In a 10 year period, he led the AL in games, home runs, RBI, runs, slugging, total bases..8 100 RBI seasons and only 9 guys have higher carreer HR+Batting average. People discredit the guy for playing at Fenway, and he isn't a slam dunk pick, but I don't think he cheapened the Hall. I guess it comes down to opinion. Some people think that it should be reserved for the cream of the crop..I have no problem with guys like Rice, Gossage, Perez going in.