LOL!
That makeup is a work of art. But given that is Charlize under there, wouldn't her role in Monster be "beautiful women in movies who you found revolting"?

Theron and Ashley Judd seem to have a thing about doing films where they get beat to a pulp and/or don't gussy up. Leave that shit to Eric Stoltz, I say (although I just admit, Monster was very good; Charlize is an amazing actress).
I thought of another lass that fits your criteria: Chloe Sevigny in Boys Don't Cry. I would say Brown Bunny, but I was told it was such a turd that the sewer threw it back up, so I never saw it.