No, I idn't think you were slaming him,but in bodybuilding anyone that competes can tell you that come contest everybody thinks you are haevier and when your off-season everyone thinks you are light. example when i am chubby off season at 250 people think I am 240, but when I am 2 weeks out everyone thinks I am 250 because I am hard (no homo) so your theory that he is light cause he is mushy, well, the oppisite is true if he was hard with abs I would think he is only 280....muscle weighs more then fat but it also gives the illusion that it takes more volumn, not saying your fat but this misconception is popular thinking among fat people from what I notice.
I hear ya. And for the record, I began my weight-training life as a bodybuilder. Competed three times. For my last go on the posing dais, I weighed an
ultra-ripped 202 (overdid it and should have been around 210-215). In clothes I looked like a bean pole ... on stage I looked more like 225. In the offeason I weighed (this is mid-'90s) 260-ish and looked gigantic in clothes but less "muscleman" when stripped off.
Now I weigh, as I say, over 290, and because I am more dense and thick 15 years later (and hugely more strong), I actually weigh a lot more but do not appear
all that much bigger than when I was 260. Weird, I know.
Strange sport.