Okay, I'll jump in on this. Too tall, yes there is such a thing...but too muscular?
No freaking way! I'm dating a guy right now who is an IFBB Pro, and at 375 in off season (6'1") and 320 on stage is definitely one of the bigger freaks. I say more power to them, get as huge as you want! I tip the scales at 165 at 10% (yes I have a 6-pack) and I'm 5'5" tall. I'm a freak of nature myself. Don't start on the "steroids" thing either. I have tested clean in all my bodybuilding and powerlifting events. So if you're thinking to discredit me in that way, prove it, otherwise keep your opinions to yourself. I think Jay, Ronnie, Gunter are ALL major studmuffin status.