Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: hipolito mejia on July 13, 2007, 11:32:35 AM
-
Lou at his prime,Zane at his best, who will win???
-
Zane, but Lou would sue him.
-
Apples and Oranges
-
Lou at his prime,Zane at his best, who will win???
Apples to oranges. Can't compare.
-
Lou in the nineties.
-
This thread is worthless without pictures. Even with pictures it's still shit
-
you cant compare those 2, exactly apples and oranges. But it would have made a sweet olympia in 77 if lou had such with it.
-
btw, Lou was planning to enter the 1995 master O. around 340 pounds !!!!
but ended up retiring thanks to Carla (his wife)
He was 325 at the 93 mr.O and took 10th
At the 94' masters he was around 295 or so trying to look "ironAge" and took the runner up.
here's a clip of lou in 1995 weighting around 335 pounds, enjoy If u haven't seen it.
-
Zane, but Lou would sue him.
haha, brilliant response.
-
you cant compare those 2, exactly apples and oranges. But it would have made a sweet olympia in 77 if lou had such with it.
Apples and oranges my ass!!!
In Mr.O 1974 Columbu (apple) beated Zane (orange)
and one of the biggest battles in Mr.O history : Lee vs. Lee!! Haney and Labrada...apples and oranges as well
but still good bb, and we know the results there too.
So don't get me no bannana,apples,oranges crap
-
Apples and oranges my ass!!!
In Mr.O 1974 Columbu (apple) beated Zane (orange)
and one of the biggest battles in Mr.O history : Lee vs. Lee!! Haney and Labrada...apples and oranges as well
but still good bb, and we know the results there too.
So don't get me no bannana,apples,oranges crap
Gaspari should have beaten Haney in 1987, regardless of Haney's mass and superior structure. Rich was 222 at 5'8 and 1/2 and as dry as can be. Apples and oranges.
-
Apples and oranges my ass!!!
In Mr.O 1974 Columbu (apple) beated Zane (orange)
and one of the biggest battles in Mr.O history : Lee vs. Lee!! Haney and Labrada...apples and oranges as well
but still good bb, and we know the results there too.
So don't get me no bannana,apples,oranges crap
Sorry what about pineapples and avacados
-
Apples and oranges my ass!!!
In Mr.O 1974 Columbu (apple) beated Zane (orange)
and one of the biggest battles in Mr.O history : Lee vs. Lee!! Haney and Labrada...apples and oranges as well
but still good bb, and we know the results there too.
So don't get me no bannana,apples,oranges crap
Don't get excited, you'll give yourself a stroke.
Ferrigno was a mass monster for his time. Zane was a all asthetics and definition. Thats like comparing Amhed Haidar to Ronnie or Jay.
-
Sorry what about pineapples and avacados
LOL... I know,
but there can only be one winner on stage..... even if one is coconut,Peach, guava or cherry.
-
Don't get excited, you'll give yourself a stroke.
Ferrigno was a mass monster for his time. Zane was a all asthetics and definition. Thats like comparing Amhed Haidar to Ronnie or Jay.
but with Haidar,Ronnie and Jay we know the results everytime they step on stage,
So in your humble opinion..........
Between Zane and Ferrigno,
Who would win??
Thank you SOOOOO much.
-
haha, brilliant response.
No joke. That's how it would go down.
:D
LOL... I know,
but there can only be one winner on stage..... even if one is coconut,Peach, guava or cherry.
Fruit
-
According to 90% here this should be apples and oranges too?
why bother right?
sorry for poor quality (37 years old pic)!!!
(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/gallery/musclegallery11/ar309.jpg)
-
Wow
Serge looks fully owned there. Let me guess, its just the "angle". ;)
-
It always is. It always is...
Wow
Serge looks fully owned there. Let me guess, its just the "angle". ;)
-
It always is. It always is...
By angle does he mean Sergio's layer of fat that he always sported ??? ???
He def got a few gifts in his day especially after he left the I.F.B.B. in the 70's.
-
IF i had to pick o would take big louie
-
Sergios best conditioning was training with Arthur Jones he never surpassed his 72MrO conditioning had he stayed with Jones the history books might have had another slant.
-
but with Haidar,Ronnie and Jay we know the results everytime they step on stage,
So in your humble opinion..........
Between Zane and Ferrigno,
Who would win??
Thank you SOOOOO much.
Judging by today's criteria, Ferrigno. Thats easy.
-
Judging by today's criteria, Ferrigno. Thats easy.
Sad to say, Lou was never ripped during that time(70s) and fat as shit during contest.
-
Lou at his prime,Zane at his best, who will win???
Gimme 20 bucks opps no, price increase 50 bucks and I'll tell ya. -Louie.
-
Wow
Serge looks fully owned there. Let me guess, its just the "angle". ;)
Exactly! :D
-
Two different physiques, but in their best respective condition, I'd have to say Lou. He was just as good condition wise, but weighed about twice as much as Zane.
-
Two different physiques, but in their best respective condition, I'd have to say Lou. He was just as good condition wise, but weighed about twice as much as Zane.
No way Lou could be as ripped as THe CHEMIST during that era.
-
We are talking when they were in their best condition, Lou wasn't great in the 70's. But at his prime he is > than Zane at his prime.
-
We are talking when they were in their best condition, Lou wasn't great in the 70's. But at his prime he is > than Zane at his prime.
Overall, you are still talking about two different physiques. You cannot compare the two of them. This is EXACTLY why the Olympia should go back to two weight classes, but that's for another thread.
-
This is EXACTLY why the Olympia should go back to two weight classes
That would be VERY interesting if they incorporated that nowadays. I've always liked that route.
What was the year they did way with that? I know it was before 1980 because Arnold wanted it back.
-
That would be VERY interesting if they incorporated that nowadays. I've always liked that route.
What was the year they did way with that? I know it was before 1980 because Arnold wanted it back.
1974 to 1979. All the guys backstage at the 80 voted to remove it, Arnold was the only holdout until Weider stepped in.
-
You can compare the physiques. The both had relatively the same peak conditioning = Even, Symetry = Zane, Mass = Lou. Lou had awe factor which is something Zane is his prime lacked. He could wow people with his conditioning, but Lou could just stand their fully clothed and gather a crowd (then charge everyone for pics 8)).
-
Here is some pics you bastards.
(http://digilander.libero.it/mikementzer/Zane11.jpg)(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/mro/zane/fz59.jpg)
(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/mro/zane/fz112.jpg)(http://digilander.libero.it/mrolympia2/zf42.jpg)'
(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/mro/zane/zf56.jpg)(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/mro/zane/fz62.jpg)
-
This will cost me a cool $120
(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/mro/ferrigno/lf139.jpg)(http://digilander.libero.it/louferrign/fer44.jpg)
(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/mro/ferrigno/lf165.jpg)(http://www.schwarzenegger.it/mro/ferrigno/lf137.jpg)
(http://digilander.libero.it/louferrign/fer5.jpg)(http://digilander.libero.it/louferrign/lf94.jpg)
-
Lou is a FAT ASS and his conditioning was never near Zane's , peak or no-peak.
-
Lou is a FAT ASS and his conditioning was never near Zane's , peak or no-peak.
But his last olympia appearance mode would have beaten Zane easily.You guys would be offended but he could own the best version of arnold too.
(http://sp5.fotologs.net/photo/53/6/26/ironpump/1161610258_f.jpg)
-
But his last olympia appearance mode would have beaten Zane easily.You guys would be offended but he could own the best version of arnold too.
(http://sp5.fotologs.net/photo/53/6/26/ironpump/1161610258_f.jpg)
You forgot to add that that was 20 years later.
And Lou's physique had never been able to reach the aesthetic standards of the likes of Zane or Arnold.
-
But his last olympia appearance mode would have beaten Zane easily.You guys would be offended but he could own the best version of arnold too.
(http://sp5.fotologs.net/photo/53/6/26/ironpump/1161610258_f.jpg)
Comparing Lou in the 90's and Arnold of the 70's in not exactly fair but I still would say Arnold LOOKED much better then Lou ever has. Just Imagine if Arnold had no life and stayed in BBing as long as Lou did. He would have been picking titles up till Dorian yates came.
-
Comparing Lou in the 90's and Arnold of the 70's in not exactly fair but I still would say Arnold LOOKED much better then Lou ever has. Just Imagine if Arnold had no life and stayed in BBing as long as Lou did. He would have been picking titles up till Dorian yates came.
Of course!! If Arnold did the samething as Lou,possibly he would have beaten Yates and got back Mr.O.
Here,just we are talking who was better in their best right?
-
btw, Lou was planning to enter the 1995 master O. around 340 pounds !!!!
but ended up retiring thanks to Carla (his wife)
He was 325 at the 93 mr.O and took 10th
At the 94' masters he was around 295 or so trying to look "ironAge" and took the runner up.
here's a clip of lou in 1995 weighting around 335 pounds, enjoy If u haven't seen it.
http://youtube.com/watch?v=v5sZ6rNGk38
This was funny.
-
Of course!! If Arnold did the samething as Lou,possibly he would have beaten Yates and got back Mr.O.
Here,just we are talking who was better in their best right?
every era has different criteria and "requirements" for physique standards. it is not really fair to gauge athletes across eras. how r u gonna compare steve reeves or john grimek with jay cutler/dennis wolf?
-
Chuck Norris.
-
every era has different criteria and "requirements" for physique standards. it is not really fair to gauge athletes across eras. how r u gonna compare steve reeves or john grimek with jay cutler/dennis wolf?
You cant compare their greatness or charisma...etc.
But physic alone,you can.
You see just
1 Muscle mass
2 Proportion
3 Definition
Total of these 3 elements are how to judge body.Quite mathematic.
-
You cant compare their greatness or charisma...etc.
But physic alone,you can.
You see just
1 Muscle mass
2 Proportion
3 Definition
Total of these 3 elements are how to judge body.Quite mathematic.
The advancement of drugs today has created physiques that look totally different and unachievable in the past. This is elementary. I hope you know this.
HOPE THIS HELPS
-
The advancement of drugs today has created physiques that look totally different and unachievable in the past. This is elementary. I hope you know this.
HOPE THIS HELPS
Hey I am not saying those past bbers are not great.
Even BBers of now or future use maga dose or something,thats nothing do do with what we are talking about. And we are NOT talking about WHO WAS GREAT.
We are just talking about their physic,dont forget.
And obviously you dont know what those gears are. Steroid dont do everything. Hope this help.
-
That must have made yourself feel really great.
LMFAO.
-
[quote author=kyomu link=topic=158944.msg2233248#msg2233248 date=1184426427
And obviously you dont know what those gears are. Steroid dont do everything. Hope this help.
That must have made yourself feel really great.
LMFAO.
I am a natural BBer dude..
-
But his last olympia appearance mode would have beaten Zane easily.You guys would be offended but he could own the best version of arnold too.
(http://sp5.fotologs.net/photo/53/6/26/ironpump/1161610258_f.jpg)
Love the calf implants.
-
The advancement of drugs today has created physiques that look totally different and unachievable in the past. This is elementary. I hope you know this.
HOPE THIS HELPS
There's no point in telling some people this. It just doesn't sink in...
Greg Kovaks vs. Sandow!!!!!
-
There's no point in telling some people this. It just doesn't sink in...
Greg Kovaks vs. Sandow!!!!!
absolutely right.
some natural BBers are just dumb.
-
Louie would eat the swimmer for lunch, but only after getting his 20 bucks first.
-
Personally, I believe that if Lou stepped on the Olympia stage while he was filming Hercules in 1982-1983, he would have destroyed everyone on stage.
-
Zane, but Lou would sue him.
hahahaha