Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums
Getbig Bodybuilding Boards => Positive Bodybuilding Discussion & Talk => Topic started by: dan18 on April 27, 2006, 07:35:45 AM
-
who thought bob chic swept the masters
-
the rusty guy ws good but bob looked more of a pro.
more polished
my opinion...
but then again i'm a form over function kinda guy.
-
I definitely think he deserved the win.
-
Chicherillo fairly won (true); Jeffers was disrespected (true).
-
Chicherillo fairly won (true); Jeffers was disrespected (true).
Word
Could have gone either way... Most where pissed off how Rusty got dissed so badly which tainted the credibility of Bobs win.
-
who thought bob chic swept the masters
Chick definately didn't "sweep" the masters but he did win, period. It's in the books for all time. Do I think he should have bee compared to Rusty? Hell yeah but this type of shit is so typical in the IFBB so it didn't surprise me.
-
I was very impressed with Bob's shape. He did the work required to win. It's really plain and simple.
Only in the retarded world of bodybuilding message boards would anyone - and I practically do mean 'one' - try to treat the win as being somehow suspect.
-
i dont think they judges it fairly
-
he was the best overall so it was fair
-
the rusty guy ws good but bob looked more of a pro.
more polished
my opinion...
but then again i'm a form over function kinda guy.
i agree rusty got shafted in his placings but i think the winner spot clearly went to bob
-
Chic in the masters? WTF? How old is he? ???
-
I definitely think he deserved the win.
I think he one because he was the biggest name. The runner up was way better... one way or the other, Chic has been kssing the right butts lately and was due...
-
i agree rusty got shafted in his placings but i think the winner spot clearly went to bob
Yeah I agree. Bob was the winner, but Rusty did get the shaft.
-
I think he one because he was the biggest name. The runner up was way better... one way or the other, Chic has been kssing the right butts lately and was due...
You're entitled to your opinion....
Just curious...who's butt have I been kissing, exactly?
-
Bob deserved the win.
IMO, he didn't beat Rusty on posing, or Pavol in the muscularity round, though.
-
Bottom line - Chick won the show. Of the people there, it wasnt a question. Forget the judges, forget the IFBB officials - ask the actual people who went. They know Bob one, it wasn't a concern. The only concern that people had was why Rusty placed in 8th place. End of story.
-
The only concern that people had was why Rusty placed in 8th place. End of story.
That's a pretty big concern considering how good Jeffers looked compared to his competition.
-
Bob deserved the win.
IMO, he didn't beat Rusty on posing, or Pavol in the muscularity round, though.
The winner of an OVERALL needs to be the best...OVERALL. He might not actually win any individual round. In this case I did...
There were guys more muscular, but they lacked in symmetry.
There were guys that posed great, but they lacked in conditioning.
There were guys with great symmetry, but they lacked in muscularity or balance.
Seeing a show from the judges table and seeing a show in still pictures are two different worlds...
No one that was in attendance disputed the win. (well, almost no one..)
-
Bob,
Can you comment on the 2 through 5 placings and if you agreed/disagreed with them.
-
There were guys more muscular, but they lacked in symmetry.
There were guys that posed great, but they lacked in conditioning.
There were guys with great symmetry, but they lacked in muscularity or balance.
We're in agreement, Bob.
But the fact that you took FIRST in the posing round- over rusty, and FIRST in the muscularity round, over Pavol, is what irked some people.
Yes, you deserved the overall crown.
But do you agree it's weird you were given a PERFCET score in every round?
-
Bob was the best of the lot without any doubts.
-
Yes, you deserved the overall crown.
-
rusty should have won but its not bob chics "fault" that he won. But it dont matter we all know rusty won...it wasnt a bodybuilding competition it was a "who has not made gay porn competition".
-
That's a fair point.
Even if you say Bob deserved the win, it sure appears like the fix was in and it would have been given to him no matter how he looked.
I have to agree.....I think Bob won....but not in every round.
Just my opinion but the judges saw something different.
-
I try not to think, I did it once hurt like hell and it was seriously overrated.
But Bob won hands down in my non biased humble opinion. :-* ;)
-
who thought bob chic swept the masters
The better question is who cares about the Master's olympia? Bob won because he had zero competition.
-
I don't like the whole judging system as it has been used for the last 10-15 years....
I've written articles about this many times...there are no "true" rounds as it should be.
Every round is judged as a "combination" round...The symmetry round isn't really about who has the best symmetry...it's about who has thee beest symmetry, COMBINED with muscularity,etc
Ditto for the muscularity round...it's not judged on who is the moost muscular, but whose the most muscular AND has the best symmetry, etc.....
Same goes for the posing round...
In this context...I believe I won the rounds fair and square, as I believe (and so did the judges) that OVERALL I had the best combo of each round.
That being said..I still by the notion that this form of judging sucks, and we need to find a beter system. The NPC system is fairer, and doeesn't use the bogus "rounds" to make things more confusing...
-
I wasn't there but I carefully watched and rewatched the videos. From my perspective, Bob was the most complete bodybuilder on stage. I really liked the way that he presented his physique -- it came across practiced and professional. I did like Rusty's physique, but personally, I think if you put the two side by side that Bob's muscularity/size would have overwhelmed Rusty. Looking at the score sheets you can see clearly that the judges were in agreement. I'd like to believe that they were honest in their appraisals.
-
Yes, I think he deserved the win. To say he won because he was the biggest name?? ridiculous! you could argue that Pavol and Claude are bigger names in the BB world.
-
I agree with Bob winning. I disagree with places 2-6. The thing troubles me is that I still think we've didn't see the best Bob that he's capable of being.
-
Bob deserved to win the show...put it to rest guys..
-
Bob imop easily won the show...it wasn't really close...Classic X-frame...And doesn't have the "all drug look" like everyone else in the top 5