So, garebar, do you think it was appropriate for Obama to say Islam has shaped the U.S. and we have a deep admiration for the Islamic faith? We means who?
I think even most hardcore liberals would disagree with having admiration for the Islamic faith. It is a religion which has been mostly resistant to change and still believes in sharia law. Look it up if you are not familiar with sharia law, its shocking.
I don't think it was so inappropriate considering we will need the help of Islamic nations in order to combat radical Islam. You would be hard pressed to find assistance from, say Pakistan, if you declared an all out war against Islam.
It is important to note that American Muslims have participated in the war on terror. Let us not dissolve ourselves into blaming that faith for everything, lest we become Hitleresque in our quest to defend ourselves. Fact is, a large percentage of this world is Islamic, like it or not.
In all fairness, however, I don't see how that faith has shaped us to any discernable degree, except in the fact that we are tolerant of all faiths (with the unfair exception of polygamists).
I understand Sharia law and also know that many Muslim nations do not want it themselves, but have it thrust upon them by an oligarchy (see the Taliban for details).
I appreciate how you phrased your question as well. You did it respectfully, which is a rarity on these boards.