Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: The_Hammer on May 19, 2012, 09:10:50 PM
-
If these two were to compete in the same show, who would place higher?
-
Lee Haney. No questions asked.
-
niga please . haney.
-
Haney
-
Dorian.
-
Lee would smoke his ass in a second.
-
Lee, however give Mcmillan time though he COULD BE top 3 Olympia in the Future Certainly looks to have the Potential there, has a Great back for someone 6ft 1
-
Cedric has the potential to be better though.
He's got the arms and legs that Haney never had.
It's really odd but I see shades of Arnold and Sergio
in Ced's physique. Ced needs to work on delts mainly
which he's aware of. Some more ham and calf work and about 10-15
pounds of muscle in the right places. Almost unlimited potential
and he's got the one thing tall guys struggle with - a good-great back
good width but great back double bi.
-
The awesome Lee Haney at his biggest in 1991
and in good shape.
-
More..
-
Ced's back double bi with good lighting...
He's bigger and better now but the lighting for the NY
Pro is not as good as here.
-
even if haney was half the size he was certain people hung up on some sorta giving respect rule for an old timer would vote for haney, people with minds like that are simply not fully developed humans
-
Lionel would make for a more interesting comparison imo
-
Lionel would make for a more interesting comparison imo
Cedric is way better than Lionel will ever be. More detail.
-
Cedric is way better than Lionel will ever be. More detail.
Yes and branch warren is even better. More detail.
Because it's all about detail.
-
Yes and branch warren is even better. More detail.
Because it's all about detail.
No it's not, but don't we agree both Cedric and Lionel are better bodybuilders than Branch, no matter how many titles Branch "wins"?
Cedric rapes Lionel from the back. ;)
-
Lionel would make for a more interesting comparison imo
I hope you mean Lionel Beyeke and not Lionel Brown.
-
I hope you mean Lionel Beyeke and not Lionel Brown.
Or Lionel Messi.
-
No it's not, but don't we agree both Cedric and Lionel are better bodybuilders than Branch, no matter how many titles Branch "wins"?
Cedric rapes Lionel from the back. ;)
Yes of course. But "way ahead" is too strong..
I'm a sucker for proportion (extremely no homo), beyeke has it in spades and mass. Aware that he needs more conditioning yes but I see more potential than McMillan.
Does Cedric rls beat Lionels? I'd want to see pics of that..
-
More..
Pretty decent stuff Cedric.
-
Cedric seems like such a genuine dude, I hope the guy does get the Olympia eventually.
-
(http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR6UywW51QxultlZqMQVlTKAoNKcxABU-nAdah3z0dLErQOabzg8A)
-
Cedric looks like a scaled Flex Wheeler except with a bigger chest, and lacking all that roundy-round look.
-
another 5 10 pounds and it's Olympia time for Ced!
-
looks like he isn't missing lower back detail either like so many today
-
Cedric looks like a scaled Flex Wheeler except with a bigger chest, and lacking all that roundy-round look oil.
fixed
-
Cedric looks like Charlie Murphy on steroids
-
cedric is one of the few guys that actually may have "genetic potential " for bodybuilding.
-
Yes of course. But "way ahead" is too strong..
I'm a sucker for proportion (extremely no homo), beyeke has it in spades and mass. Aware that he needs more conditioning yes but I see more potential than McMillan.
Does Cedric rls beat Lionels? I'd want to see pics of that..
Bro Cedric murders Lionel from all back shots, Lionel has a flawless front but his whole back end is watery and smooth.
-
even if haney was half the size he was certain people hung up on some sorta giving respect rule for an old timer would vote for haney, people with minds like that are simply not fully developed humans
Yup....if you looked at their physiques without knowing their names not a single person would say Haney was better. Cedric has arms and legs that absolutely shit all over Haneys, and their torsos are about even
-
Bro Cedric murders Lionel from all back shots, Lionel has a flawless front but his whole back end is watery and smooth.
again, i like proportion a la oliva so my opinion stands. just prefer the lower lats, calf-thigh-torso ratio etc.
-
Cedrik ftw. Haney's legs are too weak. I think he's gonna knock phil off in time.
-
Cedric McMillan? Cedric McMillan?? Cedric fucking McMillan???
Lee Haney's titles: Cedric McMillan's title:
1979 Teen Mr. America none
1979 Teen Mr. America Tall, 1st
1982 Junior Nationals Heavyweight & Overall, 1st
1982 Nationals Heavyweight & Overall, 1st
1982 World Amateur Championships Heavyweight, 1st
1983 Grand Prix England, 2nd
1983 Grand Prix Las Vegas, 1st
1983 Grand Prix Sweden, 2nd
1983 Grand Prix Switzerland, 3rd
1983 Night of Champions, 1st
1983 Mr. Olympia, 3rd
1983 World Pro Championships, 3rd
1984 Mr. Olympia, 1st
1985 Mr. Olympia, 1st
1986 Mr. Olympia, 1st
1987 Mr. Olympia, 1st
1987 Grand Prix Germany (II), 1st
1988 Mr. Olympia, 1st
1989 Mr. Olympia, 1st
1990 Mr. Olympia, 1st
1991 Mr. Olympia, 1st
-
Cedric has arms and legs proportinate to his torso, if nobody knew who the fuck Haney and Cedric were i think most would say Cedric ws better.
I like Beyeke's lines better but Cedric has more potential to be a monster.
-
You guys are morons. Haney makes cedric look soft. If Cedric could dial it in with Haney like hardness, you'd have the next 8 time or more Mr. O.
-
You guys are morons. Haney makes cedric look soft. If Cedric could dial it in with Haney like hardness, you'd have the next 8 time or more Mr. O.
kluco and cedric have the structure to go into Beast Mode. which one will bite the bullet and max out on Ronnie's Pimp Juice? if not, then enjoy evan's run as mr.o. after phil.
-
For Christ sake.....Lee Haney is an eight time Mr. Olympia!!!!
Cedric couldn't carry his jock strap.
-
You guys are morons. Haney makes cedric look soft. If Cedric could dial it in with Haney like hardness, you'd have the next 8 time or more Mr. O.
I agree Haney would still win IMO.
Cedric does have better arms and legs, but Haney beat guys with better arms and legs than himself.
He still has one of the best backs of all time and his conditioning was very good when he was on.
-
(http://i.imgur.com/oUVdG.jpg)
would look crazy in real life
-
Its like comparing Andy Dalton to Joe Montana...
-
Haney no question.
-
Not comparable at ALL.
Lee Haney is #3 on the official top 10 bodybuilders of all time.
Lee is an 8x undefeated Mr Olympia, the first to accomplish this. He improved every year. His final year was amazing.
-
..
-
..
hahaha, they are like 2 generations apart, and haney looks more muscular but cedric is on enough shit to kill an elephant. this guy hits one poses, and people are comparing him to a great. roelly will place higher than him at the O. if anything, he is the new chris cormier minus the drugs and cell phone, should win a bunch of small shows but never the A or the O.
-
Get a time machine and bring haney to the present, haney wins
Get a time machine and take cedric to haneys day, haney wins
Haney on the shit mcmillan is on, yes including oil, gh, slin, but cleverly utilized, would wipe the floor with ANYONE
The people saying cedric and haneys torsos are the same is in itself proof that almost 3 decades ago haney had better conditioning with an equal torso to a man that outweighs him by 25lbs and is 3 inches taller.
But I disagree, haneys torso was better, haneys legs were on par with the times, haneys arms were oil free. Nowdays NOBODY has oil free arms, some look better than others, but they ALL use oil
-
I respect Figo his posts are always legit,,,,,,but,,,,,,Lee has one of the most overrated physiques of all time.
But no it isn't fair to compare across eras, too many variances.
-
I respect Figo his posts are always legit,,,,,,but,,,,,,Lee has one of the most overrated physiques of all time.
But no it isn't fair to compare across eras, too many variances.
QFT and the biggest difference that people do not understand on this thread is there is a different era of judgeing, Imagine English or Warren being judged by the judges in the 90`s,lol,....probably wouldn`t place
-
I respect Figo his posts are always legit,,,,,,but,,,,,,Lee has one of the most overrated physiques of all time.
But no it isn't fair to compare across eras, too many variances.
thanks
Its bbing, its very subjective, but 8 mr o sandows tell the tale
Am I being nostalgic and hung up on the fact haney is a legend? maybe ;D
Yes, haney had weak arms, yes his torso dominated, making everything else appear smaller, but the guy ruled in his day
And until marty macfly rocks up in the delorean, we'll never know for sure
-
im just glad they all peel
-
;D ;D ;D
(http://pics.musculardevelopment.com/photos/transferred/JB5_9561wtmk.JPG) (http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/rob11gbig.jpg)
-
(http://pics.musculardevelopment.com/photos/transferred/JB5_9561wtmk.JPG)
does he do the backstroke or butterfly?
-
(http://pics.musculardevelopment.com/photos/transferred/JB5_9561wtmk.JPG)
does he do the backstroke or butterfly?
;)
-
Jake,
Haney is #3 on the list. WTF...who is better. Ronnie??? Maybe, but it is debateable. Dorian???? GTFO. Haney beat him and after 1993 Dorian was the one armed bandit. Oliva??? Great shape but never in the conditioning of Haney, Yates, etc. Ok, Arnold I can understand. He is the granfather of bodybuilding. Comparing Cedric to Haney before he has even won the Mr. O. is insulting. ::)