Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums

Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: Wiggs on December 02, 2010, 09:52:39 PM

Title: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Wiggs on December 02, 2010, 09:52:39 PM
Don't tread on my thread  assholes...>:(
























































 ;D
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: haider on December 02, 2010, 09:53:06 PM
err... Ronnie?  ???
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Firemuscle on December 02, 2010, 09:57:30 PM
 Everyone knows Dorian Yates was grainier, more symetrical, and had better conditioning than Ronnie Coleman. That torn bicep didn't look too bad, kinda looked cool.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Wiggs on December 02, 2010, 10:01:21 PM
Guys please stop it's only a matter of time before they arrive...
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: haider on December 02, 2010, 10:03:50 PM
Everyone knows Dorian Yates was grainier, more symetrical, and had better conditioning than Ronnie Coleman. That torn bicep didn't look too bad, kinda looked cool.
BULLSHIT Ronnie circa 1999 was the most amazing bodybuilder to ever walk the planet  ::) ::) LOL Dorian with his barrel shaped torso and twig arms was a complete joke!  ::)
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Wiggs on December 02, 2010, 10:04:21 PM
Ron help! :'(
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Firemuscle on December 02, 2010, 10:10:32 PM
BULLSHIT Ronnie circa 1999 was the most amazing bodybuilder to ever walk the planet  ::) ::) LOL Dorian with his barrel shaped torso and twig arms was a complete joke!  ::)

 Yeah right, Ronnie Coleman had a huge GH belly and he was black (gross).

 Worst of all he was a cop. There is no excuse for that.

 Dorian wins.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Ares on December 02, 2010, 10:14:01 PM
Sergio with Arnies biceps/chest would have been the ultimate.. As it stands Arnold at his best still wins.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Wiggs on December 02, 2010, 10:15:16 PM
Sergio with Arnies biceps/chest would have been the ultimate.. As it stands Arnold at his best still wins.

why?
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Firemuscle on December 02, 2010, 10:18:49 PM
 That story about Sergio running out of the weight lifting competition and into the U.S. embassy to escape Cuba was awesome.

 Straight up wetback style.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Ares on December 02, 2010, 10:24:40 PM
why?

His arms/chest just dominate the scene when you see them standing next to each other.  Sergio had a smaller waist and longer all around muscle bellies etc, but Arnold's overall impression is more impressive aside from the Sergio victory pose. I'm not talking the tiny legged 80 Arnold, but his 73-74 condition. Even his calves were thick back then.


Both great obviously, it's a close call.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: tallgerman on December 02, 2010, 10:42:19 PM
No one has a better body than arnold.
Including Ronnie yates and all the blocky shitbags after.

Yes arnold kicks the shit out short ass mutant delts flex wheeler too.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or
Post by: PJim on December 02, 2010, 11:20:35 PM
No one has a better body than arnold.
Including Ronnie yates and all the blocky shitbags after.

Yes arnold kicks the shit out short ass mutant delts flex wheeler too.


No.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: spude on December 03, 2010, 02:42:54 AM
Nubret shits at both of their faces, always rooting for a fellow European!
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: pellius on December 03, 2010, 02:50:23 AM
BULLSHIT Ronnie circa 1999 was the most amazing bodybuilder to ever walk the planet  ::) ::) LOL Dorian with his barrel shaped torso and twig arms was a complete joke!  ::)

2003  Ronnie = Greatest to ever walk the planet
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: flexingtonsteele on December 03, 2010, 02:53:45 AM
Neither.

Nubret in his prime blows em both away.

(http://www.bodybuilding-pics.com/168/images/Serge_NUBRET_86.jpg)
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: JP_RC on December 03, 2010, 05:37:10 AM
why?

Arnold not at his best beat Sergio who was at his best in 1972.

Enough said.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Howard on December 03, 2010, 05:40:35 AM
Arnold not at his best beat Sergio who was at his best in 1972.

Enough said.

It was always an eipic battle, but in the '72 Olympia , in my judgement, Sergio was clearly better.
He was thicker, fuller, better thigh sweep and V taper. Sergio beat Arnold badly in the frontal crab most muscular that that Olympia.
The other time was the 1970 Mr World. Sergio looked like he was on a whole other level of development that show.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: biff on December 03, 2010, 05:59:56 AM
Everyone knows Dorian Yates was grainier, more symetrical, and had better conditioning than Ronnie Coleman. That torn bicep didn't look too bad, kinda looked cool.

plus he had a special something that could never be captured in pictures, somehow

you had to see him in person, then you would see he was really betterer than all the others who appeared better than him in these misleading pictures
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: biff on December 03, 2010, 06:00:56 AM
oh and nubret has the best physique ever
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or
Post by: Parker on December 03, 2010, 06:01:48 AM
Nubret shits at both of their faces, always rooting for a fellow European!
Serge Nubret was from the Caribbean....
But, he was better than both in my opinion. Better combo of size, conditioning and shape...Arnold was hit or miss, and Sergio for most of time was not conditioned...
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: JP_RC on December 03, 2010, 06:02:15 AM
It was always an eipic battle, but in the '72 Olympia , in my judgement, Sergio was clearly better.
He was thicker, fuller, better thigh sweep and V taper. Sergio beat Arnold badly in the frontal crab most muscular that that Olympia.
The other time was the 1970 Mr World. Sergio looked like he was on a whole other level of development that show.

So do you think that contest was a fix?  

Honestly Sergio looked great on his own in 1972, but when he stood next to Arnold it was a different story.
Arnold was just better conditioned with equal size and even bigger in some bodyparts, Sergio had bigger quads and better taper that's it.
Arnold's muscularity was also better.

(http://builtreport.com/1972olympia/035.jpg)



Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Pollux on December 03, 2010, 06:27:39 AM
Well, obviously being Getbig's OFFICIAL Arnold guy, I'm gonna say Arnold. But I will say that when it comes to Sergio's '71 & '72 form, I'm gonna have to give him the nod.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: kevcat on December 03, 2010, 06:51:25 AM
Nubret shits at both of their faces, always rooting for a fellow European!

Arnold is European douchebag  ;D
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: kevcat on December 03, 2010, 06:54:25 AM
Anyway in any competition nowadays, guys are slated for 'being off' or 'holding water' etc etc so in that pic just posted Arnold is easily more cut than Sergio and still bigger.Sergios proportions are phenomonal but i say Arnold in that pose.Any more lat spread poses or anything? one picture doesnt always tell the story
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: JP_RC on December 03, 2010, 07:22:00 AM
Anyway in any competition nowadays, guys are slated for 'being off' or 'holding water' etc etc so in that pic just posted Arnold is easily more cut than Sergio and still bigger.Sergios proportions are phenomonal but i say Arnold in that pose.Any more lat spread poses or anything? one picture doesnt always tell the story

(http://builtreport.com/1972olympia/008.jpg)

(http://builtreport.com/1972olympia/001.jpg)

(http://builtreport.com/1972olympia/027.jpg)

(http://builtreport.com/1972olympia/011.jpg)

lol at Nubret blowing them both away.  :D
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: spude on December 03, 2010, 10:45:27 AM
Arnold is European douchebag  ;D

Nah, went to states, got citizenship, represented usa ---> LOST SOUL
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: MB on December 03, 2010, 10:57:19 AM
So do you think that contest was a fix?  

Honestly Sergio looked great on his own in 1972, but when he stood next to Arnold it was a different story.
Arnold was just better conditioned with equal size and even bigger in some bodyparts, Sergio had bigger quads and better taper that's it.
Arnold's muscularity was also better.

(http://builtreport.com/1972olympia/035.jpg)

The Weider's sure were skimpy on stage design.  Where was this contest held, at the local library?
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Pollux on December 03, 2010, 03:50:43 PM
Arnold is European douchebag  ;D

Watch your mouth, convict!  >:(
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Lundgren on December 03, 2010, 03:53:38 PM
Neither.

Nubret in his prime blows em both away.

(http://www.bodybuilding-pics.com/168/images/Serge_NUBRET_86.jpg)
X2

Sergio looked wierd, and Arnold wasn't perfect(still had the best look ever though).
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Wiggs on December 03, 2010, 04:09:06 PM
What was Sergio's height and competition weight in his prime?
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Lundgren on December 03, 2010, 04:10:46 PM
What was Sergio's height and competition weight in his prime?
Do you want an honest answer or the legend?

Supposedly like 6 foot 205 but that's total bull, my guess 5 9 180 or so but no one knows.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Wiggs on December 03, 2010, 04:15:02 PM
Do you want an honest answer or the legend?

Supposedly like 6 foot 205 but that's total bull, my guess 5 9 180 or so but no one knows.

I've met him a couple times most recently this year at the O and I even paid money for an autograph...He's old as fuck (and very grumpy BTW) so I'm sure he's lost some inches off his height so it's hard to tell...I want the honest answer...
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Lord of the Roidz on December 03, 2010, 04:32:27 PM
Arnold's best years were 71, 73 and 74 for his combo of size, conditioning and proportion. In 74, even his legs were massive and separated. His 75 and 80 were definitely not his best. Sergio definitely had the potential to be better than Arnold, but he never reached his peak in terms of conditioning. The rumor has it that he refused to stop drinking large amounts of Coca Cola, even before a show and didn't refine his dieting. So if you compare Sergio's best condition with Arnold's best years 71, 73, and 74..Arnold wins. Sergio could have definitely gotten the nod in 72...since Arnold was a bit off. I think if Sergio had lived in California and was eating the same foods and taking the same drug cycles as Arnold, he would have been better. He just never wanted to listen to anyone and wanted to do things his own way. Still one of the all time greats.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Wiggs on December 03, 2010, 04:36:13 PM
Do you want an honest answer or the legend?

Supposedly like 6 foot 205 but that's total bull, my guess 5 9 180 or so but no one knows.

I found it....5'9 220-240...
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Lord of the Roidz on December 04, 2010, 10:02:19 AM
These pics of Arnold in the gym and guest posing were taken in 74 . If he had continued to train hard instead of losing 30 pounds for the film "Stay Hungry" and then regaining some of it in a few months before the 75 Olympia, he may have continued to get bigger and better.
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or
Post by: tbombz on December 04, 2010, 10:14:16 AM

BULLSHIT Ronnie circa 1999 was the most amazing bodybuilder to ever walk the planet  ::) ::) LOL Dorian with his barrel shaped torso and twig arms was a complete joke!  ::)

Yeah right, Ronnie Coleman had a huge GH belly and he was black (gross).

 Worst of all he was a cop. There is no excuse for that.

 Dorian wins.


LoL  ;D
Title: Re: Politics aside who had a better physique, Sergio or Arnold...No Hulkster or ND
Post by: Feizai on December 04, 2010, 04:24:08 PM
These pics of Arnold in the gym and guest posing were taken in 74 . If he had continued to train hard instead of losing 30 pounds for the film "Stay Hungry" and then regaining some of it in a few months before the 75 Olympia, he may have continued to get bigger and better.


Guest posing photo was from 1971.