you can't determine who has a better back by one contest either .
-
you are all wrong
the first pic has bad quality so it automatically looks better...if the first pic had the same quality it would be another story...
????Do u believe urself???.. Very funny opinion..
-
You can't base who has a better back on one single picture from varying quality , lighting and scale , you have to break down the back into all the groups individually and the assess them as a whole and you can't determine who has a better back by one contest either .
I am not comapring them and I already said that at his best Jay's back would be better.. Again most of you didn't understand what I meant..
-
I am not comapring them and I already said that at his best Jay's back would be better.. Again most of you didn't understand what I meant..
You're not comparing them? really what was that side-by-side picture?
-
You're not comparing them? really what was that side-by-side picture?
1- That Nasser's worest part is still comparable to the same part of the current Mr. O.
2- Jay's back is overrated like the reast of him..
-
With a name like "Worm" I prefer to leave u die with ur tiny brain than trying to clarify anything to you.. I am sorry to say that but I am really fed up with ppl like you who just come to say stupid things.. MAN TRY TO THINK BEFORE YOU SAY ANYTHING!!!.. U c I am racist just coz I feel that Nasser's back was better than Jays!!!.. In another comparison I said that Dorian at his best would beat Nasser at his best and by the way some other stupid kids accused me of being Dorian blind follower!!..
Aaaaw..What's wrong Shareese? You're tired of people like me ?? Then leave..Never come back.. Because this isn't the last you heard from me .. Yeah..I do believe all of the team Nassoil are racist,absolutely.!. Why don't you post who you think is better than Nassoil?! Exactly...Everyone Nassoil lost to was better than him...But you muscle worshipping goat Phucking Phags can't seem to come to grips with the reality, that Nassoil is a piece of shiot...SO Phuck you Shareese,,,,,,,and Phuck that hater Nassoil...And Phuck Team NAssoil...Go and help out you're loyal Team members(JTpunani)...You homo's are quick to turn your backs on the wounded,huh?
-
If Jay had better conditioning he would have the edge, but only just.
Jay's back is over-rated. No doubting its good, but its not that good.
All i know is Nasser got screwed over quite a few times...
-
Aaaaw..What's wrong Shareese? You're tired of people like me ?? Then leave..Never come back.. Because this isn't the last you heard from me .. Yeah..I do believe all of the team Nassoil are racist,absolutely.!. Why don't you post who you think is better than Nassoil?! Exactly...Everyone Nassoil lost to was better than him...But you muscle worshipping goat Phucking Phags can't seem to come to grips with the reality, that Nassoil is a piece of shiot...SO Phuck you Shareese,,,,,,,and Phuck that hater Nassoil...And Phuck Team NAssoil...Go and help out you're loyal Team members(JTpunani)...You homo's are quick to turn your backs on the wounded,huh?
I have known from yesterday that you don't have a brain to think but I am sure now that you also don't have eyes to read!!.. I worte that I made another comp. showing that Dorian at his best was better than Nasser so how come I show only his inferiors??.. I don't belong to any team and I am just saying what I really see.. Believe it or not it's up to you..
-
I have known from yesterday that you don't have a brain to think but I am sure now that you also don't have eyes to read!!.. I worte that I made another comp. showing that Dorian at his best was better than Nasser so how come I show only his inferiors??.. I don't belong to any team and I am just saying what I really see.. Believe it or not it's up to you..
It's obvious that acceptance isn't one of your finer qualities... All your doing is reversing the roles ...Bobs does the same thing as you ..only he says Nassoil is better ....But what do both of you have in common when posting ??? NASSOIL!! He always manages to make his way into your posts...Team DL is wise to your trickeries... Quit it ..Or get dealt with ..
-
So what would cause him to get robbed? Are you finally admitting that there are judging biases, which would imply that Yates would not the better bodybuilder simply due to contest placings?
Bobs is spot on, the judging biases in bodybuilding are ridiculous (otherwise how did Paco Bautista ever win a pro show???).....Nasser in his prime >>>>>> Yates (post '93, where he was incredible). I'm not Muslim or Arab or whatever, but lets be serious, Nasser was ROYALLY fucked in '97.
-
Bobs is spot on, the judging biases in bodybuilding are ridiculous (otherwise how did Paco Bautista ever win a pro show???).....Nasser in his prime >>>>>> Yates (post '93, where he was incredible). I'm not Muslim or Arab or whatever, but lets be serious, Nasser was ROYALLY fucked in '97.
Man coz u r not Muslim or Arab the "idiots" here will believe and respect ur opinion.. But when a Muslim and an Arab like me says that Dorian at his best would beat Nasser at his best but Nasser should have beat him in 97 where he competed with no left arm and with bad condition, the idiots call me racist and one of Nasser's blind followers!!.. And again I am still confirming that if Nasser had an average good back like for example Chris Cormier's back or even Kevin Leverone's back he would beat any other guy in his prime.. Still with his "bad" back he was always considered as Dorian's biggest threat at the diff. olympias.. He placed 3rd at Mr. O. 95 but every one wanted to see or read about the contest to see what had happened bet. Dorian and Nasser and not bet. Dorian and Kevin (who placed 2nd).. Even the cover of Flex magazine about the contest showed a Dorian vs. Nasser picture!!.. Same story in 1996 where he was 3rd but still everything was mentioning that he was the crowd favorite guy and that his placing received some of the biggest boos in the history of the sport.. Again "idiots" these are not my words but what I red in the magazines which were not written by Muslims or Arabs.. Sorry for writing so long but really I came here on this forum to exchange memories and opinions with others who like the sport but have been surprised with the lot of aggressive stupid ppl who always get the others wrong and don't respect u when u see things in a diff. way.. And u knw what they may say now??.. They may ask me to leave the forum since I am fed with them!!!!..
-
Someone should post a picture of Jay's back from this past years Olympia.