Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: Bigpump9 on February 21, 2010, 10:38:18 AM
-
I saw the comparison pics and individuals, the judges must of been half blind! pathetic!!
-
Time for Weight Classes = suggested it 5 years ago and Me and My sponsors will assist in the Prize money
-
Mike Liberatore got SCREWED!
-
I totally agree! Melvin was way behind Toney and Hide in legs and hardness.
-
Mike Liberatore got SCREWED!
Yea, but typical "pay your dues first" shit
-
I totally agree! Melvin was way behind Toney and Hide in legs and hardness.
Don't agree, tony was holding some water and legs had a bit of that water-logged look. Although he was much bigger and still looked ok. I think it was pretty close overall
(http://www.flexonline.com/10contests/10phoenix/men/toney_freeman/images/_W5Q9838.jpg)
(http://www.flexonline.com/10contests/10phoenix/men/melvin_anthony/images/_W5Q9463.jpg)
-
Mike Liberatore got SCREWED!
OMG TOTALLY! I am glad i wasnt the only one that sees this! its no brainer!
-
Don't agree, tony was holding some water and legs had a bit of that water-logged look. Although he was much bigger and still looked ok. I think it was pretty close overall
(http://www.flexonline.com/10contests/10phoenix/men/toney_freeman/images/_W5Q9838.jpg)
(http://www.flexonline.com/10contests/10phoenix/men/melvin_anthony/images/_W5Q9463.jpg)
Another best gums award..
-
One of Freeman's legs is bigger than both of Melvin's. How the heck did Melvin A. win? ???
-
One of Freeman's legs is bigger than both of Melvin's. How the heck did Melvin A. win? ???
Great posing ;D
-
paid his dues ::)
-
I agree with all of this. Liberatore got raped. And Toney seemed better than Melvin.
-
where any of you at the show, I was. Melvin was the most complete, best back and most muscular. Toney has no MM pose, his conditioning was off. Take a look.
-
the judges must of been half blind! pathetic!!
X2
-
Thousands of pics here, including comparisons.
http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/2010-phoenix-pro.htm
First of all, it was close to a lot of people. Many had Hidetada winning the contest, including Jay Cutler. Others had Melvin as the close winner, and still others thought Toney Freeman was the overall winner, lacking in some parts, holding water, but still the winner.
Debates were still raging on Sunday morning at the hotel.
Still, congratulation to Melvin for coming into this show, working hard, and earning the victory.
One of the worst judged shows in a while
What do you mean? Create a discussion on why you think so.
-
What do you mean? Create a discussion on why you think so.
Freeman should have won or at worst second.
Hide was half his frickin' size for craps sake.
Liberatore screwed.
Alves gifted 5th.
Should I keep going?
-
Freeman should have won or at worst second.
Hide was half his frickin' size for craps sake.
Liberatore screwed.
Alves gifted 5th.
Should I keep going?
Yeah, keep going...you're pretty funny
-
Yeah, keep going...you're pretty funny
MEN'S BODYBUILDING
1. Melvin Anthony Jr. (agree somewhat)
2. Hidetada Yamagishi
3. Toney Freeman (not usual self)
4. Grigori Atoyan
5. Troy Alves
6. Lionel Beyeke
7. Quincy Taylor
8. Alfonso Del Rio ( ahh noo way)
9. Tarek Elsetouhi (agree)
10. Moe Bannout
11. John Sherman
12. Johnnie Jackson (are u jk?)
13. Franklin Roberson (good structure! but no way)
14. Michael Liberatore (got ripped off)
15. Eddie Abbew
-
I didn't get this guys name, but he was big as a house, albeit a small house! ;D
-
MEN'S BODYBUILDING
1. Melvin Anthony Jr. (agree somewhat) CLEAR WINNER, STOP CRYING ABOUT IT!
2. Hidetada Yamagishi SHOULD HAVE BEEN THIRD OR FOURTH, HE WAS RIPPED, BUT UGLY PHYSIQUE
3. Toney Freeman (not usual self) NO BACK, NO MOST MUSCULAR, NO FIRST PLACE!
4. Grigori Atoyan LOTS OF MUSCLE ON HIM, GREAT BACK
5. Troy Alves GREAT UPPER BODY
6. Lionel Beyeke WHO?
7. Quincy Taylor LOOKED GOOD, NO CALVES
8. Alfonso Del Rio ( ahh noo way) SHOOK TOO MUCH WHEN HE POSED
9. Tarek Elsetouhi (agree) ?
10. Moe Bannout SHOULDERS ARMS AND CHEST
MOST OVERLOOKED -JOHN SHERMAN WTF WERE THE JUDGES LOOKING AT?
11. John Sherman
12. Johnnie Jackson (are u jk?)
13. Franklin Roberson (good structure! but no way)
14. Michael Liberatore (got ripped off)
15. Eddie Abbew
-
I didn't get this guys name, but he was big as a house, albeit a small house! ;D
DOH!
-
(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=320765.0;attach=360772;image)
looking huge...
-
(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=320765.0;attach=360619;image)
the little asian guy on the right should have won.
-
MEN'S BODYBUILDING
1. Melvin Anthony Jr. (agree somewhat)
2. Hidetada Yamagishi
3. Toney Freeman (not usual self)
4. Grigori Atoyan
5. Troy Alves
6. Lionel Beyeke
7. Quincy Taylor
8. Alfonso Del Rio ( ahh noo way)
9. Tarek Elsetouhi (agree)
10. Moe Bannout
11. John Sherman
12. Johnnie Jackson (are u jk?)
13. Franklin Roberson (good structure! but no way)
14. Michael Liberatore (got ripped off)
15. Eddie Abbew
Thanks I missed the whole thing
-
One of the worst
judged music-playing shows in a while ;D
-
CD's skip they need to go back to cassettes. Ez'er to record on and hardly skip.
-
Music was definately a problem at this contest, including replaying Lady Gaga's Bad Romance song over and over, which is now in my head for the last 2 days. I heard that the music person running the CDs decided not to work at the show, which perhaps was the problem for a new person (inexperience).
As for the results, there are always complainers.
Here is the scorecard results
http://www.getbig.com/results/mens/ifbb/phoenixpro.htm
-
Music was definately a problem at this contest, including replaying Lady Gaga's Bad Romance song over and over, which is now in my head for the last 2 days. I heard that the music person running the CDs decided not to work at the show, which perhaps was the problem for a new person (inexperience).
As for the results, there are always complainers.
Here is the scorecard results
http://www.getbig.com/results/mens/ifbb/phoenixpro.htm
How hard can it be to DJ a show, or stick music in?
-
Music was definately a problem at this contest, including replaying Lady Gaga's Bad Romance song over and over, which is now in my head for the last 2 days.
Supposedly someone had the song "Owner of a Lonely Heart" stuck in their head for so long that they had to have brain surgery to stop it. :-X Not sure if it's true though since I see no reference to it on the internet.
-
A blind man could see that Hide should've won.
Freeman looked like nothing special.
-
ROn, it is supposed to be professional bodybuilding.
-
Freeman should have won or at worst second.
Hide was half his frickin' size for craps sake.
Liberatore screwed.
Alves gifted 5th.
Should I keep going?
Hide's placing was payback for him taking a drug bust for higher ups and keeping his mouth shut