New Judging Idea

[muscularny]

I say that a day before the show the judges are shown 15 photos of all those competing. The photos should have the real physiques of the bodybuilders however the heads should be photoshopped this way it would be hard for them to tell who is who, I am curious how they will vote when they cannot know who the body belongs too. Their skin color should also be adjust to match each other.

If the IFBB had any real money to spend they can do this today with video as well.

What ya guys think? I would love to know how these judges would vote if they really had no clue who they are judging.

[OB1]

I say that a day before the show the judges are shown 15 photos of all those competing. The photos should have the real physiques of the bodybuilders however the heads should be photoshopped this way it would be hard for them to tell who is who, I am curious how they will vote when they cannot know who the body belongs too. Their skin color should also be adjust to match each other.

If the IFBB had any real money to spend they can do this today with video as well.

What ya guys think? I would love to know how these judges would vote if they really had no clue who they are judging.

Basically a good idea but it's not about fairness in the IFBB.

[che]

Most retarded idea ever

[Tarantula157]

I say that a day before the show the judges are shown 15 photos of all those competing. The photos should have the real physiques of the bodybuilders however the heads should be photoshopped this way it would be hard for them to tell who is who, I am curious how they will vote when they cannot know who the body belongs too. Their skin color should also be adjust to match each other.

If the IFBB had any real money to spend they can do this today with video as well.

What ya guys think? I would love to know how these judges would vote if they really had no clue who they are judging.

The judges could recognize the bodybuilders by the unique shape of their muscles.

[tommywishbone]

Most retarded idea ever

   That's a bold statement my friend. Well, it's at least in the top-5 Most Retarded Ideas Ever.

[Hulkotron]

I say that a day before the show the judges are shown 15 photos of all those competing. The photos should have the real physiques of the bodybuilders however the heads should be photoshopped this way it would be hard for them to tell who is who, I am curious how they will vote when they cannot know who the body belongs too. Their skin color should also be adjust to match each other.

If the IFBB had any real money to spend they can do this today with video as well.

What ya guys think? I would love to know how these judges would vote if they really had no clue who they are judging.

They should all compete in masks a la Kai Greene.

[V Man]

Funny, I was thinking what they should do, is have an artists rendition of what the ultimate physique should look like in all the poses....absolute perfection with no flaws. Each competitor is compared to this ideal, and the one that matches closest is the winner.

[OB1]

They should drain the oil of each competitors and put it in several buckets. One for each.
The most amount of oil wins.

[TuHolmes]

They should drain the oil of each competitors and put it in several buckets. One for each.
The most amount of oil wins.

Do they put it in barrels and try to sell it on the stock market?

[Parker]

Remove the judges and replace them with average ordinary women. Give them the IFBB standards. Let them study it for a month. Then let them pick the best physique based upon what they find attractive and adhere to the standards the best.

There will be no guts, no roundy-round faces and die-a-beetus necks. No too big for height and body type, and no stupid faces being made.

[Azure]

Funny, I was thinking what they should do, is have an artists rendition of what the ultimate physique should look like in all the poses....absolute perfection with no flaws. Each competitor is compared to this ideal, and the one that matches closest is the winner.

That's what I think. Phil was nearly perfect after prejudging and he looked bad. There needs to be an ideal so they can say you were scored this way bc you didn't meet this specific criteria and then be able to say what it is

but then the favorites wouldn't always win. For some reason they tend to do better with this with the women

I look at wpd and think Juliana is exactly what women's physique should look like. I look at Latorya, Candice Lewis or even Nicole and think that's figure

[OB1]

Do they put it in barrels and try to sell it on the stock market?

I hope so.

[Parker]

I look at Latorya, Candice Lewis or even Nicole and think that's...

what I want in my life 

[Azure]

Remove the judges and replace them with average ordinary women. Give them the IFBB standards. Let them study it for a month. Then let them pick the best physique based upon what they find attractive and adhere to the standards the best.

There will be no guts, no roundy-round faces and die-a-beetus necks. No too big for height and body type, and no stupid faces being made.

Parker I said this yeaaaars ago. Posing quality would also go up and these guys would really put forth an effort into it if they knew showmanship and entertainment would be Part of the score

Roelly got screwed!

[Parker]

Parker I said this yeaaaars ago. Posing quality would also go up and these guys would really put forth an effort into it if they knew showmanship and entertainment would be Part of the score

Roelly got screwed!

Yep. If you look at the comments that are made about women's bodybuilding, most of the comments are made based upon attractiveness. And most men, outside of schmoes who have certain "issues", view women bodybuilders as not that attractive. Sure, you get the few female bodybuilders who are (Lenda Murray, Melissa Detwiller, Debbie Masino, etc), but the majority aren't. So, following that view from men, why aren't women allowed to be the judges of men based upon the same views? I guarantee this would help the public perception of men's bodybuilding tenfold, especially in today's society where a lot of marketing goes to what women like and want.

[Sherief Shalaby]

I say that a day before the show the judges are shown 15 photos of all those competing. The photos should have the real physiques of the bodybuilders however the heads should be photoshopped this way it would be hard for them to tell who is who, I am curious how they will vote when they cannot know who the body belongs too. Their skin color should also be adjust to match each other.

If the IFBB had any real money to spend they can do this today with video as well.

What ya guys think? I would love to know how these judges would vote if they really had no clue who they are judging.

i agree with you so they cant guess who is this guy for example