I'll ignore the other "Fucktards" and answer your question. In shape is what the muscle mass really is. Shes about 18% which is low for a woman. Granted she's a nice looking woman, but on the competitive stage, she would not be taking home a trophy. I don't expect most men to find me attractive at 160lbs and 7% bodyfat for shows. It takes a man that is really comfortable with himself to accept that as sexy.
So I see as "in shape" to be more muscle, less fat, and a pretty face...
Well, i thought we were talking about in general, not the competitive stage.
I do not believe anyone here has stated that they thought Jessie Biel would do well on the competitive fitness stages of today.
Attraction in general, she would do well though.
Common man would say she is fit comparing with the reg couch-potatoes, not the bb pros!