it really depends what your GOAL is.
If the goal is to nail 50 girls this year, then yes, call her back and go all out on date 2, and get that.
If the goal is to find a girlfriend/wifey material, then find out the story on the hand tattoo... that stands out to me as "what were you thinking?" - Examine the thinking process that puts an amateur, hand drawn tat in such a visible place. You don't put that there if you want to be a doctor/lawyer... you do it while piss drunk at 19 years old with a bunch of 30-something dudes. visible amateur ink is a warning sign, IMO.