I'm really not trying to stir up the pot, I went on their site with an open mind (albeit one of a hobby musician) I've studied theory and scales for a good 5 years so I think I am a pretty decent judge of natural talent and ability since I play mostly very technical guitar stuff (ie. Dream Theater, Symphony X)
but these guys honestly suck, they just don't have it.. the singer is horrendous, the instrument are out of tune and sometimes out of pitch and time (between the bass and drums) it's just really poorly done, I was playing songs better then this crap in grade 8 for talent show..
Jade if you can't hear how bad it really is, you're either head over heels in love or tone deaf, either way..play it to some of your friends (friends that can be critical and honest with you) and you'll see what we're all talking about.