Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: FREAKgeek on May 27, 2006, 05:33:32 PM
-
As you all can see, the ronnie vs dorian thread has exhausted itself over several times and it's pretty much down to personal insults (which is still entertaining) but there's one last interesting aspect - let all the getbig members vote on it (if you give a shit). Form your comparison on the best Ronnie Coleman and the best Dorian Yates from any time period and determine who do you think fares better, i.e. the overall better physique.
Please only vote once, and add on to the tally. I also request you have a real account with at least 20 posts to your handle to prevent stuffing the ballot box.
Thanks.
I'll start off:
Ronnie 1, Dorian 0
-
Ronnie.
-
Arnold
-
dorian
-
Dorian
-
so i vote ronnie so that makes it
Ronnie 3, Dorian 3
-
you can't create a real poll? You're a tool..
-
I'm with stupids.
-
ronnie in 1998 mr O.
since then he has gone downhill...
-
Ronnie by a country mile (this counts for two).
Isn't it possible to post a clickable poll?
I think but the integrity is lost.
Ronnie 5, Dorian 3
-
Ronnie. No question about it!
(http://www.kulturistika.com/gallery/1115026840_157.jpg)
Dorian cant touch this ::)
-
Ronnie. No question about it!
(http://www.kulturistika.com/gallery/1115026840_157.jpg)
Dorian cant touch this ::)
Ronnie by two country miles. ;D
-
Ronnie
-
Dorian.
melt-down
-
ronnie. easy.
-
Ronnie
-
def Ronnie
-
Silence matt, you're making the tally unnecessarily difficult.
Ronnie.
-
DOZ
-
Diesel.
-
Ronnie
-
tie
-
Definitely The Yates. >:( Wtf? :-\
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Haney Ronnie.
-
Ronnie.
-
ronnie, without question
-
ronnie
-
ronnie . . .
although i think he should dump the Chad for the Doz . . . I think the latter knows how to "dry out" better.
-
ronnie
I personally think Kevin Levrone is better than both, although the man himself said dorian was better than ronnie
E
-
ronnie ;)
-
Both are great but i prefer DORIAN :P
CORMIER #1 8)
-
Ronnie v Dorian isn't really the important issue:
..........the real battle is ND v Hulkster, (and I'll go with ND). :D
-
Dorian MuthaFucken Yate's!!!
-
in their primes....RONALD IS UNTOUCHABLE.
-
Dorian...
-
The Multi Mr Olympia with the greatest back in history ;D
i.e The Ronster 8)
(http://www.thebiguniverse.com/coleman/o7.jpg)
-
(http://i43.photobucket.com/albums/e371/supsvm/arnolderonniecoleman.jpg)
"Congatulations Mr. Coleman."
-
alexxx
-
alexxx
This poll's about who's better - Ronnie or Dorian, NOT who the greatest (future) Mr Olympia is ::)
-
oh thx kiwiol
i forgot
-
oh thx kiwiol
i forgot
Prime against prime it's Ronnie by a mile.
You must be blind to not be able to see that.
-
Dorian gets my vote. Sheer mass isn't the same as refined class; not that Dorian had a physique that was much nicer to look at. It's very simple, he brought a level of conditioning/hardness to the stage and hasn't been successfully and consistently replicated since. Ronnie is just someone who gains muscles upon muscles, but overall he looks disgusting and a poor representation of Bodybuilding. Ronnie's only lasting tie to a legacy in BBing is his gut.
-
Ronnie. No doubt about it...
-
Ronnie
-
Dorian
-
Ronnie, the way he looked in 97-98. Ever since then he looks like shit.
YIP
Zack
-
Ronnie, no doubt.
-
this is is silly... should be flex against coleman..
or dorian against fux....
ronnie... and all the people in between nasser...paul shawn cormier dillet... francios...
and the list goes on
but
RONNIE...
-
ND isn't here, so on behalf of him, I say
Ronnie ;D
-
Ronnie Dean Coleman, baby!
(http://digilander.libero.it/gruppociak/rc133.jpg)
-
they're both disgusting
-
-Coleman
-Oliva
-Schwarzenegger
Choose one amongst the greats.
Yates isn't in the same sentence, never was. Too much about him's ordinary. Give Weider some credit: let someone win often enough and some will buy it.
-
Yates arms are so bad in that shot that they actually look like they've been photoshopped smaller there.
-
Ronnie all the way to the bank!
-
if I added it right, it's
ronnie 30, dorian 14
holding a 2:1 ratio
-
You can add 5 more to Dorian as I have the strengh of 7 men and 1 to Dorian just as a pity vote. ;D
-
Dorian
-
If we were talking about Ronnie in that pic the votes could change but he has gotten progressively worse. I really don't think 03 is redemption. Staying at a higher BW with less cuts is not a big deal to me.
the fact that Ronnie got progressively worse (except for 2003) means nothing because Dorian did the same thing.
-
if I added it right, it's
ronnie 30, dorian 14
holding a 2:1 ratio
I'm willing to bet, tht the combined I.Q of the 14 who voted for Dorian, is higher than the combined I.Q of the 30 who voted for Ronnie. ;D You see, there are other numbers tht count as well... ;)
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
I'm willing to bet, tht the combined I.Q of the 14 who voted for Dorian, is higher than the combined I.Q of the 30 who voted for Ronnie. ;D You see, there are other numbers tht count as well... ;)
SUCKMYMUSCLE
With this post you just proved that if the combined IQ of those 14 is very high, for sure it's not because of you... ;)
-
Dorian
-
this is is silly... should be flex against coleman..
Flex pwned both their asses.
Metaphorically, that is.
I mean I'm not implying...
-
Ronnie, no doubt.
Ronnie, no doubt.
-
Dorian
-
With this post you just proved that if the combined IQ of those 14 is very high, for sure it's not because of you... ;)
I beg to differ, at least in one area: your momma sure thinks my female sexual anatomy I.Q is pretty high. ;D ;)
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
I beg to differ, at least in one area: your momma sure thinks my female sexual anatomy I.Q is pretty high. ;D ;)
SUCKMYMUSCLE
is that because you are a pussy? or is it because you have a pussy? :)
-
Ronnie.
-
ronnie...
-
ronnie...
where the hell have you been?
-
is that because you are a pussy? or is it because you have a pussy? :)
Nah, it comes from experience, after having looked closely at several of them. By the way, thanks to your momma for the lesson: I learned a lot from her! ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Nah, it comes from experience, after having looked closely at several of them. By the way, thanks to your momma for the lesson: I learned a lot from her! ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
SUCKMYMUSCLE
suckmymuscle's mom's ass is a carpenters dream, flat as a board and easy to nail.
-
ronnie
-
suckmymuscle's mom's ass is a carpenters dream, flat as a board and easy to nail.
Too bad you're not a carpenter, but a farmer: always trying to get more of those nuts and milk. ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
so whats the score so far
-
so whats the score so far
ronnie is stomping Dorian's ass.
-
Dorian wrecked the sport
RONNIE AND ITS NOT EVEN CLOSE
-
So shouldn't Ronnie have changed it to something better?
he did in 98, 99 and the 2001 AC.
Then he went crazy and bulked up to 280+ pounds... :-\
-
So shouldn't Ronnie have changed it to something better?
No but because of Dorian, Ronnie did what Dorian did and then some...Dorian planted the seed
and the judges i guess liked what Dorian brought to the table....the truth is FuX crashes Dorian in terms of sure size...Dorian just brought that granite look onstage what wowed people...Too bad he brought the massive belly to go with it
-
given that the judges awarded a 300 pound gunter a win over a 245 pound coleman, Ronnie didn't have much of a choice in his mind.
He couldn't regain his hardness of the AC without being way way too flat and depleted, so he had to bulk up or lose.
-
Ronnie Coleman
Yeaaaah Buddy!!!!
-
Officer Coleman.
-
Re: delete
-
Ronnie
-
Dorian
-
ALEXXXXXXXXXX !!!!!!!!!!
RONNIE !!!!!!!!!!!!
-
Ronnie
-
Ronnie.
-
Ronnie all the time!!! yip yip!!
-
ronnie
-
Ronnie all the time!!! yip yip!!
Wow first post and ironic you pick this thread ::) someone is trying to fluff-up the odds ;) lol its all good because we're already up eight to nothing .
-
Wow first post and ironic you pick this thread someone is trying to fluff-up the odds lol its all good because we're already up eight to nothing
More babbling. ::)
-
More babbling. ::)
Its been 5 minutes shouldn't you be posting the same pics over and over? ;)
-
The one and only.. the king of swing...the hardest working man in bodybuilding...Mr. dynamite himself... Ronnie Coleman!
-
ronnie..first year and second only
-
Dorian
-
Wow first post and ironic you pick this thread ::) someone is trying to fluff-up the odds ;) lol its all good because we're already up eight to nothing .
BWAHAHAHAHAHA.
The loser finally chimes in. This thread reinforces what a few of us have be saying all along: every can see that ronnie dominates yates at their respective peaks bar a few undesirable characters.
When will you guys stop fighting a losing battle.
Its embarassing.
Ronnie > Yates> Columbo> Dickerson
-
BWAHAHAHAHAHA.
The loser finally chimes in. This thread reinforces what a few of us have be saying all along: every can see that ronnie dominates yates at their respective peaks bar a few undesirable characters.
When will you guys stop fighting a losing battle.
Its embarassing.
Ronnie > Yates> Columbo> Dickerson
Great Post! ( :P to ND)
-
he did in 98, 99 and the 2001 AC.
Then he went crazy and bulked up to 280+ pounds... :-\
So do you admit that Ronnie sucks now?
-
Dorian
-
YATES !
-
Yates.
-
BWAHAHAHAHAHA.
The loser finally chimes in. This thread reinforces what a few of us have be saying all along: every can see that ronnie dominates yates at their respective peaks bar a few undesirable characters.
When will you guys stop fighting a losing battle.
Its embarassing.
Ronnie > Yates> Columbo> Dickerson
You truly make me laugh and I'll tell you why , when you veiw this as a ' win/lose ' situation you've already lost , why? because its neither , its an opinion , niether of us know who would beat whom , thats why we are giving our opinions , now what I find funny is seeing a few of us don't agree with your opinion , you label us as ' undesirables ' is that the best you can manage? that speaks volumes about your intelligence ;) you'll need more that that sport to run with the big dogs !!
Now seeing bodybuilding is very subjective , and personal tastes tend to dictate ones opinions we have to look for other criteria when contemplating the possible winner , and this is where I have the edge over you and Dorian has the edge over Ronnie , past history , now obviously when they met previously neither were at their all time best but what is a fact , what is undebateable , what is ironclad , is when they did meet , Ronnie fell victim to Dorian's superiorty eight times , and Dorian in fact only lost just twice as a Pro , and Ronnie lost 35 times , Dorian's win percentage rate was 88% and Ronnie's was just 42% , now by removing the personal feelings , from the debate , objectively we can use past history & mathmatical probabilty to determine that Dorian Yates in all likelyhood would beat Ronnie Coleman at their respective bests , if you think you can top that with a little something more than ' hero worship ' or your warped brand of rational , I challenge you ;) but good luck , because base on your current track record you really haven't offered up anything of value !! lol
-
Ronnie.
-
abstain
-
ok so if I counted this right its:
Ronnie 100 Yates 10
-
After losing this poll convincingly and following an unsuccessful truce called by losers, all of a sudden Yates groupies try to swarm the thread in a desperate attempt to change the result-reminds me of Bushites and Florida election results.
hahahahhahahahahahahahah
Coleman > Yates > Columbu
Yates over Columbu by a hair.
-
Ronnie............no brainer
-
Ronnie............no brainer
yip yip ;D
-
Ronnie.
-
ronnie
-
Dorian.
-
ronnie
-
Coleman
-
Ronnie
-
Ronnie.
-
The people have spoken. The votes are in.
ronnie - 48
dorian - 23
-
Ronnie by a country mile.
-
ronnie by a country link sausage
-
Dorian like the eight times before !!
-
Dorian Yates
-
Dorian like the eight times before !!
Desperate
-
Here vote here. Make it easier to keep track of
http://snappoll.com/poll/102116.php
-
ronnie
-
Here vote here. Make it easier to keep track of
http://snappoll.com/poll/102116.php
Bump Big Ronnie is going to take this out
-
Snap poll, Ronnie 11 and Dorian 4 times. I can Suckymyarsehole now, he is running to the public library to access the site by many computers; trying so hard to make his man win. Sad.
-
coleman
-
Dorian ..... Ronnie is great but..