It is one thing to possess a great physique and quite another to display one. Kai is a bit of both.
To be perfect he needs longer muscle bellies in arms and calves. That being said, look at his development in those areas. Outstanding.
I agree that Freeman has an excellent physique. However, photos tell only part of the story and during the judging the competitors move a lot and pose this way and that. Kai literally steals the show during the transitions. When they all hit poses Kai doesn't dominate like you think he might. Critics are correct that Freeman does 'win' some of the poses and has a small waist and broad shoulders. I tell you the transitions while posing during the judging is absolutely crucial.
At the Australian Pro the judges took their time and even had the top three guys change positions and pose again. So they didn't rush anything.
The fact that they changed positions means it was very close. If two are brought out that means they are having trouble separating them. This happened with Freeman and Samuel.