I don't think any of us know what we are doing!!!
Dude, I've competed six times and I still have no fucking clue what I'm doing. I have yet to find a winning formula, what worked for one show didn't work for another.
This is part of the reason why I've decided to try and go back to my old way of doing things, HIGH protein baby!!!
To give you an idea, I just finished competing last week at a weight of 160. Today I weigh 180 (yeah I binged so much this past week LOL), I officially start my off-season diet and traning tomorrow, and the plan is as follows, I will start with 3000 calories split with a 40% protein, 40% carbs, 20% fat. (Basically 300 g protein, 300 g carbs, 65 g fat), I will do this with the hopes of adding 1-2 lbs a week, if I reach a stand still I will add another 15% to the calories with the samel 40-40-20 split. So I imagine my protein can very well get up to 400 g in a couple of months. This is MUCH higher than what I did last off-season (and I had a fairly good off-season last year).
If you tell this to Lanye Norton (which I have before) he will tell you that this is stupid and way too high!!! If you tell this to Jrod (He will say this a good amount).
There is more than one way to skin a cat, there is more than one way to get big, Arnold got big on a 40-40-20 split with high protein and he lowered his carbs as he went into a show. Talk to other bodybuilders today they lower their protein going into a show and keep the carbs high.
I've been stressing about this so much the last few weeks, and finally just said fuck it, I'm gonna do what I think works for me!!! Maybe another way would work too, but I'm too scared to try it out, I'm happy like this, it keeps me sane, and I'm pretty sure it works!!!