Answer me this one. What does ETH actually price? I believe I know. It isn't anything what the gurus and grifters tell you it is. Mind you, they don't know what BTC is either.
Bro I explained this over a year ago, but not many people understood me or bothered to read. I came up with a "back of envelope" price of around $500 Eth. Obsidian will recall, as he told me I was being ridiculous at the time.
Again assuming: roughly 122 million ETH outstanding, 43.7 million ETH staked and ~2.6% staking APR.
1. The basic formula
VETH=∑t=1NCFt(1+r)t+CFN(1+gT)(r−gT)(1+r)NETHdiluted supplyV_{ETH} = \frac{ \sum_{t=1}^{N}\frac{CF_t}{(1+r)^t} + \frac{CF_N(1+g_T)}{(r-g_T)(1+r)^N} }{ ETH_{\text{diluted supply}} }
Where:
CFtCF_t = annual economic cash flow attributable to ETH
rr = required return/discount rate
gTg_T = long-term terminal growth
NN = explicit forecast period
supply = expected ETH supply
The hard part of curse is defining CF. Ie - What constitutes ETH "cash flow"?
CFt=StakingRewardst+MEVt+PriorityFeest−ValidatorCoststCF_t = StakingRewards_t + MEV_t + PriorityFees_t - ValidatorCosts_t
One thing (Obsidian has pointed it out in the past). ETH burned by EIP-1559 isn't literally a "cash payment" to holders. It's closer to a share buyback as it reduces token supply. I would therefore incorporate burning through the denominator/supply forecast rather than adding it to cash flow. That avoids double counting.
So, approximately 43.7m ETH, 35.8% of supply, is currently staked, at roughly 2.6% annual staking rewards.
That implies roughly:
43.7m×2.6%≈1.14mETH43.7m \times 2.6\% \approx 1.14m ETH
in annual staking rewards, broadly consistent with estimates of roughly 1.1m ETH annual issuance before burns.
Now, take 2026 starting cash flow
Using an ETH reference price of approximately $2,700 from the October data:
1.1mETH×$2,700=$2.97bn1.1m ETH \times \$2,700 = \$2.97bn
The $2,700 reference price and approximately 122m supply are consistent with the recent staking statistics.
So, say $2.97bn as an illustrative year-zero economic cash-flow base.
Then assume:
Variable Base assumptionStarting economic CF $2.97bn
Explicit forecast 10 years
CF growth 8%
Discount rate 12%
Terminal growth 3%
ETH supply 122m ETH
Stage 1
PV(CF1−10)=∑t=1102.97(1.08)t(1.12)tPV(CF_{1-10})= \sum_{t=1}^{10} \frac{2.97(1.08)^t}{(1.12)^t}
= $24.45bn
Terminal value
TV=CF10(1.03)0.12−0.03TV = \frac{CF_{10}(1.03)} {0.12-0.03}
Discounted back:
PV(TV)≈$23.63bnPV(TV) \approx \$23.63bn
Therefore:
Ethereum Network Value=24.45+23.63=$48.08bnEthereum\ Network\ Value = 24.45+23.63 = \$48.08bn
Divide by 122m ETH:
ETH DCF Value≈$394\boxed{ETH\ DCF\ Value \approx \$394}
Which creates an apparent problem
ETH is trading around the ~$2,700 reference level used in the underlying October data.
So a pure cash-flow DCF produces only ~$400 per ETH.What that means, as I have said many times, is that most of ETH's market valuation cannot rationally be attributed purely to conventional distributable cash flow. Hence you see Vitalik's nonsense and desperate recent statement that "Eth could also be a store of value" which was widely rediculed, for obvious reasons,
Some assumptions:
My calculated values are:
Discount rate 5% growth 8% growth 11% growth10% $415 $519 $648
12% $320 $394 $487
14% $259 $316 $385
So even using relatively bullish assumptions, conventional DCF struggles to get ETH anywhere near the price that Eth currently is.
Obsidian would likely point out we should also attribute value to things such as:
reserve/collateral within the Ethereum ecosystem;
settlement asset;
staking/security asset;
DeFi collateral;
liquidity asset;
store of value;
institutional crypto asset.
Ie - valuing Ethereum solely on L1 transaction fees substantially undervalues the total economic network. That is not a bad argument.
And I agree, if Eth does becomes substantially more important as the settlement and collateral layer for tokenized financial assets and stablecoins, then the monetary component would dominates the DCF component, and the price would be justified as being a lot higher.