From the front and sides jay would win...from the back heath SHOULD win...overall goes to Jay 09...that version of Jay is the best outside of the 01 Olympia.
I think 09 was better than 01. In 01 he was shredded, but was smaller than in 09 and had noticeable disparity between his quads. In 09 he was huge, ripped and everything was balanced.
Here are some comparisons between 2001 and 2009:

