Prove it: Court rules states can require ID to vote
Election commission can’t stop voter ID lawsA U.S. District Court judge ruled Wednesday that
Arizona and Kansas can require anyone registering to vote to prove their citizenship and the federal Election Assistance Commission cannot block them.
The ruling is a boost for states’ rights and marks a
setback for President Obama and other liberals who fought stiffer voter ID checks with an argument that they reduce voter turnout.
In his ruling, Judge Eric F. Melgren said the
EAC, which Congress created after the 2000 Florida voting fiasco, must accede to states’ requests for people to provide proof of citizenship when they register to vote.
The judge said the Constitution gives states the power to determine voter qualifications, and
if states want to insist on proof of citizenship, the election commission cannot overrule them.
Kansas and Arizona enacted requirements that voters prove their citizenship when they register. State registration forms were changed to add the requirement.
But the federal government, which also distributes voter registration forms in states under the 1993 National Voter Registration Act, or motor-voter law, refused to add the requirement.
Arizona then said it would refuse to process federal forms and ended up in court. Last year, in a case known as Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona, the Supreme Court ruled that Arizona couldn’t reject the federal forms.
But the Supreme Court ruling also hinted that if states asked the EAC to include proof of citizenship on forms distributed within their borders, the commission couldn’t refuse.
Arizona and Kansas requested that the EAC change the forms distributed in those states, but the commission refused.
Judge Melgren said he
saw clear signs in last year’s Supreme Court ruling that the justices intended for the EAC to follow the wishes of the states.
On one hand, the ITCA decision acknowledges the broad scope of Congress‘ power under the Elections Clause, which includes the authority of the NVRA to preempt state law regarding voter registration,” the judge wrote. “
But the ITCA opinion also emphasizes the states’ exclusive constitutional authority to set voter qualifications — which Congress may not preempt — and appears to tie that authority with the power of the states to enforce their qualifications.”
Arizona Secretary of State Ken Bennett said the ruling will help clean up voter rolls.
About 2,000 people have submitted federal forms in the state but haven’t proved their citizenship, he said.
Read more:
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2014/mar/19/judge-states-can-demand-proof-citizenship-voters/?page=2#ixzz2wVOoyw55 Follow us: @washtimes on Twitter
