Really? I think Kuclo is in line and has the better overall physique plus his likability, work ethic, fire fighter guy, image... Which bbers are also judged outside the stage plus he's "paying his dues" 
Justin is young and doing the same. Kuclo won his card in 2011 and did two shows plus the Olympia in the two years following. He placed 3rd (NY Pro) and 1st (some other show). Justin got his in 2012, and placed 5th and 1st (2014 Europa) in his next two shows. He's doing the Olympia this year. So even there.
Justin could be a better poser, but I think has more consistent conditioning, and considering how young his career is...
Kuclo is bigger, but also WAY further along in his career than J. Give J a couple of years. Steve still won't have won the O, and Justin will have caught up.






That said, I only swoon over one of the two, and it's the one with the fire hose.