Matt is puny 
His 5’8 frame is smaller than girls these days, he def fits in with modern bbers lol
Don't forget, in 2016, Matt threw his hat into the local open heavyweight "Motors & Muscles" contest, on its 10th anniversary.
The average competitor weight was 245-lb.
Matt was 170-lb, and placed last.
He was impressed by not getting zero in any event, and made the front page of the local sports section.
There were pretty heavy lifts in that contest...950-lb tire flip, 8,900-lb Monster Truck pull, etc.
The perspective here being...the 175-lb CAASA Nationals was lighter...
Thing i like about now having a weight class [since 2016] is that guys at 175-lb can only get so strong... meanwhile, WSM today is so heavy, it almost pains me to watch it.
Prime-Matt could be on point with a 315/405/495 total [strong by normal people standards...not by WSM or Getbig standards], and literally not even BUDGE any implement.
Blows my mind.
Mateusz set the world circus dumbbell record last year with a 330-lb dumbbell...at age 25!!!
I can't even fathom how that's possible.
Oh...and Matt did all that at a mere 5'8.5". (parsh included)
Everything else you said about Matt is bang on though.
Would love to see Matt get back to his best shape...or even 355/435/525...but at his age, without gear...I wouldn't bet on it to be possible.
Also, you have to fear for your joints just watching contests these days.
Tommy's recent squat video was inspiring though.