Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums

Getbig Misc Discussion Boards => Mixed Martial Arts (MMA/UFC) => Topic started by: BDsauce on May 01, 2011, 09:38:22 AM

Title: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: BDsauce on May 01, 2011, 09:38:22 AM
Hahaha getting busted up by Jake freakin Shields and cries that he cant see. Erik Morales fought his last fight with his eye shut and never complained. Every since Sierra ko'd his chinny ass, hes been fighting saftey first.

Fedor never fought like that in his reign ;)
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: *ChuteBoxe* on May 01, 2011, 11:34:54 AM
I honestly expected GSP to steamroll Jake in the 1st round.  Jake's standup really didn't look any different than it has in the past, it just seemed like once again.....GSP was just content with pot shotting Jake to yet another point victory, maybe he was scared to over commit to strikes and risk Jake taking him down....either way he has been overly conservative in every facet since Serra cleaned his clock.  Erik Morales has balls of steel, I saw that fight and he fought his ass off with one eye against a brutal puncher who was naturally bigger than him for 11 rounds.  Gsp's eye was injured late in the second.....he had 2 rounds of fully functioning eyes that he could have gotten Jake out of there in. 
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: George Whorewell on May 01, 2011, 06:17:31 PM
I hate to say it, but Anderson would make mincemeat out of him if he fights the way he did against SHields.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: coltrane on May 02, 2011, 06:48:24 AM
I hate to say it, but Anderson would make mincemeat out of him if he fights the way he did against SHields.

What's what i've been saying all along.

Anderson would dice him up.

I think GSP should move up to 185, but not right to Anderson.  Start with top 5 and work up.  I'd like to see a Belfort/GSP fight.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 02, 2011, 07:34:18 AM
GSP is currently fighting the best at 170 and I feel a move to 185 would kill his career. Other than Silva, there's really no outstanding talent for him to fight there either.

GSP and Anderson are so far ahead of anyone else, they appear to not be challenging themselves, when in fact they are.

If 185 was better stacked than 170, then I would be worth the move.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: coltrane on May 02, 2011, 07:39:43 AM
GSP is currently fighting the best at 170 and I feel a move to 185 would kill his career. Other than Silva, there's really no outstanding talent for him to fight there either.

GSP and Anderson are so far ahead of anyone else, they appear to not be challenging themselves, when in fact they are.

If 185 was better stacked than 170, then I would be worth the move.

The talent pool at 85 may not be the best outside of Silva, but remember those guys are physically bigger than GSP.  How would GSP handle Marquardt or Okami?  Vitor would be a hellava fight imo.  I don't think GSP would storm thru the division.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 02, 2011, 07:54:17 AM
The talent pool at 85 may not be the best outside of Silva, but remember those guys are physically bigger than GSP.  How would GSP handle Marquardt or Okami?  Vitor would be a hellava fight imo.  I don't think GSP would storm thru the division.


This is exactly my point....what incentive does GSP have to move up in weight? He IS being challenged now at WW, it just doesn't appear that way because of his safe style.

I feel there is little benefit to GSP moving up and I doubt we'll see it.

Marquardt's next fight is at 170.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: coltrane on May 02, 2011, 08:09:17 AM

This is exactly my point....what incentive does GSP have to move up in weight? He IS being challenged now at WW, it just doesn't appear that way because of his safe style.

I feel there is little benefit to GSP moving up and I doubt we'll see it.

Marquardt's next fight is at 170.

If Marquardt can perform at 170 well, this should be a legit matchup.  His striking is much better than GSP's imo..  and his wrestling is strong too.  I see a Marquartd win.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 02, 2011, 08:10:35 AM
If Marquardt can perform at 170 well, this should be a legit matchup.  His striking is much better than GSP's imo..  and his wrestling is strong too.  I see a Marquartd win.

It would be interesting, except they occasionally train together.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: *ChuteBoxe* on May 02, 2011, 08:14:02 AM
If Marquardt can perform at 170 well, this should be a legit matchup.  His striking is much better than GSP's imo..  and his wrestling is strong too.  I see a Marquartd win.

Nate has been one of GSP's main training partners in preparation for fights for almost 4 years now.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: coltrane on May 02, 2011, 08:20:41 AM
Nate has been one of GSP's main training partners in preparation for fights for almost 4 years now.

Well there goes that fight..  unless you think one of two things will occur:

1.  UFC will force the fight, or
2.  They'll fight regardless of their friendship.

Thoughts Chute?
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 02, 2011, 08:42:57 AM
Hahaha getting busted up by Jake freakin Shields and cries that he cant see. Erik Morales fought his last fight with his eye shut and never complained. Every since Sierra ko'd his chinny ass, hes been fighting saftey first.

Fedor never fought like that in his reign ;)

Fedor fought cans.  GSP fights the best int he world, and dominates every single one.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: *ChuteBoxe* on May 02, 2011, 11:22:08 AM
Well there goes that fight..  unless you think one of two things will occur:

1.  UFC will force the fight, or
2.  They'll fight regardless of their friendship.

Thoughts Chute?

First off im curious to see how Nate handles that cut, he's pretty big for a middleweight let alone a welter.  I think they can manage to avoid fighting each other for a while though,  A.K.A has 3 WW.'s that have all managed to avoid fighting each other (Kos,Fitch,Swick).  I really doubt they'll fight each other unless, one of them has a falling out with Greg Jackson.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: Jadeveon Clowney on May 02, 2011, 11:24:17 AM
Fedor fought cans.  GSP fights the best int he world, and dominates every single one.

If by dominate you mean ekes out a victory.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: coltrane on May 02, 2011, 11:33:36 AM
This is what pisses me off about GSP:  that he dominates the other guy, but never can finish anyone.  How does one correct this?  Work striking?  Not be so defensive in a fight.  IDK.  That's why I didn't waste $55.99 on this UFC.   I knew it was gonna be a vintage GSP decision by bore and snore.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 02, 2011, 11:45:27 AM
This is what pisses me off about GSP:  that he dominates the other guy, but never can finish anyone.  How does one correct this?  Work striking?  Not be so defensive in a fight.  IDK.  That's why I didn't waste $55.99 on this UFC.   I knew it was gonna be a vintage GSP decision by bore and snore.

I agree...that is the big dilemma with GSP. If he's so dominant, why can't he finish a fight?

But at the same time, he's winning the fights and defending his belt. He's smart not to put himself in risky positions.

To me, I think GSP is one of the best, but at this point in his career, I would say he is nowhere near legendary status do to his safe style of fighting.

The first guy that can make GSP uncomfortable in a fight can defeat GSP.  GSP's biggest weakness is his fear of defeat.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: coltrane on May 02, 2011, 12:10:03 PM
I agree.  I don't think Diaz can beat him.  Hopefully Marquartd can get a shot at some point.

I also doubt Silva/Gsp ever takes place.  It's marketing suicide for one of them.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 02, 2011, 12:47:54 PM
I don't think it will ever happen either.  Whomever loses will claim "weight issues" and I don't want to hear it.

A Jon Jones/ Anderson Silva would be nice though and more reasonable.  Silva has fought at 205 before, so it wouldn't be a big stretch.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 02, 2011, 04:08:18 PM
If by dominate you mean ekes out a victory.

ekes out a victory?  He stuffed every single take down.  Kept the fight exactly where he wanted it.  And, in spite of getting eye-fucked, still pulled out the unanimous decision. 
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 02, 2011, 04:16:24 PM
Guys, GSP just fought one of the best ever welterweights and he did it with one eye!  In his 32 fights, Shields has only been finished once (his 3rd fight 11 years ago).  And, you could tell that GSP was trying hard to finish him.  He must have thrown that overhand right at least two dozen times and it came a hair away from landing on more than one occasion. 

Of his 22 wins, GSP has finished 13 (3 of them after the Serra loss).  IMO, he is still the best P4P fighter and greatest welterweight ever.  I hope they feed him Diaz.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: Jadeveon Clowney on May 02, 2011, 04:27:01 PM
And, you could tell that GSP was trying hard to finish him. 

You're a funny guy.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: basil on May 02, 2011, 04:58:20 PM
I honestly expected GSP to steamroll Jake in the 1st round.  Jake's standup really didn't look any different than it has in the past, it just seemed like once again.....GSP was just content with pot shotting Jake to yet another point victory, maybe he was scared to over commit to strikes and risk Jake taking him down....either way he has been overly conservative in every facet since Serra cleaned his clock.  Erik Morales has balls of steel, I saw that fight and he fought his ass off with one eye against a brutal puncher who was naturally bigger than him for 11 rounds.  Gsp's eye was injured late in the second.....he had 2 rounds of fully functioning eyes that he could have gotten Jake out of there in. 

You're comparing apples to oranges.  In the Morales-Maidana fight, Morales was in survival mode.  He was not dictating the pace of the fight, and was looking to make the 12 rounds regardless of the amount of damage he took.  Morales has prob already suffered a considerable amount of brain damage from the punishment he's taken over his career.  GSP was in total control of the fight, despite his injury.  He would have to be a fool/retarded to do anything that would put him at a greater disadvantage than he already was.  If Shields had any balls, he would have went after the lame duck instead of standing back and being controlled.  GSP did the smartest thing he could have done with the injury by staying where he felt comfortable and still controlling things.  The fight was 3 days ago, GSP is still champ, and Sheilds suffered his first lost in a dogs age, so GSP obviously made the right decision(s). 

Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 02, 2011, 05:19:40 PM
You're a funny guy.

You couldn't tell that he was trying to force a KO?  When have you seen GSP throw that over righ hand before?  He clearly trained for it and tried hard to land it.  Unfortunately, it didn't happen...
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: Bindare_Dundat on May 02, 2011, 10:26:12 PM
He won, that's all that matters.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: *ChuteBoxe* on May 03, 2011, 07:32:34 AM
You're comparing apples to oranges.  In the Morales-Maidana fight, Morales was in survival mode.  He was not dictating the pace of the fight, and was looking to make the 12 rounds regardless of the amount of damage he took.  Morales has prob already suffered a considerable amount of brain damage from the punishment he's taken over his career.  GSP was in total control of the fight, despite his injury.  He would have to be a fool/retarded to do anything that would put him at a greater disadvantage than he already was.  If Shields had any balls, he would have went after the lame duck instead of standing back and being controlled.  GSP did the smartest thing he could have done with the injury by staying where he felt comfortable and still controlling things.  The fight was 3 days ago, GSP is still champ, and Sheilds suffered his first lost in a dogs age, so GSP obviously made the right decision(s). 

Jake was in survival mode the entire fight, while GSP was in his usual "safe mode", even before his eye was hurt.  Jake was the same old Jake he always is (stand up wise) and GSP failed to capitalize on that.  GSP was probably so afraid of Jake getting the take down  that he just pot shotted him all night from the outside rather than going for the kill and risking being taken down.  GSP had 2 rounds of fully functioning eyes to get it done and he chose stand and pray rather than the "finish" that he always promises.  Much like in his last fight in which HE had a one eyed Koscheck in front of him for almost the entire fight, yet he still lacked the balls to go out and put the stamp on that dead man walking.  It's official that Matt Serra took GSP's balls, and we'll probably never see another exciting highlight reel finish from him again because he's too scared of the consequences in that risk.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 03, 2011, 08:00:01 AM
Jake was in survival mode the entire fight, while GSP was in his usual "safe mode", even before his eye was hurt.  Jake was the same old Jake he always is (stand up wise) and GSP failed to capitalize on that.  GSP was probably so afraid of Jake getting the take down  that he just pot shotted him all night from the outside rather than going for the kill and risking being taken down.  GSP had 2 rounds of fully functioning eyes to get it done and he chose stand and pray rather than the "finish" that he always promises.  Much like in his last fight in which HE had a one eyed Koscheck in front of him for almost the entire fight, yet he still lacked the balls to go out and put the stamp on that dead man walking.  It's official that Matt Serra took GSP's balls, and we'll probably never see another exciting highlight reel finish from him again because he's too scared of the consequences in that risk.

I agree, Serra took GSP's balls and GSP is so terrified of losing, it actually holds him back.

The first guy to put GSP out of his comfort zone , will become the new champion.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 03, 2011, 08:33:27 AM
I agree, Serra took GSP's balls and GSP is so terrified of losing, it actually holds him back.

The first guy to put GSP out of his comfort zone , will become the new champion.

This should put an end to you and I being a gimmick, as I completely disagree.  Serra took GSPs balls?  Did you see the rematch?  GSP finished him without breaking a sweat.  As for getting put out of his comfort zone, the guy had a major groin injury in the ALves fight and still won.  And he had a major eye poke against shields and still won.  When injuries like that happen to other fighters, they get put out of their "comfort zone" and lose.  GSP still wins.

GSPs counterparts in other weight divisions have all been beaten or come within an inch of being beaten.  Look at BJ Penn.  He lost his belt.  Look at Anderson.  Plenty of decisions on his record, and he got dominated by Chael.  The light heavy weight division is a revolving door of champs, as is the heavy weight division.  Even Jose Aldo was made to look human this weekend.

GSP has never been dominated.  If anyone should be criticized in this last fight, it should be Shields.  He had one way, and one way only, to win this fight.  He needed to take it to the ground and impose his BJJ on GSP.  Yet, he failed miserably in his two takedown attempts, and then spent the rest of the fight boxing with a one-eyed GSP.

I'm as disappointed as anyone that this main event didn't end in spectacular fashion.  But, it's not because GSP sucks.  It's MMA.  Anything can happen, including an eye poke...

Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: Geo on May 03, 2011, 08:35:40 AM
It's official that Matt Serra took GSP's balls, and we'll probably never see another exciting highlight reel finish from him again because he's too scared of the consequences in that risk.

absolutely...

all the gymnastics in the world aren't gonna make George worth watching anymore...

I predicted and was pulling for Jake but I was totally dumbfounded when two judges gave Jake two rounds...

that fight almost made Couture/Coleman look good..

Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 03, 2011, 08:36:47 AM
absolutely...

all the gymnastics in the world aren't gonna make George worth watching anymore...

I predicted and was pulling for Jake but I was totally dumbfounded when two judges gave Jake two rounds...

that fight almost made Couture/Coleman look good..




No shit.  What two rounds did Jake win ???
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: Geo on May 03, 2011, 08:39:13 AM

No shit.  What two rounds did Jake win ???

I had jake doing nothing in the first round and fighting like a girl in rounds 2-5.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 03, 2011, 12:01:07 PM
This should put an end to you and I being a gimmick, as I completely disagree.  Serra took GSPs balls?  Did you see the rematch?  GSP finished him without breaking a sweat.  As for getting put out of his comfort zone, the guy had a major groin injury in the ALves fight and still won.  And he had a major eye poke against shields and still won.  When injuries like that happen to other fighters, they get put out of their "comfort zone" and lose.  GSP still wins.

GSPs counterparts in other weight divisions have all been beaten or come within an inch of being beaten.  Look at BJ Penn.  He lost his belt.  Look at Anderson.  Plenty of decisions on his record, and he got dominated by Chael.  The light heavy weight division is a revolving door of champs, as is the heavy weight division.  Even Jose Aldo was made to look human this weekend.

GSP has never been dominated.  If anyone should be criticized in this last fight, it should be Shields.  He had one way, and one way only, to win this fight.  He needed to take it to the ground and impose his BJJ on GSP.  Yet, he failed miserably in his two takedown attempts, and then spent the rest of the fight boxing with a one-eyed GSP.

I'm as disappointed as anyone that this main event didn't end in spectacular fashion.  But, it's not because GSP sucks.  It's MMA.  Anything can happen, including an eye poke...



I'm sure they'll think we're disagreeing to throw them off the gimmick accusations ;D

GSP became a different fighter after the Serra loss. He became a smarter fighter at the price of boredom.  I think GSP is one of the best, but his terrifying fear of losing is why I agree that Serra took his balls. There is absolutely no reason that his fight with Koscheck went 5 rds. Same with Hardy and even some could say Fitch.  If he had balls, he would have stepped it up a bit and finished the fight instead of coasting to victory.  We all know that GSP has the skills to plow through most WW's, but I think once that midget KO'd him, he lost his confidence.

And yes, I'm tired of getting psyched for a GSP fight, only to watch a boring clinic. I do understand that this is not all GSP's fault, but if he's so talented, he should be able to finish fights.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 03, 2011, 12:17:19 PM
I'm sure they'll think we're disagreeing to throw them off the gimmick accusations ;D

GSP became a different fighter after the Serra loss. He became a smarter fighter at the price of boredom.  I think GSP is one of the best, but his terrifying fear of losing is why I agree that Serra took his balls. There is absolutely no reason that his fight with Koscheck went 5 rds. Same with Hardy and even some could say Fitch.  If he had balls, he would have stepped it up a bit and finished the fight instead of coasting to victory.  We all know that GSP has the skills to plow through most WW's, but I think once that midget KO'd him, he lost his confidence.

And yes, I'm tired of getting psyched for a GSP fight, only to watch a boring clinic. I do understand that this is not all GSP's fault, but if he's so talented, he should be able to finish fights.

I agree with all that.  I think he just doesn't want to go through what Miguel Torrez went through. 
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 03, 2011, 12:28:42 PM
I agree with all that.  I think he just doesn't want to go through what Miguel Torrez went through. 

Good point.

Besides, GSP shouldn't be upset about Serra taking his balls.  GSP took Serra's balls and a kidney after their last fight. Those knees were brutal.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 03, 2011, 02:43:19 PM
Good point.

Besides, GSP shouldn't be upset about Serra taking his balls.  GSP took Serra's balls and a kidney after their last fight. Those knees were brutal.

If I were GSP, I would keep defending my 170 title until I broke the UFC record for title defenses and consecutive wins.  Then, I would throw caution to the wind and either move up to 185, or start fighting like a reckless madman at 170...
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 03, 2011, 03:02:33 PM
If I were GSP, I would keep defending my 170 title until I broke the UFC record for title defenses and consecutive wins.  Then, I would throw caution to the wind and either move up to 185, or start fighting like a reckless madman at 170...

I agree.  I think that he would be foolish to move up in weight.  He dominates and he's the champ. He should not be held responsible for changing his style.  That's what his challengers should be forcing him to do.

Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: micro26 on May 06, 2011, 06:39:34 AM
GSP vs. RICH FRANKLIN makes good sense to me......both technicle stand up fighters and franklin would push GSP.  but no permanent move to 185.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 06, 2011, 08:13:29 AM
GSP vs. RICH FRANKLIN makes good sense to me......both technicle stand up fighters and franklin would push GSP.  but no permanent move to 185.


Only one problem with this, Rich fights at 205 these days.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: MindSpin on May 06, 2011, 09:50:35 AM
There are some really big guys fighting at 185.  Chael Sonnen and Okami are very big and very strong.  I don't think GSP would match up well with them.  There are some good fights for him there though.  How about Leben, Dollaway, Grove or even Wandy. I do think that because of Anderson's weak wrestling, GSP would have a real chance against him....
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: WeightPSHR on May 06, 2011, 12:21:01 PM
But again why should GSP move up to fight anything but the best in the division?

If he moves up, then loses to someone like Leben, he instantly becomes an average, washed up champ in a lot of people's eyes.

I think the only fight worth the risk is with Silva, otherwise, he should just stay at WW.

GSP said it best when he mentioned in an interview that he doesn't want to become a Roy Jones Jr. by playing with his weight.
Title: Re: GSP P4P REALLY??
Post by: coltrane on May 06, 2011, 12:29:37 PM
I agree, he shouldn't move in weight unless he wants to really test himself.  At some point he's gonna lose and tarnish a great record.  I think he stays at 170 and fight whoever is put in front of him. 

I'd like to see Sanchez get a crack at him, not that I think he'd win.