I honestly can't understand how Branch Warren is being compared with the top guys. His shape isn't aesthetic at all. Wolf or Rockel should both be in the top 5 and Warren out of the top 6.
If the judges think like many do here on Getbig then that is a pity because physique judging is all over the place. Give the trophy to the guy who looks the best overall. Size, shape, proportions, condition, and overall aesthetics. If you do that then clearly Dexter Jackson is the best and perhaps Phil Heath second.