Getbig.com: American Bodybuilding, Fitness and Figure
Getbig Misc Discussion Boards => Mixed Martial Arts (MMA/UFC) => Topic started by: suckmymuscle on January 20, 2011, 11:42:04 PM
-
I have a gut hunch that Barnett will surprise everyone and win this. He is as well rounded as Fedor but stands 6'3 and 240 lbs and he has the superb wrestling that other Strikeforce heavyweights lacks which will allow him to neutralize both Werdum's grappling and Overeem's stand up. A fight between Overeem and Barnett would be totally epic. Fedor is truly a mystery. If he comes back the Fedor of 2004 with insane submissions, superb takedown defenses, super KO power and the most epic and technical ground-and-pound ever, he could win but I don't think the Fedor of 20011 is even close to the Fedor of 2004. My prediction: Barnett will win this.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Barnett? Whos is that?
-
Barnett? Whos is that?
A guy who's better than anything the UFC can produce. :)
-
Lol! StrikeForce is planning to have the finally of the tournament in their back years, SJ California, where they get their biggest crwd. If Barnett makes it to the finals, they'll have to find a different venue because Barnett is not licensed to fight in CA due to his continuous steroid use...
This tournament will fall apart...
-
Wow- Good job MS. Nobody at SF or anywhere else took that into consideration until your last post. Thank you for saving us the trouble of having to watch the tournament. Hopefully I can watch some UFC unleashed "Best of Brock Lesnar" on spike instead. The only issue is that the program would last one minute and 24 seconds. Maybe I can squeeze an additional 15 minutes worth of viewing into "The Worst of Chuck Lidell" and a montage of some Kimbo slice appearences on TUF.
-
Barnett? Whos is that?
You know, the guy who was good enough to win the UFC heavyweight belt, become a finalist at PRIDE's Open Weight Granp Prix, one of the top wrestlers in the World and an MMA legend who is universally regarded as one of the top 5 MMA heavyweight fighters ever. That is who. Barnett would demolish all UFC heavyweight fighters they have in their roster because none of them has the combination of wrestling, KO power, chin, endurance and sheer size and strength that Barnett has.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
You know, the guy who was good enough to win the UFC heavyweight belt, become a finalist at PRIDE's Open Weight Granp Prix, one of the top wrestlers in the World and an MMA legend who is universally regarded as one of the top 5 MMA heavyweight fighters ever. That is who. Barnett would demolish all UFC heavyweight fighters they have in their roster because none of them has the combination of wrestling, KO power, chin, endurance and sheer size and strength that Barnett has.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
hahha.. yeah, no ufc heavies have his skill set. ::) They're drug tested idiot.
Barnett would possibly lose to Cain, Dos Santos, Big Nog, and Carwin. He is a UFC dropout due to his need for anabolics. Take that away and he isn't the same fighter. He would get crushed in UFC.
Keep dreamin' though boss.
-
You guys are all forgetting one thing here....Barnett and his hot piss took out an entire organization (Affliction).
If Barnett makes it all the way to the finals, and can't fight in CA, maybe he will fold Strikeforce too?
Barnett is good for the UFC, as history shows.
-
hahha.. yeah, no ufc heavies have his skill set. They're drug tested idiot.
Barnett would possibly lose to Cain, Dos Santos, Big Nog, and Carwin. He is a UFC dropout due to his need for anabolics. Take that away and he isn't the same fighter. He would get crushed in UFC.
Keep dreamin' though boss.
You need to resort to insults because you have nothing intelligent or intelligible to say.
You speak as if the UFC heavyweights aren't on steroids. Epic delusions. Do you really think that Shane Carwin would be around 290 lbs with average bodyfat like he is without steroids? Shit dude, you're dumb.
And steroids do not increase your skills and technique; it only increases your strength. It does not improve your submissions or your take-down techniques and it does not even increase punching power - pro bodybuilders hit like girls.
Barnett > all the UFC heavyweight roster except for maybe Cain who is well rounded.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
You guys are all forgetting one thing here....Barnett and his hot piss took out an entire organization (Affliction).
If Barnett makes it all the way to the finals, and can't fight in CA, maybe he will fold Strikeforce too?
Barnett is good for the UFC, as history shows.
Oh hi, Mindpsin. Why don't you give your(same) opinions on your "Evolver" account? Posting the same shit on multiple accounts just to make people believe that there are other people who agree with you and give credibility to your positions is sad.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Wow- Good job MS. Nobody at SF or anywhere else took that into consideration until your last post. Thank you for saving us the trouble of having to watch the tournament. Hopefully I can watch some UFC unleashed "Best of Brock Lesnar" on spike instead. The only issue is that the program would last one minute and 24 seconds. Maybe I can squeeze an additional 15 minutes worth of viewing into "The Worst of Chuck Lidell" and a montage of some Kimbo slice appearences on TUF.
Have you listened to the Scott Coker interviews on the Larry Pepe show or on the SRN? The guy put this whole thing together with virtually no planning and announced everything before he even knew who was committed or who wasn't. It was just last week that they finally figured out that they would be doing a separate belt. And Coker got caught lying. He said the commission would not let them do 5 five minute rounds. They interviewed the commissioners and they said they hadn't even spoken to Coker about it.
Trust me, this thing has train wreck written all over it.
-
Oh hi, Mindpsin. Why don't you give your(same) opinions on your "Evolver" account? Posting the same shit on multiple accounts just to make people believe that there are other people who agree with you and give credibility to your positions is sad.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
What multiple accounts idiot? It's the exact same account. I already posted on a previous thread that I changed my handle name to Evolver ::)
-
What multiple accounts idiot? It's the exact same account. I already posted on a previous thread that I changed my handle name to Evolver
I am talking about your "Evolver" and "WeighPSHR" accounts, idiot. These are the multiple accounts I am talking about. I just called you "MindSpin" because that is how everyone knows you. Retarded fuck. Don't try to offend people who are smarter than you.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
On this same thread you called me out for insults
Your hate for spin in epic. How much is the rent for space in your head going for these days? Ill pm Ms and ask him.
-
On this same thread you called me out for insults
Your hate for spin in epic. How much is the rent for space in your head going for these days? Ill pm Ms and ask him.
I only insulted him after he insulted me. I never initiate insults. After my opponent insults me, he is fair game and can't complain. Lolllll.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Josh Barnett is Fedor's favorite MMA fighter. And not in the heavyweight division, but in all weight divsions!! :D
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
I only insulted him after he insulted me. I never initiate insults. After my opponent insults me, he is fair game and can't complain. Lolllll.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
Dude, is english your 2nd language? You're fucking illiterate.
-
Dude, is english your 2nd language? You're fucking illiterate.
Are you illiterate? Google the phrase "initiate insults" and see what the results are. And for your own enrichment, here are some of the definitions of the word from Princeton University. I guess lacking in MMA knowledge isn't your only deficiency.
•originate: bring into being; "He initiated a new program"; "Start a foundation"
•take the lead or initiative in; participate in the development of; "This South African surgeon pioneered heart transplants"
•accept people into an exclusive society or group, usually with some rite; "African men are initiated when they reach puberty"
•novice: someone new to a field or activity
•broach: bring up a topic for discussion
•someone who has been admitted to membership in a scholarly field
•lead up: set in motion, start an event or prepare the way for; "Hitler's attack on Poland led up to World War II"
•initiation - trigger: an act that sets in motion some course of events
-
Are you illiterate? Google the phrase "initiate insults" and see what the results are. And for your own enrichment, here are some of the definitions of the word from Princeton University. I guess lacking in MMA knowledge isn't your only deficiency.
•originate: bring into being; "He initiated a new program"; "Start a foundation"
•take the lead or initiative in; participate in the development of; "This South African surgeon pioneered heart transplants"
•accept people into an exclusive society or group, usually with some rite; "African men are initiated when they reach puberty"
•novice: someone new to a field or activity
•broach: bring up a topic for discussion
•someone who has been admitted to membership in a scholarly field
•lead up: set in motion, start an event or prepare the way for; "Hitler's attack on Poland led up to World War II"
•initiation - trigger: an act that sets in motion some course of events
Thanks, dude. You beat me to it. I never initiate insults, but if the person debating me insults me, then I have carte blanche to insult back.
Coltrane criticized me for criticizing others for insulting because I also insult, but he missed the point that all my insults only happen after I am insulted.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Thanks, dude. You beat me to it. I never initiate insults, but if the person debating me insults me, then I have carte blanche to insult back.
Coltrane criticized me for criticizing others for insulting because I also insult, but he missed the point that all my insults only happen after I am insulted.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
I'll try to follow your postings a little better next time. Sorry for any inconvienence I may have cause you. :'(
-
I'll try to follow your postings a little better next time. Sorry for any inconvienence I may have cause you. :'(
Condescending post reported.
-
Condescending post reported.
Reported for accuracy.
-
Reported for accuracy.
Coltrane, you are the biggest joke in this board by far. Even WeightPSHR contributes better posts than you. All you are good for is to get owned continuously by myself and George Whorewell. None of your MMA predictions come true. You basically combine the lack of knowledge of MindSpin with the UFC fanboyism of Weight PSHR. You should delete your account and go away in shame. Lolllll.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Coltrane, you are the biggest joke in this board by far. Even WeightPSHR contributes better posts than you. All you are good for is to get owned continuously by myself and George Whorewell. None of your MMA predictions come true. You basically combine the lack of knowledge of MindSpin with the UFC fanboyism of Weight PSHR. You should delete your account and go away in shame. Lolllll.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
I own you and live inside your head as soon as you log into Getbig.
YOU, my friend, should delete your account before you become too obsessed with what I post.
-
Oh, and Barnett sucks. Cain, JDS, Carwin, Mir, & Nog would all beat his ass down. AND, I might add that Cro Cop probably would too.. as Barnett just can't seem to get a win against him. I'd even go on record to say that Lesnar would put on a good match with him these days.
Oh wait though... it's a STRIKEFORCE tourney. I forgot.
Insane amounts of Barnett Ball-Licking going on.
-
After hearing recent interviews on this Tournament from Coker, this is a HUGE clusterfuck. Here are just a few things:
-Not sure if or where Barnett will be licensed to fight.
-Not sure if fights are going to be three rounds or five
-Not sure if they will end up with a separate "Tournament" champ from the regular HW Champ.
-Not Sure where each of the events will be held.
Could you imagine the UFC or any other well run sports organization "planning" something with all these uncertainties?
-
Oh, and Barnett sucks. Cain, JDS, Carwin, Mir, & Nog would all beat his ass down. AND, I might add that Cro Cop probably would too.. as Barnett just can't seem to get a win against him. I'd even go on record to say that Lesnar would put on a good match with him these days.
Oh wait though... it's a STRIKEFORCE tourney. I forgot.
Insane amounts of Barnett Ball-Licking going on.
Barnett hasn't had a credible victory in years!! The sport changes so fast. Barnett fans are forgetting this is 2011.
Who in their right mind would even promote a fight with Barnett? MULTIPLE failed tests, some with MULTIPLE Steroids as well.
Oh...wait, If you are Strikeforce, what other choice do you have? IMO, Barnett will fold Strikeforce like Affliction. He IS A DRUG ABUSER! He CAN"T fight clean.
-
I own you and live inside your head as soon as you log into Getbig.
YOU, my friend, should delete your account before you become too obsessed with what I post.
To be honest with you, I didn't even know who you were before I started posting on the MMA board. How many posts of mine have been directed at you? This is the second or third. Own my mind? Hardly.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Coltrane- out of all the TUF retards on here, ( both of you) I like you the best. However, to say Barnett sucks is absurd. Beyond that, to say Frank Mir or Cro Cop would beat down anybody shows you don't know shit about MMA or you're just saying that to bait Suck into arguing with you.
JDS and Cain are the only two legitimate HW's in the UFC (until Carwin comes back from his injury and shows he can still fight). The rest are a complete joke. Check Kongo, Frank Mir and a 72 year old Nogueirra who's brain is mush from getting hit for the better part of a decade doesn't impress me (or anyone else). Who else are you going to argue? Roy Nelson? Brock Lesnar? ::)
Fedor, Overeem, Barnett, Werdum= 10x better than the UFC HW division on their own.
-
Coltrane- out of all the TUF retards on here, ( both of you) I like you the best. However, to say Barnett sucks is absurd. Beyond that, to say Frank Mir or Cro Cop would beat down anybody shows you don't know shit about MMA or you're just saying that to bait Suck into arguing with you.
JDS and Cain are the only two legitimate HW's in the UFC (until Carwin comes back from his injury and shows he can still fight). The rest are a complete joke. Check Kongo, Frank Mir and a 72 year old Nogueirra who's brain is mush from getting hit for the better part of a decade doesn't impress me (or anyone else). Who else are you going to argue? Roy Nelson? Brock Lesnar?
Fedor, Overeem, Barnett, Werdum= 10x better than the UFC HW division on their own.
Coltrane's MMA predictions never come true. You have beaten him in all your bets. At least I don't pretend to be an MMA expert, even though I probably know more than he does given that I have watched MMA since the first UFC back in 1993 when Royce shocked the World and won.
The only people in this board who truly know MMA are yourself, ChuteBoxe, GracieJJ and SinCity. I literally laughed out loud when MindSpin said that Frank Mir would beat Fedor because he beat a brain-destroyed past prime Nogueira who was just coming back from surgery. That was so stupid that it boggles the imagination. Are these guys for real?
And Barnett has the tools to destroy the entire UFC heavyweight division. I mean, he beat Couture back in 2002 when he was still in his prime, and he did it dominantly. None of the UFC heavyweights have a well-rounded game that would present Barnett with a challenge except for Cain. The Nogueira of 5 years ago maybe, but today he is too injured. If he fights JDS, he will do that take-down and either win by points or submit him. Yeah, JDS has a black belt in BJJ, but we've never seen submissions from him whilst we have seen masterful ones from Barnett. But Barnett would proably hold him down and ground-and-pound. If he fights Carwin, same thing. Cain would be a real challenge, but Barnett would overwhelm him with sheer power - Barnett is incredibly strong even for his 250 lbs.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Coltrane's MMA predictions never come true. You have beaten him in all your bets. At least I don't pretend to be an MMA expert, even though I probably know more than he does given that I have watched MMA since the first UFC back in 1993 when Royce shocked the World and won.
The only people in this board who truly know MMA are yourself, ChuteBoxe, GracieJJ and SinCity. I literally laughed out loud when MindSpin said that Frank Mir would beat Fedor because he beat a brain-destroyed past prime Nogueira who was just coming back from surgery. That was so stupid that it boggles the imagination. Are these guys for real?
And Barnett has the tools to destroy the entire UFC heavyweight division. I mean, he beat Couture back in 2002 when he was still in his prime, and he did it dominantly. None of the UFC heavyweights have a well-rounded game that would present Barnett with a challenge except for Cain. The Nogueira of 5 years ago maybe, but today he is too injured. If he fights JDS, he will do that take-down and either win by points or submit him. Yeah, JDS has a black belt in BJJ, but we've never seen submissions from him whilst we have seen masterful ones from Barnett. But Barnett would proably hold him down and ground-and-pound. If he fights Carwin, same thing. Cain would be a real challenge, but Barnett would overwhelm him with sheer power - Barnett is incredibly strong even for his 250 lbs.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
Thanks for proving my point. You guys swinging on Barnett's strap are forgetting that times have changed and this is 2011. The Couture victory was 9 years ago...you know how insane even bringing that victory up sounds?
Sorry, but Barnett will always be remembered as the guy that brought down Affliction.
I find it more comical that everyone thinks Barnett has a chance in this tournament, all while overlooking Overeem.
Overeem will dominate every single one of these guys, and hopefully will come to the UFC. I know Overeem will not dodge anyone.
Look at Barnett's recent fights....Who on here is even worth noting. He hasn't fought a top guy in years.
Win Geronimo dos Santos TKO (Punches) Impact FC 1 - The Uprising: Brisbane 7/10/2010 1 2:35
Win Siala-Mou Siliga Submission (Kimura) Dream - Dream 13 3/22/2010 1 4:41
Win Gilbert Yvel Submission (Punches) Affliction - Day of Reckoning 1/24/2009 3 3:05
Win Pedro Rizzo KO (Punch) Affliction - Banned 7/19/2008 2 1:44
Win Jeff Monson Decision (Unanimous) Sengoku - Second Battle 5/18/2008 3 5:00
Win Hidehiko Yoshida Submission (Heel Hook) Sengoku - First Battle 3/5/2008 3 3:23
Loss Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira Decision (Unanimous) PRIDE - Shockwave 2006 12/31/2006 3 5:00
Win Pawel Nastula Submission (Toe Hold) PRIDE 32 - The Real Deal 10/21/2006 2 3:04
-
Thanks for proving my point. You guys swinging on Barnett's strap are forgetting that times have changed and this is 2011. The Couture victory was 9 years ago...you know how insane even bringing that victory up sounds?
Sorry, but Barnett will always be remembered as the guy that brought down Affliction.
I find it more comical that everyone thinks Barnett has a chance in this tournament, all while overlooking Overeem.
Overeem will dominate every single one of these guys, and hopefully will come to the UFC. I know Overeem will not dodge anyone.
Look at Barnett's recent fights....Who on here is even worth noting. He hasn't fought a top guy in years.
Win Geronimo dos Santos TKO (Punches) Impact FC 1 - The Uprising: Brisbane 7/10/2010 1 2:35
Win Siala-Mou Siliga Submission (Kimura) Dream - Dream 13 3/22/2010 1 4:41
Win Gilbert Yvel Submission (Punches) Affliction - Day of Reckoning 1/24/2009 3 3:05
Win Pedro Rizzo KO (Punch) Affliction - Banned 7/19/2008 2 1:44
Win Jeff Monson Decision (Unanimous) Sengoku - Second Battle 5/18/2008 3 5:00
Win Hidehiko Yoshida Submission (Heel Hook) Sengoku - First Battle 3/5/2008 3 3:23
Loss Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira Decision (Unanimous) PRIDE - Shockwave 2006 12/31/2006 3 5:00
Win Pawel Nastula Submission (Toe Hold) PRIDE 32 - The Real Deal 10/21/2006 2 3:04
You are clinically insane.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
@ GW: I may be trying to bait Suck a little with my CroCop beating Barnett. I do think Mir is still a very viable fighter though. Again, just my two cents. And when have I ever gone on record as being a huge TUF fan? I actually haven't watched much of that show in years.
@Suckmymuscle: Relax. The whole Barnett thing is trying to rile you up just a bit. I do know all about Barnett and what he's accomplished in his past. However, he hasn't been relevent in the past years. I do agree with Weighpusher in that overeem will dominate the tourney (outside of Fedor) if it ever occurs. You don't need to post back about how he has been relevant.. that only prolongs this feud, etc.
Also, I made my 2010 prediction, which didn't pan out that great...along with most posters' predictions. Some did better than others. You, as i recall, didn't predict shit for last year. So don't boast about my poor predictions. And remember, they are PREDICTIONS. Of course they're not going to be super accurate.
I hate bickering back and forth with you guys on here bc I love coming on these boards and reading about MMA. You all have your opinions, some different than mine, but in the end we need to stop with this bs. This is an official truce, a peace pipe if you will, to try to keep the personal bashing at a minimum.
-
And when is this tourney supposed to take place?
I'm assuming it's on Showtime?
-
You are clinically insane.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
For the purpose of enlightenment, in your opinion, when was Barnett's last credible opponent?
-
@ GW: I may be trying to bait Suck a little with my CroCop beating Barnett. I do think Mir is still a very viable fighter though. Again, just my two cents. And when have I ever gone on record as being a huge TUF fan? I actually haven't watched much of that show in years.
@Suckmymuscle: Relax. The whole Barnett thing is trying to rile you up just a bit. I do know all about Barnett and what he's accomplished in his past. However, he hasn't been relevent in the past years. I do agree with Weighpusher in that overeem will dominate the tourney (outside of Fedor) if it ever occurs. You don't need to post back about how he has been relevant.. that only prolongs this feud, etc.
Also, I made my 2010 prediction, which didn't pan out that great...along with most posters' predictions. Some did better than others. You, as i recall, didn't predict shit for last year. So don't boast about my poor predictions. And remember, they are PREDICTIONS. Of course they're not going to be super accurate.
I hate bickering back and forth with you guys on here bc I love coming on these boards and reading about MMA. You all have your opinions, some different than mine, but in the end we need to stop with this bs. This is an official truce, a peace pipe if you will, to try to keep the personal bashing at a minimum.
I agree...the back and forth debates on here are great, but the Dick N Ball excuse for everything that people don't agree on is pointless. Just back up why you feel the way you do on certain things and leave it at that.
-
For the purpose of enlightenment, in your opinion, when was Barnett's last credible opponent?
You are making the a priori assumption that Barnett has declined. There is no evidence of it. Barnett actually carries 20 lbs of lean muscle more than he did when he beat prime Couture in dominating fashion. He hasn't fought top competition because of his failed steroids tests and not because he isn't good enough to fight them. His wrestling continues World-class and he is even bigger and faster than he used to be.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
I find it more comical that everyone thinks Barnett has a chance in this tournament, all while overlooking Overeem.
No one is overlooking Overeem. In fact, most people are Overeem fan-boys who believe that he's the greatest MMA fighter on the planet. In fact, he`s the favorite to win the tournament.
But what has Overeem accomplish to rate him so high in MMA? Winning K-1 doesen't mean that you are the best MMA fighter on the planet. We have never seen Overeem fight a top wrestler who is as big and strong as he is. What would happen if he fought Josh Barnett who is as big and strong as he is and got taken down over and over again? How would Overeem deal with that? Trying to clinch won't work with a really big and strong wrestler. And Overeem certainly doesen't have the BJJ to finish of a wrestler on the ground or get off his back and stand up again. Also, Overeem has never been tested against guys with lots of KO power and with stone chins. Put him against guys who hit really hard and can take a lot of punishment, like Carwin, Fedor or JDS, and let's see how he fares, He can certainly dish out, but can he take it? The guys he fought in K-1 are very technical strikers, but none has devastating KO power.
Overeem will dominate every single one of these guys, and hopefully will come to the UFC. I know Overeem will not dodge anyone.
Fedor is a little too small to defeat Overeem, but he has the tools. Barnett is the one guy who can do it. He is just as strong and fast as Overeem and has the World-class wrestling that is custom-made to deal with one-dimensional strikers like Overeem.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
@ GW: I may be trying to bait Suck a little with my CroCop beating Barnett. I do think Mir is still a very viable fighter though. Again, just my two cents. And when have I ever gone on record as being a huge TUF fan? I actually haven't watched much of that show in years.
The old Crocop could certainly do it. Crocop put more people to sleep with his upper left leg kick than anyone in MMA history. Unfortunately, the cage doesen't suit his fighting style
@Suckmymuscle: Relax. The whole Barnett thing is trying to rile you up just a bit. I do know all about Barnett and what he's accomplished in his past. However, he hasn't been relevent in the past years. I do agree with Weighpusher in that overeem will dominate the tourney (outside of Fedor) if it ever occurs. You don't need to post back about how he has been relevant.. that only prolongs this feud, etc.
Overeem needs to be tested against two types of fighters before he can claim to be truly great at MMA: huge wrestlers and guys with KO power who are really hard to put to sleep. How would Overeem deal with a guy who is as strong as he is and keeps taking him down over and over and over again? He won't just be able to get of his back with sheer strength against a guy who is as strong as he is over and over and over again. How will he deal with someone like Fedor who hits like a sledge hammer and is a master at finding chins and who took several of Brett Roger's punches to face without any effect on him?
And I agree with you about Fedor. He is the most intelligent fighter out there. He always finds a way to win by discovering the holes in his opponent's games, and he has incredible heart and pain endurance. The really incredible thing about a Fedor vs Overeem fight is that Overeem would probably try to take the fight down after he tastes some of Fedor's punches. That guy hits really, really hard. People might be shocked in a potential Fedor vs Overeem fight to see "the World's best striker" trying to either clinch with Fedor or take him to the ground. Everything to avoid that power.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
The old Crocop could certainly do it. Crocop put more people to sleep with his upper left leg kick than anyone in MMA history. Unfortunately, the cage doesen't suit his fighting style
Overeem needs to be tested against two types of fighters before he can claim to be truly great at MMA: huge wrestlers and guys with KO power who are really hard to put to sleep. How would Overeem deal with a guy who is as strong as he is and keeps taking him down over and over and over again? He won't just be able to get of his back with sheer strength against a guy who is as strong as he is over and over and over again. How will he deal with someone like Fedor who hits like a sledge hammer and is a master at finding chins and who took several of Brett Roger's punches to face without any effect on him?
And I agree with you about Fedor. He is the most intelligent fighter out there. He ALMOST always finds a way to win by discovering the holes in his opponent's games, and he has incredible heart and pain endurance. The really incredible thing about a Fedor vs Overeem fight is that Overeem would probably try to take the fight down after he tastes some of Fedor's punches. That guy hits really, really hard. People might be shocked in a potential Fedor vs Overeem fight to see "the World's best striker" trying to either clinch with Fedor or take him to the ground. Everything to avoid that power.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
Edited for accuracy.
-
Edited for accuracy.
Fedor lost fair and square to Werdum, but the loss was flukish in the sense that Fedor shouldn't even be in Werdum's guard in the first place. Fedor fought unintelligently in that fight which is ususual for him. When you are in the guard of a BJJ master like Werdum you cannot afford to make even a single mistake and you get caught, and Fedor made a mistake. Even Rickson Gracie, the World's finest BJJ practitioner(7th degree black belt in BJJ) has made mistakes whilst in the guard of other BJJ masters and got submitted. Anyone can get caught in the guard of a BJJ master.
What annoys me about you is that you regard Fedor as worthless because he got caught in a submission. You completely disregard all his accomplishments. I could see your point if Fedor had been taken over and over to the ground and controlled there and ground-and-pounded by his opponent, or got beat into submission in the stand-up to a point where the judge declared a technical KO. That would be proof that his opponent clearly surpassed him in skills as a fighter and dominated him. But he got caught in a submission in the first couple minutes of the fight. What does that prove? That Werdum is a better grappler than Fedor? We already knew that even before the fight. Getting caught in a submission is the cheapest way to lose a fight. Despite the loss, I still belive that Fedor at his best is the best heavyweight out there: most well-rounded, experienced, the one who makes the least mistakes and toughest in pain tolerance and desire to win. I will only accept that Fedor is no longer the World's best MMA heavyweight when he gets dominated in the course of a protracted fight or KOd. Until that happens, he is still king. The loss to Werdum doesen't prove much.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Yeah for people to say 'Barnett would destroy the whole UFC HW division' is pathetic.He couldnt beat Crocop for a start, and look how poor he is in the UFC ;)
-
Fedor lost fair and square to Werdum, but the loss was flukish in the sense that Fedor shouldn't even be in Werdum's guard in the first place. Fedor fought unintelligently in that fight which is ususual for him. When you are in the guard of a BJJ master like Werdum you cannot afford to make even a single mistake and you get caught, and Fedor made a mistake. Even Rickson Gracie, the World's finest BJJ practitioner(7th degree black belt in BJJ) has made mistakes whilst in the guard of other BJJ masters and got submitted. Anyone can get caught in the guard of a BJJ master.
What annoys me about you is that you regard Fedor as worthless because he got caught in a submission. You completely disregard all his accomplishments. I could see your point if Fedor had been taken over and over to the ground and controlled there and ground-and-pounded by his opponent, or got beat into submission in the stand-up to a point where the judge declared a technical KO. That would be proof that his opponent clearly surpassed him in skills as a fighter and dominated him. But he got caught in a submission in the first couple minutes of the fight. What does that prove? That Werdum is a better grappler than Fedor? We already knew that even before the fight. Getting caught in a submission is the cheapest way to lose a fight. Despite the loss, I still belive that Fedor at his best is the best heavyweight out there: most well-rounded, experienced, the one who makes the least mistakes and toughest in pain tolerance and desire to win. I will only accept that Fedor is no longer the World's best MMA heavyweight when he gets dominated in the course of a protracted fight or KOd. Until that happens, he is still king. The loss to Werdum doesen't prove much.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
I never said Fedor was worthless. Fedor's had several freak-show fights and questionable opponents over the last 5+years. Fedor and his fans are still trying to hold onto the 'mystique' that he had years ago. Fedor is an exciting fighter, but I have no reason to call him the CURRENT best HW in MMA. Call it what you want, the loss to Werdum was real and legit. At the highest level, you can't make these mistakes. These mistakes are what separate the best from the second or third best.
-
Yeah for people to say 'Barnett would destroy the whole UFC HW division' is pathetic.He couldnt beat Crocop for a start, and look how poor he is in the UFC ;)
Not to mention, he hasn't heat a top 5 opponent in years.
-
I never said Fedor was worthless. Fedor's had several freak-show fights and questionable opponents over the last 5+years. Fedor and his fans are still trying to hold onto the 'mystique' that he had years ago. Fedor is an exciting fighter, but I have no reason to call him the CURRENT best HW in MMA.
You can say Cain is the current best, but even Cain would be an underdog if he fought Fedor at his best day. I see it 60/40 for Fedor to win.
Call it what you want, the loss to Werdum was real and legit. At the highest level, you can't make these mistakes. These mistakes are what separate the best from the second or third best.
You completley missed my point...you can't make mistakes? Even 7th degree BJJ masters make mistakes in grappling and get caught. Grappling is by far the most technical of all the three things that make an MMA fighter(the other being striking and wrestling). There is no such thing as "at this level you can't make mistakes". When you are grappling with a 5th degree World champion in BJJ, not making mistakes is impossible. Even other 5th degree BJJ fighters get caught whilst in the guard of 5th degree BJJ masters. How do you think that BJJ World championship ids won? A grand master makes a mistake and gets submitted and the other guy wins. No such thing as not making mistakes at this level. This is why grappling with another fighter is foolish if you aren't way better than him because even if your opponent is isn't better than you there is a good chance you will make a mistake, put one of your limbs in a position of bad leverage and get submitted. Fedor was stupid, but he still beats Werdum 999 out of 1,000 times if he fights intelligently, which he didn't.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
You can say Cain is the current best, but even Cain would be an underdog if he fought Fedor at his best day. I see it 60/40 for Fedor to win.
You completley missed my point...you can't make mistakes? Even 7th degree BJJ masters make mistakes in grappling and get caught. Grappling is by far the most technical of all the three things that make an MMA fighter(the other being striking and wrestling). There is no such thing as "at this level you can't make mistakes". When you are grappling with a 5th degree World champion in BJJ, not making mistakes is impossible. Even other 5th degree BJJ fighters get caught whilst in the guard of 5th degree BJJ masters. How do you think that BJJ World championship ids won? A grand master makes a mistake and gets submitted and the other guy wins. No such thing as not making mistakes at this level. This is why grappling with another fighter is foolish if you aren't way better than him because even if your opponent is isn't better than you there is a good chance you will make a mistake, put one of your limbs in a position of bad leverage and get submitted. Fedor was stupid, but he still beats Werdum 999 out of 1,000 times if he fights intelligently, which he didn't.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
Fedor will never be in the UFC, so pointless to debate or speculate. Although I would LOVE to see that fight!
I think you misunderstood my statement on mistakes and I was not very clear. You can't make blatant mistakes at this level and expect to remain #1.
I know EVERYONE makes mistakes, but when you are at the top, it's really about who makes the smallest ones. Fedor indeed made a mistake in the Werdum fight that cost him his record and #1 ranking. It was a mistake that he can't make to be #1.
Ask Chael Sonnen about mistakes.
-
Fedor will never be in the UFC, so pointless to debate or speculate. Although I would LOVE to see that fight!
I think you misunderstood my statement on mistakes and I was not very clear. You can't make blatant mistakes at this level and expect to remain #1.
I know EVERYONE makes mistakes, but when you are at the top, it's really about who makes the smallest ones. Fedor indeed made a mistake in the Werdum fight that cost him his record and #1 ranking. It was a mistake that he can't make to be #1.
Ask Chael Sonnen about mistakes.
The only ones who wouldn't make a mistake in Werdum's guard are Roger and Rickson Gracie and Werdum would still stand a good chance of beating them. Making mistakes at this level of grappling is almost a sure thing. Like I said, even Rickson has been tapped! Why can't you understand this?! Werdum submitting Fedor doesen't prove that he's better at MMA: it proves that he's better at BJJ. Fedor beats Werdum 99 out of 100 times is he avoids Werdum's guard. It's simple as that.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
Hi guys, just thought i would contribute my own thoughts on this as i have been mildly excited about this one since it was announced.
First and foremost, and i know this will irritate a vast majority of posters, but i do not buy into the Overeem hype as him being the worlds best. I agree that his striking is premier and he probably has a half decent ground game, but how he manages to pass a steroid test is beyond me. He has most of the tools but there are people out there who are always better - regardless of the margin, theyre still better. If he can maintain the standing position and take the center he is going to be very hard to beat.
Fedor's prime has come and gone in the blink of an eye, he maintained his mystique by fighting lesser opponents in his later years although he is once again stepping up to the plate. Age affects us all differently, do you really think Nog would have lost to Mir by any means in his prime? I think not even close. Whilst Fedor should have demolished Werdum he made unaccustomed mistakes in the guard against a man he should have recognised as world class in that position and he was caught.
Josh Barnett is the dark horse for me, his skills are probably still there but how will he perform come fight night - and if he is clean what effect will it have on his ability to control people? I think he will have a good showing, win or lose, but the big question is - will he be licensed to compete and then complete the tournament?
Werdum is in a position hes never found himself, and he needs to prove the Fedor win wasnt a fluke. The big problem is that he already stated that Fedor is the best and should have / will beat him regardless of a fluke. What does that say about confidence - he needs to realise hes now the big target aside from Overeem.
Arlovski, Rogers and Kharitonov are there to make up the numbers, i dont see any of them doing any real damage to the division but i think Sergei will bury Andrei. Silva however has always been a standout for me, ive followed him since his debut and was very shocked when Pele beat him - even more so with the Werdum fight. If he wasnt fighting Fedor first i would pick him for the final, i think he is excellent (not everyone agrees as its all down to personal taste) but far from world number 1.
Overall winner - Fedor (time to learn from past mistakes, stand up and be counted again)
-
The only ones who wouldn't make a mistake in Werdum's guard are Roger and Rickson Gracie and Werdum would still stand a good chance of beating them. Making mistakes at this level of grappling is almost a sure thing. Like I said, even Rickson has been tapped! Why can't you understand this?! Werdum submitting Fedor doesen't prove that he's better at MMA: it proves that he's better at BJJ. Fedor beats Werdum 99 out of 100 times is he avoids Werdum's guard. It's simple as that.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
Let's keep this on topic. Fedor made a mistake and got caught. It was a rookie mistake, but regardless, Werdum got a legitimate win. I never said Werdum is a better fighter.
-
Let's keep this on topic. Fedor made a mistake and got caught. It was a rookie mistake, but regardless, Werdum got a legitimate win. I never said Werdum is a better fighter.
And I never denied Fedor's loss was genuine. But you are just a Fedor hater. You never miss an opportunity to put the guy down. Hell, your avatar is a celebration of Fedor's loss. And rookie mistake? Yes, going into Werdum's guard was a rookie mistake. The way he escaped Werdum's first submission attempt was masterful. Werdum was on T.V here in Brazil and said that he was intimidated by how good Fedor's grappling was when he escaped his first submission attempt. According to Werdum, most BJJ black belts would have tapped there.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
-
And I never denied Fedor's loss was genuine. But you are just a Fedor hater. You never miss an opportunity to put the guy down. Hell, your avatar is a celebration of Fedor's loss. And rookie mistake? Yes, going into Werdum's guard was a rookie mistake. The way he escaped Werdum's first submission attempt was masterful. Werdum was on T.V here in Brazil and said that he was intimidated by how good Fedor's grappling was when he escaped his first submission attempt. According to Werdum, most BJJ black belts would have tapped there.
SUCKMYMUSCLE
::)
-
::)
Ok, you are questioning the veracity of it? I can post links to Werdum praising Fedor if you want me to.
SUCKMYMUSCLE