Author Topic: Settlement to be argued in big pet food case  (Read 1250 times)

~weed~

  • Guest
Settlement to be argued in big pet food case
« on: October 14, 2008, 04:58:52 PM »
Settlement to be argued in big pet food case

By GEOFF MULVIHILL –

MOUNT LAUREL, N.J. (AP) — Thousands of pet owners whose dogs and cats died last year after eating contaminated pet food traced to China could be close to a $32 million settlement.

A federal judge in Camden was to hear oral arguments on the final proposal Tuesday. The court also will consider any filed objections.

The settlement allows pet owners to apply for expenses associated with deaths and illnesses, including the costs of veterinarians, time missed from work to care for sick animals, replacement pets, burial expenses and even property damaged because animals got sick.

In addition to the $8 million they had already agreed to pay owners of sickened pets, the pet food companies would put up $24 million for the settlement.

The case began in March 2007, when companies that make or sell pet food — including Menu Foods Income Fund, which makes dog and cat food under about 90 brand names from its base in Streetsville, Ontario — agreed to settle lawsuits with pet owners.

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration later found that the food contained melamine, a chemical used to make plastics. The chemical was traced to contaminated wheat gluten imported from China.

In April, lawyers for representing plaintiffs and dozens of companies announced they had struck a deal for pet owners in the United States and Canada.

Under the terms, even those who did not keep any receipts for either the pet food or the costs of the pets' illness and death could get up to $900 per animal.

If any money is left after all plaintiffs are paid, it would go to animal-welfare charities.

But the agreement did not include any money for the humans' pain and suffering from injuries to their pets. That has upset some pet owners.

One, Donna Elliott, of Fries, Va., for instance, sent U.S. District Judge Noel Hillman a picture of her late boxer, Abby.

"How do you answer the statement on the claim form, what was the value of your pet?" she asked. "My companion was everything in the world to me."

In one court filing, the parties that struck the settlement explained: "This settlement does not pretend to do what it cannot — which is to make people fully whole for their incomprehensible losses," the filing said. "The settlement is, however, a reflection of strenuous efforts to secure the maximum economic relief available."

As of Sept. 30, more than 9,500 people in the United States and Canada had made claims, while just over 100 people had preserved their rights to sue separately. Relatively few — 28 — had filed objections to the settlement.
On the Net:

    * Claim information: http://www.petfoodsettlement.com


http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5jWoj-xA1xcoCq8oQAb5janun5ZpQD93Q65380

Vet

  • Getbig IV
  • ****
  • Posts: 1679
  • Immortal
Re: Settlement to be argued in big pet food case
« Reply #1 on: October 17, 2008, 02:04:11 AM »
Call me a fatalist, but I think the recent problems with childrens milk linked to melamine in China with what was it, something like 50 thousand children becoming ill speaks volumes for the "quality" of what is coming from that country. 

~weed~

  • Guest
Re: Settlement to be argued in big pet food case
« Reply #2 on: October 21, 2008, 03:11:55 AM »
I think these raccoon dogs were lucky to die this way rather than the barbaric way those assholes kill them for their fur.  (Which gets mislabeled alot for US sale, absolutely disgusting!!!!)   >:(


1,500 Chinese raccoon dogs die from tainted feed

By GILLIAN WONG, Associated Press Writer Gillian Wong, Associated Press Writer Mon Oct 20, 4:26 pm ET

BEIJING – Some 1,500 dogs bred for their raccoon-like fur have died after eating feed tainted with melamine, a veterinarian said Monday, raising questions about how widespread the industrial chemical is in China's food chain.

The revelation comes amid a crisis over dairy products tainted with melamine that has caused kidney stones in tens of thousands of Chinese children and has been linked to the deaths of four infants.

The raccoon dogs — a breed native to east Asia whose fur is used to trim coats and other clothing — died of kidney failure after eating the tainted feed, said Zhang Wenkui, a veterinary professor at Shenyang Agriculture University.

"First, we found melamine in the dogs' feed, and second, I found that 25 percent of the stones in the dogs' kidneys were made up of melamine," said Zhang, who performed a necropsy — an animal autopsy — on about a dozen dogs.

Zhang declined to say when the animals died, but a report Monday in the Southern Metropolis Daily said the deaths occurred over the past two months.

The animal deaths were a reminder of last year's uproar over a Chinese-made pet food ingredient containing melamine that was linked to the deaths of dozens of dogs and cats in the United States and touched off a massive pet food recall.

It was not immediately clear how the chemical entered the raccoon dog feed. But in the tainted milk scandal and last year's pet food recall, melamine was believed to have been added to artificially boost nitrogen levels, making products seem higher in protein when tested.

At the time, China's product safety authorities revoked the business licenses of questionable firms, announced tougher guidelines and increased inspections. But the countless small, illegally operating manufacturers found throughout the country make monitoring difficult.

"It's still happening because it's enormously profitable. It's much cheaper to put melamine in as a nitrogen source than to put a real source in," said Marion Nestle, a professor of nutrition, food studies and public health at New York University who wrote a book about the tainted pet food scandal.

"You're going to have this kind of thing until you have a food safety system that's adequate to oversee what's going on or provide enough of a deterrent that people doing this think there's too much of a chance they're going to get caught," she said.

Bonnie Glaser, a senior associate with the Freeman Chair in China Studies at the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies, agreed.

"This is a problem throughout China where you have incentives that exist to produce things in a cheaper way to make greater profits, and people circumvent the regulations," she said. "The (central government) is trying to eliminate this, but the problem is that for the few factories you close down, there's another factory that pops up."

Raccoon dogs are not the only animals in China that have fallen victim to melamine-tainted products — a lion cub and two baby orangutans developed kidney stones last month at a zoo near Shanghai.

Hospital officials said the three baby animals had been nursed for more than a year with milk powder made by the Sanlu Group Co., which is at the center of the tainted milk crisis.

Melamine has been found in a wide range of Chinese-made dairy products over the past few months. The government is still trying to win back consumer confidence after tainted products turned up on store shelves around the world.

When ingested by humans, melamine — which is used in plastics and fertilizers — can cause kidney stones as the body tries to eliminate it, and in extreme cases can lead to kidney failure. Babies are particularly vulnerable.

Zhang said the company that produces the animal feed is in talks with breeders in Xishan, the village in Liaoning province where the dogs died, about providing compensation and has pressured them not to talk to the media.

Zhang did not give the company's name but the newspaper report said the feed was produced by Harbin Hualong Feed Co. The company refused to comment Monday, saying officials were unavailable because they were in a meeting.

An official surnamed Liu at the Liaoning provincial animal feed and medicine inspection center said the facility tested one sample of animal feed from Xishan and found it contained about 500 parts per million of melamine.

China's Health Ministry recently capped the amount of melamine permissible in milk and foods containing dairy products to 2.5 parts per million.

Liu said the center was assisting the Ministry of Agriculture in a nationwide inspection of animal feed but would not give any other details.

The ministry did not respond to a list of faxed questions. Telephone calls to the agricultural department of the Ciyutuo county government, which oversees Xishan, rang unanswered.