Yeah i think you're alright these days too, but we did have some nice battles 
As far as the topic, Alex will be a big guy dieted down....I've seen him in person and he's a thick guy. You can't tell how big someone is from pics, guys that are lean and small look more impressive in photos.
I'm working on being BOTH these days...in the mid 240's and still thick, but much trimmer around the waist and much more defined all the way around.
lol for sure :p... the "I'm in love/can't dance" thread had imo the most genius forum battles in a long time

.
And alex has some serious muscle... if he "even" diets to 10% bf he would seem like he's 8% because his muscles are allready big enough to tighten the skin against it at that level, there's no questin about that.