so, same amount of muscle on both guys, but short guy is better. see, that's why weight clsases makes no sense.
First, were dealing with a hypothetical...we are assuming at best.
Second, weight classes make all the sense in the world as it keeps the playing field level, so you dont have a guy that is 5'3/ 230 and a guy thats 6'0/ 270 in which case....the bigger man almost always wins...and the very reasoning we instilled the 202 class
In your senario....a guy 5'11 at 200 is probably underdeveloped, which is why I said the shorter guy would win...with few exceptions...99% of the 202 guys are about the same height/ structure