Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure

Getbig Main Boards => Gossip & Opinions => Topic started by: TRIX on September 25, 2010, 08:47:00 AM

Title: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: TRIX on September 25, 2010, 08:47:00 AM
(http://jerrybruton.files.wordpress.com/2010/09/frist-night-pre-judging.png)
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: G_Thang on September 25, 2010, 08:51:57 AM
in jay's front double bicep his waist is wider than his shoulders.  if jay wins this yr...then he needs to retire.  i'm not sure branch isnt better than jay.  wtf is wolfe there for?  they got pressure from BSN for being a top 3 sponsor of the show.

 
 
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: XXXII/LX on September 25, 2010, 08:52:23 AM
Phillip.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: tendonitis on September 25, 2010, 08:54:24 AM
Phil
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Meso_z on September 25, 2010, 09:40:52 AM
Jay, his thickness is unbeatable. he will mop the floor with those guys tonight.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: 2ND COMING on September 25, 2010, 09:44:25 AM
wolfs back double bicep is sick.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Jaime on September 25, 2010, 09:47:32 AM
Wolf easily. The BDB on it's own should get him the win.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Myra on September 25, 2010, 09:51:34 AM
Wolf easily. The BDB on it's own should get him the win.

x2
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: _bruce_ on September 25, 2010, 09:55:19 AM
Branch
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: MAXX on September 25, 2010, 09:59:03 AM
Jay.

Phil looks like a toad
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: mass 04 on September 25, 2010, 10:03:36 AM
Branch
Yes!!!! My boy Bruce is pumped for the men in thong action!
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: JimmyJam1974 on September 25, 2010, 10:08:06 AM
O
wolfs back double bicep is sick.
Something's amiss though? Lats attached too high?
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: mass 04 on September 25, 2010, 10:10:14 AM
After closer inspection and multiple orgasms,
jay
phil
branch
dexter
wolf
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: French on September 25, 2010, 10:10:14 AM
Branch all the ways. He is the Man at this O.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Nails on September 25, 2010, 10:10:33 AM
Phil .. Great v-taper


Cutler zero calves
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Jaime on September 25, 2010, 10:11:55 AM
Looks better like that, keeps the tiny waist.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Boost on September 25, 2010, 10:12:26 AM
Cutler's forearms and calves have gone to s*** in recent years.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Pet shop boys on September 25, 2010, 10:14:33 AM

Hard to tell ....


I hope Phil doesnt win it ....Arms overpower rest of upper body, plus something with his torso that is not right"

WOOOSSSHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: French on September 25, 2010, 10:15:37 AM
1. Branch.
2. Robert Piotrkowicz.
3. Phil.
4. Dexter.
5. Jay.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: MuscleMcMannus on September 25, 2010, 10:16:41 AM
Wolf for sure has the coolest physique out of anyone put there.  But I also don't think midget height is very appealing.   ::)  Wolf will never win though because the judges like the short stumpy faggy bodybuilders. 
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Nirvana on September 25, 2010, 10:20:02 AM
I wish that huge arya-n bastard would get the refrigerator off the top

branch is a goblin

dex sounds too much like snoop dogg

and phil is a black levrone

kai is just fat this year
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: SF1900 on September 25, 2010, 10:31:57 AM
Okay, how can anyone look at Jay's front double bicep and actually think he should win? WTF!! Look at that stomach. Look at that overall structure. Id rather give it to a smaller guy with pleasing lines and who doesn't have  waistline as wide as their shoulders.

Either Phil, Dex or Wolf should be Mr. O.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: crownshep on September 25, 2010, 10:42:58 AM
Interesting to note that Wolf was moved by the judges closer to the middle for a closer comparison with Jay.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on September 25, 2010, 10:46:30 AM
Hard to judge from those pics. Jay doesn't look as good as last year but Heath didn't nail his conditioning as well as at the AC so in the absence of a clear winner in that department, Jay is wider, bigger but less aesthetic. Branch is still fuckin' ripped but proportions are still awful. Interesting to see that Wolf is back, he'll probably be in the top 4. Dex looks like Dex. Can't believe how off Kai is.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: berblexer on September 25, 2010, 10:47:23 AM
Dexter is my favorite.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Parker on September 25, 2010, 10:48:33 AM
wolfs back double bicep is sick.

Wolf for sure has the coolest physique out of anyone put there.  But I also don't think midget height is very appealing.   ::)  Wolf will never win though because the judges like the short stumpy faggy bodybuilders.  

Branch
Branch all the ways. He is the Man at this O.

WTF are you guys smokin? Wolf has no real back detail, and is missing a whole lower back, and Branch has a very shitty back, T-Rex arms that look like  twigs, true branches... detail from the back is shitty, the quality from both these hype monsters is quite pathetic
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: tendonitis on September 25, 2010, 10:50:02 AM
Cutler's front double bi has always been a disaster. He's got that giant barrel of a torso and his biceps look like they are from two different people.
His rear lat spread has absolutely no detail whatsoever and he's got wrinkles in his lower back.
How he continuously beats better bodybuilders is the biggest joke in bodybuilding.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Tom on September 25, 2010, 10:52:54 AM
heath i guess has the "prettier" physique, but cutler is the mass monster, freak with conditioning. whether i'm right or wrong, when i see heath i think of "npc nationals/ npc usa winner! i don't think of him as mr.olympia material?! since the last 10 plus years the olympia with the 1 time exception of dexter has always gone to the freakiest, mass monster whether that be yates, coleman or now cutler and it's still cutler.

alot of comments about jay's structure always go back to his "huge wide waist" however, think of the size and mass and thickness cutler has too that no one can touch, in another way, can't someone have "too thin of a waist" as well, wouldn't that be a downside to a physique as well. some of the heath and even dex waist shots, their waist to me almost too small, and not in a good way in that it actually brings down any size and mass and thickness they have.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on September 25, 2010, 10:54:35 AM
WTF are you guys smokin? [b]Wolf has no real back detail, and is missing a whole lower back,[/b] and Branch has a very shitty back, T-Rex arms that look like  twigs, true branches... detail from the back is shitty, the quality from both these hype monsters is quite pathetic

You exagerate a little here. Wolf's lower back has actually improved and he's in good condition. Cutler looks like he's holding water there, not Wolf. The upper back does miss some detail but the BDB is good though. The most complete is Dex in that back shot. Cutler's arms don't really pop when Wolf(s look great. Upper back detail is Jay's though. But the shoulder/Waiste ratio is Wolf and Dex all the way.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: CC973 on September 25, 2010, 10:55:41 AM
jay
phil
dex
branch
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: SF1900 on September 25, 2010, 10:58:49 AM
Hard to judge from those pics. Jay doesn't look as good as last year but Heath didn't nail his conditioning as well as at the AC so in the absence of a clear winner in that department, Jay is wider, bigger but less aesthetic. Branch is still fuckin' ripped but proportions are still awful. Interesting to see that Wolf is back, he'll probably be in the top 4. Dex looks like Dex. Can't believe how off Kai is.

Kai didn't get in touch with the universe, which is why he is off. Clearly in discordance with the metaphysical world  ::) ::) He needs to bring this up to the judges.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: Parker on September 25, 2010, 11:02:24 AM
You exagerate a little here. Wolf's lower back has actually improved and he's in good condition. Cutler looks like he's holding water there, not Wolf. The upper back does miss some detail but the BDB is good though. The most complete is Dex in that back shot. Cutler's arms don't really pop when Wolf(s look great. Upper back detail is Jay's though. But the shoulder/Waiste ratio is Wolf and Dex all the way.
After 3 yrs, he's only "slightly" improved his lower back...lazy ass
Kai didn't get in touch with the universe, which is why he is off. Clearly in discordance with the metaphysical world  ::) ::) He needs to bring this up to the judges.
Didn't you hear/ 2012 is around the corner, this is a harbinger of what's to come. Goro spilled over due to fluctuations in the Astral Plane coinciding with a random doorway opening between our world and the spirit realm (Lower Level of the Astral Plane)
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: MORTALCOIL on September 25, 2010, 11:04:31 AM
After 3 yrs, he's only "slightly" improved his lower back...lazy assDidn't you hear/ 2012 is around the corner, this is a harbinger of what's to come. Goro spilled over due to fluctuations in the Astral Plane coinciding with a random doorway opening between our world and the spirit realm (Lower Level of the Atral Plane)

All of them have flaws, Jay's waist is back in wide mode and he's conditioning is not as great as last, year, Heath still looks narrow, etc....All except Dex maybe (calves are still shitty though) and Rockell. It won't be about the most complete Bber.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: shootfighter1 on September 25, 2010, 12:09:26 PM
Such different physiques, hard to judge.  Phil is probably my favorite up there to win.  With the added mass, his gut is bigger though...still my favorite.  Jay looks ridiculous, wide, massive but the midsection is a negative for me, thankfully his width still gives him a taper. 

Wolf nailed it this time, interesting he isn't using a guru, just like when he nailed it in 2007.  His back is great, just that his lats don't insert as low as we'd like to see them.  His width is sick but the mid back lags because of the high lats. 

Great to see Rockel up where he belongs and he got better as the pre-judging went on.
The Polish guy is super impressive but the gut is out of hand.
Dexter looks great, very similar. The quads from the front aren't as separated but he'll land 3rd or 4th.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: che on September 25, 2010, 12:12:33 PM
Branch Warren ,Hahaha
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: tendonitis on September 25, 2010, 12:15:02 PM
Branch Warren ,Hahaha

Branch from the rear is a hideous beast.
Jay's lats climb up his back more and more every year, like they're trying to hide in his armpits or something.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: XXXII/LX on September 25, 2010, 12:20:15 PM
Branch Warren ,Hahaha

Branch looking very aesthetic.  ;D Top tier "athlete" all the way.
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: che on September 25, 2010, 12:28:39 PM
Phil Heath is narrow ::) but he is wider than Branch  :D
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: lowkeyguy on September 25, 2010, 12:34:11 PM
# 1 Heath
# 2 Cutler
# 3 Warren
# 4 Jackson


 
Title: Re: jay, wolf, phil, branch, dex comparisons - whos winning these shots?
Post by: JP_RC on September 25, 2010, 12:40:18 PM
Jay, Branch and Phil. The top 3 right there.

I can't really see who will take the title though.