Seriously?? Vic is superior to Mel IMO even if Mel is in shape.
2005 (was it?) Melvin was off the chain, as was his 1999 USA shape...Melvin lacks quad sweep, chest, bigger delts and lower back...if you can view him as a poor man's Flex and see him with those improvements, Vic has no chance...but, Vic like Mel almost never comes in excellent shape, except for his NOC win and in 2007.