Getbig Bodybuilding, Figure and Fitness Forums

Getbig Bodybuilding Boards => History - Stories - and Memories => Topic started by: JUSTJAXX on May 23, 2006, 02:55:33 PM

Title: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: JUSTJAXX on May 23, 2006, 02:55:33 PM
just wondering if anyone knows what was said in that confrontation backstage at the 1980 mr O...or any of the details...thanks in advance
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: alexxx on May 23, 2006, 03:21:02 PM
Something about Arnold entering the contest at the last minute and calling Mike Mentzer fat.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Lord Humungous on May 23, 2006, 06:39:35 PM
To make a long story short, the participants voted to eliminate the 2 weight classes. Arnie was the only one that wanted to keep the split and Boyer Coe asked him why. Arnie make some tuff guy remarks to him and Mentzer told him to cool it. Arnie told Mike he lost to Robbie Robinson in a past show because he was too fat and Mentzer blew his stack. Arnie being the pussy he is backed down. ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: alexxx on May 23, 2006, 06:43:12 PM
To make a long story short, the participants voted to eliminate the 2 weight classes. Arnie was the only one that wanted to keep the split and Boyer Coe asked him why. Arnie make some tuff guy remarks to him and Mentzer told him to cool it. Arnie told Mike he lost to Robbie Robinson in a past show because he was too fat and Mentzer blew his stack. Arnie being the pussy he is backed down. ;D

lol it says in Arnold's book that he was quite a brawler!
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: onlyme on May 23, 2006, 09:22:37 PM
lol it says in Arnold's book that he was quite a brawler!

That was a misprint.  It was meant to say "baller" (as in cry baby)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on May 23, 2006, 11:47:52 PM
pussy? no way. he was breaking his balls and all he wanted was for the guy to melt down.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Slick Vic on May 24, 2006, 06:47:03 PM
Funny that there are actual pictures of Arnold sitting (some claim he sat when Mike approached him) and Mike practically standing over him pointing his finger.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Lord Humungous on May 25, 2006, 05:33:17 AM
Mike owned Arnie  ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: knny187 on May 25, 2006, 12:00:22 PM
Funny that there are actual pictures of Arnold sitting (some claim he sat when Mike approached him) and Mike practically standing over him pointing his finger.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: tommywishbone on May 25, 2006, 02:09:38 PM
Great photo. I bet if Mentzer had stepped closer, Waller would have stood up and crushed him. Waller was a braller, who would mix it up. ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: stuntmovie on May 25, 2006, 05:31:47 PM
If I recall right, I think it was Arnold himself who was supposedly promoting that contest and his last minute entry pissed Mike off immensely.

I had frequent talks with Mike after that contest and he had nothing  but contempt for Arnold and always felt that the show was predetermined due to Arnold's friendship with Weider.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on May 25, 2006, 05:36:36 PM
arnold's got an obscenely big chest. he's all chest in that pic.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: onlyme on May 25, 2006, 09:50:12 PM
Is that Kenny sitting down.  It doesn't look like him.  Is it?  Anyway yes Kenny is a brawler and likes to fight.  At least he used to.  I have told the story of him chasing the car a couple times on here.  It definitely showed he like to fight.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: tommywishbone on May 25, 2006, 10:10:22 PM
Yes, I'm almost positive that's him sitting on the floor giving Mentzer the Stink-eye.  ;D. Kent Keuhn told me stories about Waller's ability to mix it up.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: BallzDeep69 on May 25, 2006, 10:30:42 PM
Great photo. I bet if Mentzer had stepped closer, Waller would have stood up and crushed him. Waller was a braller, who would mix it up. ;D


Definetly.  Waller was alot bigger and probably stronger than Mentzer and has the fiery attitude alot of red-headed guys tend to have.  Waller was known for his freakish strength back in the day!
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: onlyme on May 26, 2006, 01:12:23 AM
That guy sitting down has such small legs and arms.  He kind of looks like him.  Can anyone definitely say thats Kenny.  I will call him tommorrow and find out.  I trained with him numerous times back in the late 70's and early 80's and I keep looking at that pic and I just don't see it.  A little but......... I will find out.  But, yes I think Kenny could hav taken Arnold and Mike and I think Mike could have taken Arnold.  Arnold was not a fighter or tough guy.  He was a good talker and talked his way out of shit.  And he was never alone most of the time.  At least when I saw him.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: alexxx on May 26, 2006, 07:13:57 AM
That guy sitting down has such small legs and arms.  He kind of looks like him.  Can anyone definitely say thats Kenny.  I will call him tommorrow and find out.  I trained with him numerous times back in the late 70's and early 80's and I keep looking at that pic and I just don't see it.  A little but......... I will find out.  But, yes I think Kenny could hav taken Arnold and Mike and I think Mike could have taken Arnold.  Arnold was not a fighter or tough guy.  He was a good talker and talked his way out of shit.  And he was never alone most of the time.  At least when I saw him.

It says in his unauthorized biography that Arnold was quite the brawler in his youth.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: stuntmovie on May 26, 2006, 07:19:59 AM
YES, that is Waller.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Jeff Preston on May 26, 2006, 08:55:03 AM
Yep that's the Big Red Machine!

Keith you mentioned that you would call him. If you haven't talked to Ken in awhile that might be an exercise in futility.
Bill Grant on his last trip out to LA tried to get a hold of Ken. He called Extreme Activewear where Ken worked and they told Bill that he didn't work there anymore and as soon as his house sold he was moving back east with his son.
No one seems to know where he ended up, St Louis perhaps? (I believe his sister lives there)

I interviewed Ken for Ironage a year or so ago and this is the last update that I know of.
http://ironage.us/articles/preston-waller.html
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: knny187 on May 26, 2006, 09:03:22 AM
Keith stop doubting it....it's Waller 100%
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: alexxx on May 26, 2006, 10:32:34 AM
Yep that's the Big Red Machine!

Keith you mentioned that you would call him. If you haven't talked to Ken in awhile that might be an exercise in futility.
Bill Grant on his last trip out to LA tried to get a hold of Ken. He called Extreme Activewear where Ken worked and they told Bill that he didn't work there anymore and as soon as his house sold he was moving back east with his son.
No one seems to know where he ended up, St Louis perhaps? (I believe his sister lives there)

I interviewed Ken for Ironage a year or so ago and this is the last update that I know of.
http://ironage.us/articles/preston-waller.html


Jeff your writting style is like a cross word puzzle.. you gotta decipher every sentence and try to make sense of  it. Stop using the thesaurus and get to the point dammit!
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: onlyme on May 26, 2006, 12:17:16 PM
okay then I won 't call him.  I thought it would be nice to talk to him a little, but if he don't work there anymore forget it.  thanks
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on May 26, 2006, 04:47:15 PM
It's clear he doesn't want to be seen-no pics that i've seen after the 1970s, noticable absence at the Pumping Iron re-release with everyone else there.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: onlyme on May 26, 2006, 10:17:40 PM
I saw allot in the 80's.  We trained a few times together and went to lunch.  He came into the club I was bouncing at all the time.  It was so funny cause he would see me at a restaurtant or movie or just out and it just so happen he would almost always see me with a different girl.  He would tell the girl to watch out for me and to make sure to use protection.  he would say that in a normal voice with people around or not.  Veyr embarrasing.  He had the best tank tops.  KW Enterprises.  Then he went to work for ExtremeWear.  Then I saw him at shows and talked to him on the phone when I had to order some shirts.  I haven't talked to him in maybe a year or so.  SO I had no idea he had left Extreme.  I'll never forget, me Manny Perry, Ron Depolito watching him chase that car down the street to beat up those kids.  That was so funny
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Hurricane Beef ! on May 28, 2006, 08:03:44 AM
Great photo. I bet if Mentzer had stepped closer, Waller would have stood up and crushed him. Waller was a braller, who would mix it up. ;D

It's odd you would say that. I always got the same impression from that photo . . . sort of a Volume vs.H.I.T ( Boyer was using Mentzers methods then  and was pissed at Arnold ) old school vs new school thing.

I think Waller would have been a bastard to start with, there are pics of him using 150's in the incline bell press in the early 70's. He was as strong as the come and if he liked to mix it up, it would have been a nasty combo. One only Ronnie Abston might have been able to deal with.

The Beef
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Jeff Preston on May 28, 2006, 11:42:56 AM
I think Waller would have been a bastard to start with, there are pics of him using 150's in the incline bell press in the early 70's.

And here are those pics!

(http://pic7.picturetrail.com/VOL208/994433/2943765/38549266.jpg)

(http://pic7.picturetrail.com/VOL208/994433/2943765/38549256.jpg)

(http://pic7.picturetrail.com/VOL208/994433/2943765/38549250.jpg)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on May 28, 2006, 12:50:52 PM
that dont look like waller. he looks like John Kerry on the juice.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on May 28, 2006, 01:11:26 PM
Quote
I always got the same impression from that photo . . . sort of a Volume vs.H.I.T ( Boyer was using Mentzers methods then  and was pissed at Arnold ) old school vs new school thing.
Supposedly it was the difference in training philosophies as well as personal dislikes. A little surprising if true-apparently Schwarzenegger got bent out of shape about Mentzer's training and how it discredited Arnold's approach, which seems more than a little small.

Personally it would be easy to dislike Schwarzenegger with the arrogance, BS and non-stop need for an ever-present side-kick to whisper negatives about others to. There is just the slightest  split-second's glimpse of Mentzer in Pumping Iron: being ignored while drinking a supplement at the Gold's Gym counter when Arnold comes in.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: knny187 on May 28, 2006, 02:19:12 PM
When watching pumping iron....there's a spot where Waller is doing pulldowns & you can hear some 45's clanging in repetition.......(i love that sound).
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Dan-O on June 01, 2006, 08:01:55 AM
That was a good interview with Waller on ironage.com.  Why did I always think Waller was Aussie?  Weird...  I wonder where I got that idea.  So he was born & raised in Kentucky then?
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Gord on June 01, 2006, 10:07:19 AM
That was a good interview with Waller on ironage.com.  Why did I always think Waller was Aussie?  Weird...  I wonder where I got that idea.  So he was born & raised in Kentucky then?

Could you have been thinking of Roger Walker, who was actually UK born, but became an aussie citizen later and competed in the 1980 Olynmpia (like Waller)?

Here he is on the far right, back row (for some reason he kept staring at Arnold in just about every 1980 'O' shot I've seen of him)!








 
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Dan-O on June 01, 2006, 11:24:12 AM
Could you have been thinking of Roger Walker, who was actually UK born, but became an aussie citizen later and competed in the 1980 Olynmpia (like Waller)?

Here he is on the far right, back row (for some reason he kept staring at Arnold in just about every 1980 'O' shot I've seen of him)!




No, I wasn't confusing him with Walker but Roger did look pretty awesome at the 1980 Olympia.  I always wondered if he would've done better if he'd had any kind of tan, which he did not.  He definitely should've gotten better than 6th place.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: knny187 on June 01, 2006, 12:00:22 PM
No, I wasn't confusing him with Walker but Roger did look pretty awesome at the 1980 Olympia.  I always wondered if he would've done better if he'd had any kind of tan, which he did not.  He definitely should've gotten better than 6th place.

I agree.....I think he looked much better than placing 6th
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Peaking at 45 !!! on June 02, 2006, 05:24:32 PM
Yes, that is Ken Waller, I was reading all the magazines at the time when all that was happening, and I remember a quote about Arnold telling Mike Mentzer that he lost because he had a fat stomach.

Arnold should not have won that contest, if it was truly based on best build on that day. No surprise !
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Bossa on June 02, 2006, 10:09:01 PM
Yep that's the Big Red Machine!

Keith you mentioned that you would call him. If you haven't talked to Ken in awhile that might be an exercise in futility.
Bill Grant on his last trip out to LA tried to get a hold of Ken. He called Extreme Activewear where Ken worked and they told Bill that he didn't work there anymore and as soon as his house sold he was moving back east with his son.
No one seems to know where he ended up, St Louis perhaps? (I believe his sister lives there)

I interviewed Ken for Ironage a year or so ago and this is the last update that I know of.
http://ironage.us/articles/preston-waller.html


A google search for his son shows that he is in st louis

http://72.14.207.104/search?q=cache:tdE5jbeiKxQJ:prepsports3.stltoday.com/basketballboys/06/stats/lead518.shtm+%22ron+waller%22%2Bbasketball&hl=en&gl=ca&ct=clnk&cd=1 (http://72.14.207.104/search?q=cache:tdE5jbeiKxQJ:prepsports3.stltoday.com/basketballboys/06/stats/lead518.shtm+%22ron+waller%22%2Bbasketball&hl=en&gl=ca&ct=clnk&cd=1)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Playboy on July 31, 2006, 11:47:20 AM
pussy? no way. he was breaking his balls and all he wanted was for the guy to melt down.
Excactly, He did the same to Ferrigno, Oliva & half the others from back in the day. That was his way of making the compitition nervous so they couldn't think straight come posing time.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: bigragu on August 05, 2006, 07:10:21 PM
Mentzer was mad because Arnold entered the contest at the very last minute. The rules stated that all competitors must register 3 weeks prior to the contest - this rule was obviously waived for Arnold. You see Conan was supposed to start filming in 1981, however that date was brought forward unexpectedly. The first scenes were to be shot in August 1980. In addition, Universal, the films distributor was going to use thise footage as a promo along with it's Christmas release of Flash Gordon. All of a sudden, Arnold had to get big, and fast. The best way to get big - and to get attention doing so - was to attempt the unthinkable: to make a comeback! You see Arnold was scheduled to arrive in Sydney as a TV Commentator only - so you can imagine everyone's surpise when he registered to compete at the very last minute. Mentzer was pissed.  Reg Park was also put in a precarious position as he was one of the judges and of course him and Arnold were very close. Paul Graham was the promoter of that event and him and Arnold were also very close - he is the big guy who pulls Arnold in and hugs him in the very beginning of the movie Pumping Iron. The argument between Arnold and Mike Mentzer was over the fact that Boyer Coe was instrumental in getting the IFBB rules changed for the 1980 Olympia so that instead of a winner being chosen from the best of two weight classes he would emerge from six all-comer finalists. Arnold was the only one who objected to this. Arnold wanted only two weight classes, that way there is only one man to beat. Mentzer got pissed and told Arnold that he was acting like a baby and Arnold said to Mike, " If your belly wasn't as big as your mouth, then maybe you would have a chance at this event". Mike then jumped up and got in Arnold's face and Arnold just sat cooly and laughed it off...Classic example of mental psyche-out which Arnold was famous for since it almost always worked. Needless to say, Mentzer was not a threat to Arnold's throne as Mike ended up third, behind Chris Dickerson. If anyone had a chance to beat Arnold it was Chris and not Mike.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on August 06, 2006, 12:21:21 AM
i remember seeing dickerson. he had no arms. arnold had no legs but it's better to have no legs than no arms. at least it was in 1980.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Dan-O on August 06, 2006, 12:32:25 AM
Needless to say, Mentzer was not a threat to Arnold's throne as Mike ended up third, behind Chris Dickerson. If anyone had a chance to beat Arnold it was Chris and not Mike.

Actually a slight correction--Frank Zane and Boyer Coe took 3rd and 4th places respectively, leaving Mike in fifth place which was even more of a slap in the face from the powers-that-be.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: knny187 on August 06, 2006, 09:49:25 AM
Mentzer was mad because Arnold entered the contest at the very last minute. The rules stated that all competitors must register 3 weeks prior to the contest - this rule was obviously waived for Arnold. You see Conan was supposed to start filming in 1981, however that date was brought forward unexpectedly. The first scenes were to be shot in August 1980. In addition, Universal, the films distributor was going to use thise footage as a promo along with it's Christmas release of Flash Gordon. All of a sudden, Arnold had to get big, and fast. The best way to get big - and to get attention doing so - was to attempt the unthinkable: to make a comeback! You see Arnold was scheduled to arrive in Sydney as a TV Commentator only - so you can imagine everyone's surpise when he registered to compete at the very last minute. Mentzer was pissed.  Reg Park was also put in a precarious position as he was one of the judges and of course him and Arnold were very close. Paul Graham was the promoter of that event and him and Arnold were also very close - he is the big guy who pulls Arnold in and hugs him in the very beginning of the movie Pumping Iron. The argument between Arnold and Mike Mentzer was over the fact that Boyer Coe was instrumental in getting the IFBB rules changed for the 1980 Olympia so that instead of a winner being chosen from the best of two weight classes he would emerge from six all-comer finalists. Arnold was the only one who objected to this. Arnold wanted only two weight classes, that way there is only one man to beat. Mentzer got pissed and told Arnold that he was acting like a baby and Arnold said to Mike, " If your belly wasn't as big as your mouth, then maybe you would have a chance at this event". Mike then jumped up and got in Arnold's face and Arnold just sat cooly and laughed it off...Classic example of mental psyche-out which Arnold was famous for since it almost always worked. Needless to say, Mentzer was not a threat to Arnold's throne as Mike ended up third, behind Chris Dickerson. If anyone had a chance to beat Arnold it was Chris and not Mike.

From what I read in past & old articles....this is what I remember
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: bigragu on August 06, 2006, 11:25:14 AM
Actually a slight correction--Frank Zane and Boyer Coe took 3rd and 4th places respectively, leaving Mike in fifth place which was even more of a slap in the face from the powers-that-be.

Yes, my mistake Dan-O. Thanks for the correction.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: alexxx on August 06, 2006, 11:27:27 AM
From what I read in past & old articles....this is what I remember

Go on..
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: knny187 on August 07, 2006, 09:05:30 AM
Go on..

DS
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Jr. Yates on August 09, 2006, 06:30:47 PM
I had no idea that even was  a confrontation......I knew that there was always a debate over arnold and mike about that contest. hmmm thats interesting.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: alexxx on August 09, 2006, 07:55:40 PM
Looks like Arnold had something to say after all..
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Jr. Yates on August 09, 2006, 09:24:19 PM
holy shit! thats crazy.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on August 10, 2006, 04:46:48 AM
Arnold's abs look a little messy there. I dont think the competition was so strong. maybe if Arnold had 2 more months to regrow his legs and come in better condition there wouldn't be any controversy.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Lord Humungous on August 10, 2006, 08:36:00 AM
Arnie looked like crap at that show
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: alexxx on August 10, 2006, 12:08:46 PM
I have the 1980 Mr. Olympia DVD and Arnold less then stellar still blows them all away!

Here is a comparison of his form in 80(left) and 74(right).
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 15, 2006, 12:50:33 PM
Could you have been thinking of Roger Walker, who was actually UK born, but became an aussie citizen later and competed in the 1980 Olynmpia (like Waller)?

Here he is on the far right, back row (for some reason he kept staring at Arnold in just about every 1980 'O' shot I've seen of him)!








 


What the, Mentzer blew everyone else away! Mass, shape, conditioning...1st place should have been his, not the joke that was 5th...
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 15, 2006, 12:52:18 PM


Haha, it's obvious that Mike OWNED Arnie there...Arnie couldn't even bear to look at Mentzer, he was petrified to the core!
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: bmacsys on August 16, 2006, 10:37:59 AM
pussy? no way. he was breaking his balls and all he wanted was for the guy to melt down.

I don't think so. All accounts of that day state Mike put a scare into Arnold when  Mike blew his stack.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: bmacsys on August 16, 2006, 10:38:54 AM
Great photo. I bet if Mentzer had stepped closer, Waller would have stood up and crushed him. Waller was a braller, who would mix it up. ;D

Waller was a tough, ex-football playing country boy.


Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: onlyme on August 17, 2006, 12:22:45 AM
Waller was a tough, ex-football playing country boy.





Kenny loved to fight.  I told a story on the history about when me,Kenny, Manny Perry and Ron Depolito were walking across the street in frontof World Gym.  A car with 3 or 4 guys almost hit us.  Kenny ran at least a mile after these guys.  We jumped in the car and chased after him.  He said he was hoping they would hit a red light or stop sign. Hewas funny.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: FREAKgeek on August 17, 2006, 06:00:11 PM
The Mentzer hype in that show was overrated. His chest was flat and other than his conditioning, nothing really stood out.

Arnold, even at his worst, still had that unbeatable structure.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 17, 2006, 08:53:13 PM
The Mentzer hype in that show was overrated. His chest was flat and other than his conditioning, nothing really stood out.

Arnold, even at his worst, still had that unbeatable structure.

Mentzer was unbeatable that day due to his combo of mass and symmetry. Arnold was a joke. Unbeatable structure? He towered above Mike but yet his legs were significantly SMALLER...I rest my case.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: FREAKgeek on August 17, 2006, 09:03:44 PM
Mentzer has more mass?
Where?

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=73618.0;attach=82329;image)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 17, 2006, 09:23:04 PM
Mentzer has more mass?
Where?

(http://www.getbig.com/boards/index.php?action=dlattach;topic=73618.0;attach=82329;image)

Arms, quads, delts, everywhere....compare Mike's arms to Zane's and his legs to Arnie's toothpicks..out of all the BBs there, Mentzer was the most balanced, symmetrical and yes, massive.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Hedgehog on August 18, 2006, 01:39:49 AM
I used to a Mentzer fan through and through.

Still thinks he had a crazy physique.







But Arnold was the man. He's the greatest bodybuilder ever.

I don't count Sergio as a bodybuilder, he's on a different level, unique.

But when it comes to humans, Arnold rule.

YIP
Zack
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 18, 2006, 06:14:07 AM
Quote
Quote from: FREAKgeek on August 17, 2006, 09:00:11 PM
The Mentzer hype in that show was overrated. His chest was flat and other than his conditioning, nothing really stood out.

Arnold, even at his worst, still had that unbeatable structure.


Mentzer was unbeatable that day due to his combo of mass and symmetry.
That pic proves that even at less than his best, Schwarzenegger had better aesthetics, refinement, muscle maturity and structure, even when he was not what he had been. Also had a height advantage.

Mentzer was never as good as hyped IMO, and while good was always the 3-4th best BB in the world-both Schwarzenegger & Zane had better aesthetics & structure in that pic. Mentzer had virtually no detail in parts of his upper body-arms, chest, delts, etc. He was not clearly better than Schwarzenegger in 1980; if he hadn't been so carried away with himself, Mentzer might've accepted this and tried to get better instead of having a career-ending meltdown when he lost.


Quote
Waller was a tough, ex-football playing country boy.
CFL, like Ferrigno.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: bmacsys on August 18, 2006, 06:59:53 AM

Kenny loved to fight.  I told a story on the history about when me,Kenny, Manny Perry and Ron Depolito were walking across the street in frontof World Gym.  A car with 3 or 4 guys almost hit us.  Kenny ran at least a mile after these guys.  We jumped in the car and chased after him.  He said he was hoping they would hit a red light or stop sign. Hewas funny.

Keith, where did all these guys with character like Waller go? Seems like todays bodybuilders have no charisma.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on August 18, 2006, 07:25:49 AM
Arnold's chest has monster thickness there.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: knny187 on August 18, 2006, 11:32:04 AM
Big Arnold fan....but Mike had bigger arms that day
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 19, 2006, 07:05:41 PM
That pic proves that even at less than his best, Schwarzenegger had better aesthetics, refinement, muscle maturity and structure, even when he was not what he had been. Also had a height advantage.

Mentzer was never as good as hyped IMO, and while good was always the 3-4th best BB in the world-both Schwarzenegger & Zane had better aesthetics & structure in that pic. Mentzer had virtually no detail in parts of his upper body-arms, chest, delts, etc. He was not clearly better than Schwarzenegger in 1980; if he hadn't been so carried away with himself, Mentzer might've accepted this and tried to get better instead of having a career-ending meltdown when he lost.

CFL, like Ferrigno.

Mentzer was bigger, harder, more conditioned and balanced than any other BB out there at the 1980 Mr O, as anyone with eyes can clarly see for himself from that comparison shot; Mike was so dry and in such shape that he almost looked to be bursting out of ghis skin! Arnold was all arms and no legs..what structure? He carried less mass than Mentzer on a taller frame but was yet a tad NARROWER than Mike! I'm not sure Arnie even merited a top 3 berth that day, and don't get me srated on Zane...excellent conditioning as usual and the defending champ but just too SMALL to contend with Mike. Arnold may own Mike in terms of career excellence but he shoulda stayed retired and off his Dbol instead of receiving a dubious gift from Uncle Joe.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 20, 2006, 07:44:38 AM
Quote
Mentzer was bigger, harder, more conditioned and balanced than any other BB out there at the 1980 Mr O, as anyone with eyes can clarly see for himself from that comparison shot

Only proves that you have a bias for his type of physique, because the pic does not show him to be quite as good. I never liked his physique, especially the extreme lack of refinement and detail in areas like arms and chest. Also lacked shoulder to waist differential relative to both Schwarzenegger and Zane as can be seen in that pic, in addition to his lack of refinement, detail and aesthetics.

He was never quite as good as Robinson, Padilla or Fox, let alone Szkalak who beat him.

I did like the way he stood up to Schwarzenegger though; it demolishes the whole theory that Schwarzenegger propogates endlessly that he was always able to psyche out his opponents, which was largely made-up BS.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 21, 2006, 12:59:35 AM
Only proves that you have a bias for his type of physique, because the pic does not show him to be quite as good. I never liked his physique, especially the extreme lack of refinement and detail in areas like arms and chest. Also lacked shoulder to waist differential relative to both Schwarzenegger and Zane as can be seen in that pic, in addition to his lack of refinement, detail and aesthetics.

He was never quite as good as Robinson, Padilla or Fox, let alone Szkalak who beat him.

I did like the way he stood up to Schwarzenegger though; it demolishes the whole theory that Schwarzenegger propogates endlessly that he was always able to psyche out his opponents, which was largely made-up BS.

You never liked his physique? Who's the one being biased now? You mention shoulder to waist differential but conveniently neglect to consider sorely lacking aspects of both the Zane and Shwarzenegger physique, at least in that '80 show anyway. Like I said, Mentzer was the most balanced and complete physique that day, along with the vascular mass he carried. MM had a tight waist, bigger than Zane's, but that was to be expected with his torso looking TWICE as massive. I just don't get why folks like yourself continually overlook the obvious; it's a crime! Just give the man his due. Arms and pecs thicker than Arnie's, frame BROADER despite being far shorter than Arnie, and legs destroying Arnie's toothpicks...points that destroy your arguments I'm afraid. Frank looked like Christine Zane next to Mike; it was almost a complete joke! Padilla and Robinson were phenomenal too but not in the lineup that day. ;)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 21, 2006, 05:43:46 AM
Give the man his due when better BBs like Robinson, Padilla, Fox and Szkalak were also denied because of politics? You show no balance obsessing on just Mentzer.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 22, 2006, 01:29:43 AM
Give the man his due when better BBs like Robinson, Padilla, Fox and Szkalak were also denied because of politics? You show no balance obsessing on just Mentzer.


My friend, I've already stated that all of the above BBs were awesome too (except that Kalman left the spoty way too early) but right here we are talking about Mentzer and the '80 Olympia. Isn't that what this thread's title says? I just find it hard to believe that folks can continue to deny the man his due when anyone with eyes and a brain can see he was by far the best BB that day.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 22, 2006, 06:16:58 AM
Quote
I just find it hard to believe that folks can continue to deny the man his due when anyone with eyes and a brain can see he was by far the best BB that day.

No obvious advantage over Arnold. That it was fixed is another story.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: FREAKgeek on August 22, 2006, 07:59:51 PM
My friend, I've already stated that all of the above BBs were awesome too (except that Kalman left the spoty way too early) but right here we are talking about Mentzer and the '80 Olympia. Isn't that what this thread's title says? I just find it hard to believe that folks can continue to deny the man his due when anyone with eyes and a brain can see he was by far the best BB that day.

Silly. He was placed 5th. Blind as a bat and far the best?

Here's your boy getting owned again by zane

(http://dnj23.onesite.com/images/mro1980.jpg)

Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: FREAKgeek on August 22, 2006, 08:06:42 PM
You never liked his physique? Who's the one being biased now? You mention shoulder to waist differential but conveniently neglect to consider sorely lacking aspects of both the Zane and Shwarzenegger physique, at least in that '80 show anyway. Like I said, Mentzer was the most balanced and complete physique that day, along with the vascular mass he carried. MM had a tight waist, bigger than Zane's, but that was to be expected with his torso looking TWICE as massive. I just don't get why folks like yourself continually overlook the obvious; it's a crime! Just give the man his due. Arms and pecs thicker than Arnie's, frame BROADER despite being far shorter than Arnie, and legs destroying Arnie's toothpicks...points that destroy your arguments I'm afraid. Frank looked like Christine Zane next to Mike; it was almost a complete joke! Padilla and Robinson were phenomenal too but not in the lineup that day. ;)

Why does everyone think Mentzer is such a BB'ing martyr?

He is a pioneer of nothing but drivel.

He endorses Power Factor Training, by Sisco and Little, what a joke.




Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: FREAKgeek on August 22, 2006, 08:08:19 PM
Here is your crybaby being destroyed by Zane's conditioning in 1979.

(http://dnj23.onesite.com/images/index33.jpg)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on August 22, 2006, 09:22:30 PM
monster hardness
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Jr. Yates on August 22, 2006, 09:25:59 PM
Thats a good comparison pic, I love Menzter but Zane takes it there.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: FREAKgeek on August 22, 2006, 10:58:19 PM
Mentzer was right about reducing volume and frequency; he is right about overtraining like his influence Arthur Jones, but he took it too far.  His dogmatic assumption that it's all about intensity and not volume IS WRONG. A certain amount of volume is still predominantly anerobic and necessary for hypertrophy. Muscles want work. Too much intensity leaves your nervous system taxed. Nobody, and I mean nobody, will develop a pro physique through exclusive heavy duty. It is initially good for strength gains, but it will leave you burned out or chronically adjusted to the routine depending on your efforts. Strength gains does not necessarily mean muscular gains. Mentzer himself did not build his physique through his protocols either.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 23, 2006, 01:55:52 AM
Here is your crybaby being destroyed by Zane's conditioning in 1979.

(http://dnj23.onesite.com/images/index33.jpg)

Haha, epic size on Zane; why not show Susie Curry ripped next to Mike though and hand her a SAndow? ::)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on August 23, 2006, 05:37:05 AM
Haha? how many olympias have you won?
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 23, 2006, 09:37:23 AM
Quote
His dogmatic assumption that it's all about intensity and not volume IS WRONG. A certain amount of volume is still predominantly anerobic and necessary for hypertrophy. Muscles want work. Too much intensity leaves your nervous system taxed.

Agreed, moderation between the two extremes makes more sense and is less taxing. Even a HIT proponent like Viator believed in the advantages of pre-contest volume training, for the refinement it provided.

Mentzer was always overrated to some extent-he just didn't have that much refinement to warrant the hype that he himself believed. Zane looks a lot better other than the size difference. Mentzer didn't even have a decent tan; all those little things add up.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 24, 2006, 01:44:42 AM
Agreed, moderation between the two extremes makes more sense and is less taxing. Even a HIT proponent like Viator believed in the advantages of pre-contest volume training, for the refinement it provided.

Mentzer was always overrated to some extent-he just didn't have that much refinement to warrant the hype that he himself believed. Zane looks a lot better other than the size difference. Mentzer didn't even have a decent tan; all those little things add up.

Not true in '80; maybe in '79 but not the following year.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 24, 2006, 02:42:27 AM
No obvious advantage over Arnold. That it was fixed is another story.

LMAO, no obvious advantage over toothpicks legs and narrow framed Arnold? ;)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 24, 2006, 02:46:15 AM
Silly. He was placed 5th. Blind as a bat and far the best?

Here's your boy getting owned again by zane

(http://dnj23.onesite.com/images/mro1980.jpg)



Hahaha, getting owned by an undersized Zane with tricep tilted toward the camera, thus lending an illusion of greater cuts? I don't buy it but nice try to discredit Mentzer, the rightful winner of da Sandow that day, kiddo.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 24, 2006, 02:50:48 AM
Why does everyone think Mentzer is such a BB'ing martyr?

He is a pioneer of nothing but drivel.

He endorses Power Factor Training, by Sisco and Little, what a joke.






LOL yeah, so he sold and endorsed some crap, that means he automatically didn't deserve the '80 Sandow...brutal logic...I can't believe kids like these can be so irrational and foolish due to unmitigated bias...
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: smaul on August 24, 2006, 05:08:15 AM
Was Zane knocked-kneed?  In every photo you see of him he seems to point his knees inwards, to emphasize the size of his upper body maybe?
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 24, 2006, 07:04:15 AM
Quote
Not true in '80; maybe in '79 but not the following year.
You're obviously way biased & resolute in your denial of it-he doesn't look so great in those shots either. As mentioned and as you refuse to acknowledge, he did NOT do a good job with the little details that can make a crucial difference: he had as usual insufficient muscular refinement in some areas of the upper body, had no tan & looked pasty, etc. even in 1980. Both Zane & Schwarzenegger had those attributes and looked polished, he didn't. Typical of Mentzer & HIT in general there's a smugness there that led to his downfall, that his fans also seem to retain as if they know better than anyone else. ;D


Quote
Was Zane knocked-kneed?  In every photo you see of him he seems to point his knees inwards, to emphasize the size of his upper body maybe?
I've seen that so many times in his poses; should've learned to avoid that as much as possible, though part of it might've been structural. He was never an ideal in that respect despite the rhetoric involving his aesthetics, IMO.


*Nothing* impressive about Mentzer here-rid yourself of your preconceptions and obsession with size just long enough to notice that Mentzer had virtually no cuts or detail, looked pasty AND washed-out.  ;) Zane had all of those things that Mentzer lacked. Deal with it.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 24, 2006, 07:22:13 AM
Further evidence of Mentzer with virtually *no* detail or refinement (as usual), washed out, pasty..Zane had all the refinement, detail & polish that Mentzer lacked. Mentzer was as oblivious to this as you are which is why he was devasted and retired, like a little baby.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 25, 2006, 09:35:10 AM
Further evidence of Mentzer with virtually *no* detail or refinement (as usual), washed out, pasty..Zane had all the refinement, detail & polish that Mentzer lacked. Mentzer was as oblivious to this as you are which is why he was devasted and retired, like a little baby.

LOL yeah no refinement...the camera's just catching Zane's arm at a tilted angle ya stupid dweeb...why are you kids so dumb? Must be the porn nowadays... ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 25, 2006, 10:26:57 AM
The "only" problem with your constant flimsy excuses is that my observations hold for all pics in this thread.  ;D ;D ;D Basically you can't even entertain let alone accept the reality that you're a Mentzer groupie who is 100% blinded/deluded by fanaticism. I don't have any particular bias or preference for any of the guys in that contest.

Mentzer was never the best guy in any contest I've seen-*always* lacked refinement and polish in key areas of the upper body. ;)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 25, 2006, 11:52:37 AM
The "only" problem with your constant flimsy excuses is that my observations hold for all pics in this thread.  ;D ;D ;D Basically you can't even entertain let alone accept the reality that you're a Mentzer groupie who is 100% blinded/deluded by fanaticism. I don't have any particular bias or preference for any of the guys in that contest.

Mentzer was never the best guy in any contest I've seen-*always* lacked refinement and polish in key areas of the upper body. ;)

Hahaha, yeah your "observations". The only things that lack refinement and polish are your flimsy arguments fuelled by Mentzer hatredl only a fool or someone with hatred for the guy would continue overlooking the patently obvious. Or you're a just a 'tard, plain & simple. Show me one thing you've said that is true. Making conjecture about Zane's conditioning and Mentzer's supposed lack thereof still won't make you a man...boy. Still, you're a pretty funny kid I'll give ya that; I might just decide to keep toyin' around with you for laughs. ;)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 25, 2006, 12:12:12 PM
Your "case": endless blathering and excuses for Mentzer.


My case: pics don't lie.  ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 25, 2006, 12:18:39 PM
My "case": endless blathering and excuses against Mentzer.


Your case: pics don't lie.  ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D ;D

Haha, ok "Pumpster", whatever you say! ;)



Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 25, 2006, 12:21:34 PM
Take a good look at your Mike "no cuts" Mentzer posters and be honest with yourself.. ;D ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 25, 2006, 12:22:18 PM
Zane had all of those things that Mentzer lacked. Deal with it.


Well, maybe Zane did have a pussy, he was so small. In that sense, maybe yer right ya lil' homo. ;) My misguided, deluded, pathetic lil' friend, definition does count for something obviously but at the end of the day, the sport's called BODYBUILDING.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 25, 2006, 12:23:15 PM
Take a good look at your Mike "no cuts" Mentzer posters and be honest with yourself.. ;D ;D ;D ;D

They don't exist; the only one here with no cuts is you....boy. ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 25, 2006, 01:07:11 PM
Quote
My misguided, deluded, pathetic lil' friend, definition does count for something obviously but at the end of the day, the sport's called BODYBUILDING.
Forgetting Zane, there were "only" 4-5 other guys who could regularly beat Mentzer: Robinson, Padilla, Fox, Szkalak, etc. I like your taste in BBs!  ::) ::) ::)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 25, 2006, 01:18:51 PM
Forgetting Zane, there were "only" 4-5 other guys who could regularly beat Mentzer: Robinson, Padilla, Fox, Szkalak, etc. I like your taste in BBs!  ::) ::) ::)

The above were all amazing and were at least comparable with Mike (Robinson was definitely superior though) except for Szkalak who left before his potential was fulfilled. Zane was too small by the late '70s though a legend nontheless. It's just that when turds like yourself overlook the obvious (Zane too small all-round and Arnie having chicken legs and a narrowe frame despte being taller!), you kids need to be bitchslapped. I'm not talking about '79 now ya little dipshit but '80 where MM's balance of size, symmetry and conditioning blew all comers away.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 25, 2006, 01:43:56 PM
Unfortunately for you i see things very clearly, which is why you're now forced to agree with my pithy analysis of other BBs of the era.

Then be bothered by the now almost completely forgotten fact that Robinson was never allowed to win, nor Padilla or Fox. Stop obsessing on Mentzer who was very good but not quite great you whiny little homo groupie. ;)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: suckmymuscle on August 26, 2006, 12:45:55 AM
  Yes, Mentzer recalled the episode:

  "Here was this big Prussian son of a bitch disrespecting a bodybuilding legend. We were all shocked by how arrogant and debacuhed Arnold's attitude was. I confronted him about it, and he cowered."

  Poor Mentzer; he simply didn't have the genetics to beat Arnold. I personally admire his precise, logical approach to bodybuilding training. But the thing is, I suspect, that he took his obsession with Rand and objectivism too far. He bacame excessively logical, and started to believe that Humans relate to each other through objectivist logic; he actually believed that mind games, manipulation and favoritism are not parts of Human interaction. How could he win the title against a man who, although he had retired previously, was, coming into the contest, a six time Olympia winner, and who defeated him on both muscularity and natural structure? Poor Mike... ::)

  Also, Arnold is a natural alpha male: a man who was born to rule. It's obvious that Arnold's ability to play mind and political games was superior to Mike's: Arnold completely and utterly dominated all the men around him, through a combination of intimidation, false flattery and outright deceit. Mike never had a chance. The fact that he publicly criticized Weider and his training methods, on magazine articles, didn't help him either to win Joe's most important contest. Mentzer was a great bodybuilder and a brilliant intellectual, but he was a social retard. :-\

SUCKMYMUSCLE
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 26, 2006, 06:02:19 AM
Quote
Also, Arnold is a natural alpha male: a man who was born to rule. It's obvious that Arnold's ability to play mind and political games was superior to Mike's: Arnold completely and utterly dominated all the men around him, through a combination of intimidation, false flattery and outright deceit. Mike never had a chance. The fact that he publicly criticized Weider and his training methods, on magazine articles, didn't help him either to win Joe's most important contest. Mentzer was a great bodybuilder and a brilliant intellectual, but he was a social retard.

Agreed, except that I'm not sure that their personas had much to do with it-Schwarzenegger was going to win as long as it was close, period. I give Mentzer credit for standing up to him however Weider and others had already decided the outcome as long as Schwarzenegger was in reasonable shape.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: suckmymuscle on August 26, 2006, 09:23:54 PM
Agreed, except that I'm not sure that their personas had much to do with it-Schwarzenegger was going to win as long as it was close, period. I give Mentzer credit for standing up to him however Weider and others had already decided the outcome as long as Schwarzenegger was in reasonable shape.

  Oh damn, Pumpster, you finally agree with me! :D :D :D :D :D :D I agree with you, but I think that Mentzer's lack of personal charm and his abarsive, non-negotiating personality made him lose a lot of opportunities in life. For instance, his obsession with moral rectitude made him feel so upset by Arnold's victory that he simply called it quits. For good. Any other champion, in his position, would have re-grouped and competed the following year, especially considering that Arnold would be out.

SUCKMYMUSCLE
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 28, 2006, 06:12:07 AM
Unfortunately for you i see things very clearly, which is why you're now forced to agree with my pithy analysis of other BBs of the era.

Then be bothered by the now almost completely forgotten fact that Robinson was never allowed to win, nor Padilla or Fox. Stop obsessing on Mentzer who was very good but not quite great you whiny little homo groupie. ;)

Haha yeah, so clearly that your "pithy analysis" has led you to see inferior BBers like Arnold and Zane as the winners, LOL. You can't answer the facts kiddo, so you deviate from the argument at hand. Get a brain dipshit and realise we're talking about MM here, and his '80 Mr O victory. ;)
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on August 28, 2006, 06:21:52 AM
Quote
Get a brain dipshit and realise we're talking about MM here, and his '80 Mr O victory

Tear yourself away from your Mentzer posters long enough to finally accept that he was never as good as you thought; in reality he was only in the top 4-5 guys in the world at the time, hardly the dominator your fantasies suggest. ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on August 30, 2006, 07:26:14 AM
Tear yourself away from your Mentzer posters long enough to finally accept that he was never as good as you thought; in reality he was only in the top 4-5 guys in the world at the time, hardly the dominator your fantasies suggest. ;D

When I did say otherwise? MM was not the best BB of his era, just the best at the '80 O.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 02, 2006, 10:07:44 AM
Too bad "golden" can't get his simply BB facts straight. hahahahahaha

LOL@simply. Too bad your myopic vision sees inferior BBers like skinny Zane and chickenlegged Arnold as being superior, hahahaha!
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: suckmymuscle on September 03, 2006, 01:02:23 AM
LOL@simply. Too bad your myopic vision sees inferior BBers like skinny Zane and chickenlegged Arnold as being superior, hahahaha!

  Don't worry about Pumpster. He's a fanatic who hates Dorian Yates and anything associated with him. Mentzer coached Dorian; ergo, Pumpster hates him.

SUCKMYMUSCLE
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 03, 2006, 07:03:42 PM
  Don't worry about Pumpster. He's a fanatic who hates Dorian Yates and anything associated with him. Mentzer coached Dorian; ergo, Pumpster hates him.

SUCKMYMUSCLE

Thanks, that explains Pumpster's mind-bogglingly deficient contest insight. That kid should NEVER judge any contest, ever!
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on September 04, 2006, 11:36:51 AM
Quote
Don't worry about Pumpster. He's a fanatic who hates Dorian Yates and anything associated with him. Mentzer coached Dorian; ergo, Pumpster hates him.
SUCKY's reknowned for faulty logic-one has nothing to do with the other, so that's an interesting jump in logic once again. ;D


Quote
Thanks, that explains Pumpster's mind-bogglingly deficient contest insight. That kid should NEVER judge any contest, ever!
Let's rely on "golden" the Mentzer guy he's not at all biased in his worshipping! hahahahaahahah
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 05, 2006, 07:36:49 PM
Pumpster's reknowned for faulty logic-one has nothing to do with the other, so that's an interesting jump in logic once again. ;D

Let's rely on "Pumpster" the Mentzer nuthater/closet fag - he's not at all biased in his worshipping!  ::) hahahahaahahah

Why do you always sabotage yourself kid? ;)

Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 06, 2006, 08:48:32 PM
Let's watch "golden showers" prove once again that he absolutely, positively must have the last word..only confirms that we have a Mentzer freak bereft of objectivity. Boring too, unless I help him dodder along as i've been doing.  :P

Haha, the only "golden showers" around here boy, are the ones you take off your boyfriend. The fact that you bring in all sorts of outside trash (Mentzer's theories, other BBers who were screwed) like a il' pussy homo only drives home further the fact that you've been majorly OWNED. Now bow down and worship at my feet; we aren't all laughing with you kid - we're chortling at you and yer bum brain.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: onlyme on September 07, 2006, 12:51:41 PM
Hey guys no fighting in here.  This is the only board on GetBig that doesn't have it.  So don't make me erase stuff. Can you believe I am saying this.  It's because the past is sacred and EVERYONE should respect the guys from the past.  They paved the roads for everyone else. 
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 07, 2006, 08:11:46 PM
Golden Showers just can't resist, has kneepads out and ready for more on Mentzer, who was always very good but never great.

Haha, stop fantasizing about other men like that...I know you're a hopeless queer but you're shameless! ;D
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: suckmymuscle on September 08, 2006, 09:59:24 PM
SUCKY's reknowned for faulty logic-one has nothing to do with the other, so that's an interesting jump in logic once again. ;D

  Yes, one hs nothing to do with the other. But not to you. You hate anyone who's ever been associated with Dorian, from Peter McGough to Mentzer. "Faulty logic"? How about you saying that Dorian only won the Olympia due to politics? This despite the fact that Dorian is both British and White. From a PR perspective, you can't go more wrong than "choosing" a White Ango-Saxon - from Britain, another country! - to represent your sport; it is far more politically correct to "choose" a Black national. So, there's you taking the cake for "faulty logic" once again. How about you claiming that McGough is biased in favor of Dorian, even though he said Ronnie's2001 ASC form was the best he's ever seen, and that he wrote a three page article criticizing Dorian's distended midsection from 1997? Once again, I'm no competition for you on the "faulty logic" category, Pumpster! ;)

Quote
Let's rely on "golden" the Mentzer guy he's not at all biased in his worshipping! hahahahaahahah

  Mentzer's 1980 physique was a hell of a lot better than Ronnie's in either 2003 or 2004: at least he had a flat stomach and clearly separated abdominals and serratus, and didn't look like a nine months pregnant woman. ;)

SUCKMYMUSCLE
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 09, 2006, 01:41:21 AM
Amen to that brother.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on September 09, 2006, 06:56:08 AM
Don't start with the race thing. If Dorian got any gifts it wasn't because he was white. Coleman got 2 gifts and Haney got one or two.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on September 09, 2006, 09:35:39 AM
Quote
"Faulty logic"? How about you saying that Dorian only won the Olympia due to politics? This despite the fact that Dorian is both British and White. From a PR perspective, you can't go more wrong than "choosing" a White Ango-Saxon - from Britain, another country! - to represent your sport; it is far more politically correct to "choose" a Black national.
SUCKY's cognitive difficulties embarassingly on display once again-I never said his fortune was entirely due to politics, dumbass.  Anyone with a brain bigger than Golden Shower the Mentzer ball washer or SUCKY can figure out that politics has played significant roles in contests INCLUDING the 1980 Olympia - in fact, ask Golden Shower about this SUCKY you stupid moron! In future I may have to tell him when it's ok to comment. ::)

Man the delusion just gets more and more intense-being black's an advantage? That even exceeds the way Golden perches proudly atop Mentzer's dick. haahahahahahaahahahahaha haahahah
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 09, 2006, 10:45:23 PM
SUCKY's cognitive difficulties embarassingly on display once again-I never said his fortune was entirely due to politics, dumbass.  Anyone with a brain bigger than Golden Shower the Mentzer ball washer or SUCKY can figure out that politics has played significant roles in contests INCLUDING the 1980 Olympia - in fact, ask Golden Shower about this SUCKY you stupid moron! In future I may have to tell him when it's ok to comment. ::)

Man the delusion just gets more and more intense-being black's an advantage? That even exceeds the way Golden perches proudly atop Mentzer's dick. haahahahahahaahahahahaha haahahah

Hey kiddo, welcome back. :) I thought ya died or something. :'(
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 09, 2006, 10:52:21 PM
SUCKY's cognitive difficulties embarassingly on display once again-I never said his fortune was entirely due to politics, dumbass.  Anyone with a brain bigger than Golden Shower the Mentzer ball washer or SUCKY can figure out that politics has played significant roles in contests INCLUDING the 1980 Olympia - in fact, ask Golden Shower about this SUCKY you stupid moron! In future I may have to tell him when it's ok to comment. ::)

Man the delusion just gets more and more intense-being black's an advantage? That even exceeds the way Golden perches proudly atop Mentzer's dick. haahahahahahaahahahahaha haahahah

LOL, M E L T D O WN. Hehe, think of all all the misguided, girly rage, fear and energy that went into that post! :o
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 09, 2006, 11:02:28 PM
Haha, now "Pumpster" you tiny turd, listen up boy. Like I said previously, stop fantasizing about other men like the lil' fag you are and get some smarts. Right now, you're at the level of a tard. You've been blown out of the water and been proven as a biased fraud/fake. You're not a BBer, you're just a frustrated teenage wannabe who just got rejected for the prom by erven the fattest gal in class, the Jumbo Dumbo. Now kindly get out of my garden and stop licking my dog's balls or he'll call the Animal Police (led by the one and only Vince G himself) on ya! Consider yerself warned ya fag! ;D 
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on September 10, 2006, 07:36:55 AM
I'm not the one rhapsodizing about a very good but over-hyped Mentzer. Feel free to get off those kneepads after your latest shower you fag.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: BEAST 8692 on September 10, 2006, 08:34:51 AM
what i find interesting re mentzer:

he was very unorthodox with his training contrasting the dogma of the time. Perhaps not quite as much as he later (post retirement) prescribed, but unorthodox at the time.

this included his nutrition.

I remember reading excerpts from his daily diary eg a cantaloup for breakfast and such. he'd have been lucky to get 50 grms of protein a day.

the guy was fearless, but he sure as hell backed it up on stage. he had alot of dense muscle and he was SHREDDED.

standing next to guys that were alot more excessive about training and eating he very much held his own in the muscle mass dept.

i know that mentzer was taking gear like everyone else but, hell, aren't ya supposed to take in more protein with gear???

very interesting. there should be more mentzers in the world. challenge everything. if it's written in stone, all the more reason to challenge it.

R.I.P the great Mike Mentzer



Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Bix on September 10, 2006, 08:49:03 AM
Supposedly it was the difference in training philisophies as well as personal dislikes. A little surprising if true-apparently Schwarzenegger got bent out of shape about Mentzer's training and how it discredited Arnold's approach, which seems more than a little small.

Personally it would be easy to dislike Schwarzenegger with the arrogance, BS and non-stop need for an ever-present side-kick to whisper negatives about others to. There is just the slightest  split-second's glimpse of Mentzer in Pumping Iron: being ignored while drinking a supplement at the Gold's Gym counter when Arnold comes in.
  Ya but just remember that Mentzer was a no=body back then.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Bix on September 10, 2006, 09:09:30 AM
Mentzer was mad because Arnold entered the contest at the very last minute. The rules stated that all competitors must register 3 weeks prior to the contest - this rule was obviously waived for Arnold. You see Conan was supposed to start filming in 1981, however that date was brought forward unexpectedly. The first scenes were to be shot in August 1980. In addition, Universal, the films distributor was going to use thise footage as a promo along with it's Christmas release of Flash Gordon. All of a sudden, Arnold had to get big, and fast. The best way to get big - and to get attention doing so - was to attempt the unthinkable: to make a comeback! You see Arnold was scheduled to arrive in Sydney as a TV Commentator only - so you can imagine everyone's surpise when he registered to compete at the very last minute. Mentzer was pissed.  Reg Park was also put in a precarious position as he was one of the judges and of course him and Arnold were very close. Paul Graham was the promoter of that event and him and Arnold were also very close - he is the big guy who pulls Arnold in and hugs him in the very beginning of the movie Pumping Iron. The argument between Arnold and Mike Mentzer was over the fact that Boyer Coe was instrumental in getting the IFBB rules changed for the 1980 Olympia so that instead of a winner being chosen from the best of two weight classes he would emerge from six all-comer finalists. Arnold was the only one who objected to this. Arnold wanted only two weight classes, that way there is only one man to beat. Mentzer got pissed and told Arnold that he was acting like a baby and Arnold said to Mike, " If your belly wasn't as big as your mouth, then maybe you would have a chance at this event". Mike then jumped up and got in Arnold's face and Arnold just sat cooly and laughed it off...Classic example of mental psyche-out which Arnold was famous for since it almost always worked. Needless to say, Mentzer was not a threat to Arnold's throne as Mike ended up third, behind Chris Dickerson. If anyone had a chance to beat Arnold it was Chris and not Mike.
You got the Pauls mixed up, that was Grant.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: JPM on September 10, 2006, 09:21:19 AM
I agree with Beast8692. Mentzers always looked more masculiine, dense and powerful than a lot of other guy's at that time, even with that mustache. Sort of like the Paul brothers were different in their look and approach to training. Nice to have someone who was unique in the BB'ing world rather than follow the same oh, same oh that most of them did back than (and even these days). Arnold is Arnold. Sergio is Serigo. And Mentzer is Mentzer. All with their own approach to what was  good and worked for them.

Onlyme: Maybe some of these old men who come here just to argue could be deleated to the trash can rather than taking up space and boring everyone else. Senseless at times. Aloha.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 11, 2006, 01:42:28 AM
I'm not the one rhapsodizing about a very good but over-hyped Mentzer. Feel free to get off those kneepads after your latest shower you fag.

LOL, rhapsodizing? You kids make me laugh so hard. I'm just calling it as it is sonny boy....what a sad lil' homo tard you are. Now get back to scrubbing the toilets and begging the house canines for somemore doggy nad action; some guests (maybe Roy Callender) will be coming tomorrow for a visit and the loo needs to be spotlessly clean. You've been owned so bad even your momma can feel your anus bleed that's why you're in the subservient position you're in now.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 11, 2006, 01:43:46 AM
what i find interesting re mentzer:

he was very unorthodox with his training contrasting the dogma of the time. Perhaps not quite as much as he later (post retirement) prescribed, but unorthodox at the time.

this included his nutrition.

I remember reading excerpts from his daily diary eg a cantaloup for breakfast and such. he'd have been lucky to get 50 grms of protein a day.

the guy was fearless, but he sure as hell backed it up on stage. he had alot of dense muscle and he was SHREDDED.

standing next to guys that were alot more excessive about training and eating he very much held his own in the muscle mass dept.

i know that mentzer was taking gear like everyone else but, hell, aren't ya supposed to take in more protein with gear???

very interesting. there should be more mentzers in the world. challenge everything. if it's written in stone, all the more reason to challenge it.

R.I.P the great Mike Mentzer





You can't take Mentzer's low-protein approach seriously due to the anabolics involved if you're a natural.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: BEAST 8692 on September 11, 2006, 06:51:03 AM
yep, that's my point. anabolics are SUPPOSED to help you assimilate and synthesize higher intakes of protein.

this is anabolics 101.

In actual fact, naturals need far less protein.

i honestly don't know the nutritional requirements of the contemporary drug assisted bodybuilder (has there actually been any non-weider influenced/funded research on this subject?)

we've all had too much weider bullshit forced down our throats for too many years, but mentzer had the courage to challenge the protocol which is probably his most significant achievement.

weider has committed the greatest fraud ever in the fitness industry. he has sold his bullshit philosophy (building a billion dollar industry) since the 40's and propped up his heavily juiced bodybuilders as proof of it's efficiency, when in fact the real truth lied in pharmacology.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Scimowser on September 11, 2006, 02:01:17 PM
Arnold had an ego problem because he believed he was better than everyone else (he generally was and still is lol). He wanted the weight classes to make sure he was guaranteed the title. Mike wanted to be in Arnolds position and thought he was the best. For better or worse, Arnold won the competition and Mike couldnt deal with that. Essentially it destroyed his career as a competitive bodybuilder
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 12, 2006, 01:29:20 AM
yep, that's my point. anabolics are SUPPOSED to help you assimilate and synthesize higher intakes of protein.

this is anabolics 101.

In actual fact, naturals need far less protein.

i honestly don't know the nutritional requirements of the contemporary drug assisted bodybuilder (has there actually been any non-weider influenced/funded research on this subject?)

we've all had too much weider bullshit forced down our throats for too many years, but mentzer had the courage to challenge the protocol which is probably his most significant achievement.

weider has committed the greatest fraud ever in the fitness industry. he has sold his bullshit philosophy (building a billion dollar industry) since the 40's and propped up his heavily juiced bodybuilders as proof of it's efficiency, when in fact the real truth lied in pharmacology.

Naturals don't require less protein per se, otherwise they wouldn't grow w/o the aid of gear. Not as much as Trevor Smith was taking but still a lot is needed as protein buids muscle. Carbs and fat have very potent anabolic properties as well; I could lecture on all this for hours but who would listen? Plus, though I'm a philantropist and Good Samaritan to the poor and needy, I most justifiably charge well-endowed professionals and top amateurs a nice fee for advanced secrets as well as you can't put no pricetag on quality muscle gains. Some people equate lack of growth as lack of protein; not true really, as your body needs to be able to absorb the aminos and everything else. People buy chicken and rice, and eat it anyhow but there is a science to food selection and meal timing, as well as cycling an variety. As far as anabolics, yes I know the chemicals help utilise the calories and protein far better but they are so anabolic that a genetic freak even on a deprived diet would make great gains, so long as some protein was being ingested, as was the case with Mentzer.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: cornebb on September 12, 2006, 04:52:34 AM
anyone have more pics from 80' olympia?
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: bicepsforyou on September 12, 2006, 11:40:51 AM
Good ?
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on September 13, 2006, 03:49:29 PM
Quote
For better or worse, Arnold won the competition and Mike couldnt deal with that. Essentially it destroyed his career as a competitive bodybuilder
Can't blame him for being upset, but after seeing Robinson denied more than once he should've been a little more realistic about the politics that are part of such a commercial enterprise as the IFBB and Weider. Of course 5th place seems absurd but if you don't win who cares anyway?

It's clear that he, like Schwarzenegger, had his own set of ego problems.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: gibberj2 on September 13, 2006, 04:23:04 PM
well if he got 5th he shouldn't be mad at arnold. he should be mad an places 2-4.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on September 13, 2006, 05:48:45 PM
Except that there was already long-term animus between them that produced tension and a confrontation at the contest, plus the impression that it was fixed with the late entry of Schwarzenegger.

Can't blame Mentzer at all for disliking Schwarzenegger who was clearly both annoying and surrounded by a coterie of Gold's yes-men. Too bad he couldn't see that this Arnold nonsense was a one-year thing, which left the field wide-open in subsequent years. With a little patience he'd have been rewarded by sticking around.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 14, 2006, 01:47:31 AM
Except that there was already long-term animus between them that produced tension and a confrontation at the contest, plus the impression that it was fixed with the late entry of Schwarzenegger.

Can't blame Mentzer at all for disliking Schwarzenegger who was clearly both annoying and surrounded by a coterie of Gold's yes-men. Too bad he couldn't see that this Arnold nonsense was a one-year thing, which left the field wide-open in subsequent years. With a little patience he'd have been rewarded by sticking around.

Perhaps he would have been rewarded but it all depends. Dickerson got his due but guys like Danny P justifiably got tired of the bs and packed it up too.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: Jr. Yates on September 14, 2006, 12:21:37 PM
Perhaps he would have been rewarded but it all depends. Dickerson got his due but guys like Danny P justifiably got tired of the bs and packed it up too.
which was sad don't blame him though. The giant killer was great to see. us shorter guys love the shorter guys.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: TheGoldenPrince on September 15, 2006, 01:13:30 AM
which was sad don't blame him though. The giant killer was great to see. us shorter guys love the shorter guys.

Padilla was awesome; I'd love to see him make a comeback all-natural to try and dethrone Chick at the Masters Pro World next year!
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: pumpster on September 15, 2006, 12:39:39 PM
Weider was savvy but for whatever reason when it comes to the Olympia the thought process was warped. He let most of his best BBs leave in the early 80s where if he'd let them win once in a while BB would have been more interesting with good rivalries between them until the mid-80s-Robinson, Padilla, Szkalak, Mentzer, Fox.
Title: Re: what was the arnold/mentzer confrontation about at the 80 olympia?
Post by: kimo on August 28, 2007, 10:56:39 AM
in bodybuiding all stars book which mike prefaced he says many flattering things regarding arnold he simply disaggrred on his training methods and arnold took it personal . aking like arnold want to be worshipped and not criticised but mentzer or not arnold would probably have won in 1980.