GetBig has so many gays that narrowing the list to 5 just isn't possible or fair, LOL!
What are the criteria, even?!
Excluding "Gay marriage" threads on the politics board I'd say most of the posters/members, who happen to be gay, are pretty cool and don't excessively post about gay stuff. In most cases you'd never know, not that anyone cares.
GetBig's top 5 attention whores, who happen to be gay, is probably a more fair way to ask. Even then there are so many that narrowing the list down to any number less than 20 seems impossible.