Author Topic: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!  (Read 2502294 times)

obsidian

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 9077
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12950 on: November 03, 2026, 10:53:49 PM »
Why when it goes up and you hold some, it isn't manipulated?

Why is it only manipulated when a person holds some and it doesn't go up?

Price has never fallen below the 1yr bottom. When it happens is that manipulation to?

We know what BTC actually know what BTC is now. We don't quite know what ETH is. All we know is it was launch and BTC holders rotated over to pump it but it was all OGs and there created "alt season". So the next cycle the rotation occured and alt season repeated. That is manipulation.......

The next cycle it didn't occur. It was SOL. So we have 2 rotations out of 3.

Yet an ETF has been created which means it does mean something. We don't know what yet.
You're arguing against a point I never made. I'm not saying ETH is manipulated only when it goes down. I'm questioning the entire five-year price action — the peaks AND the valleys. Manipulation doesn't have to mean suppressing a price; it can mean pumping it just as easily. Calling out the volatility isn't the same as being upset about losing money. You're debating my portfolio, not my argument.

And just look at the five-year chart I've attached. Seriously, does that look like a healthy, organic price discovery journey to you? Look at those peaks and valleys. I'm not claiming the chart alone proves manipulation, but if that doesn't at least raise an eyebrow, I don't know what will. A mountain range isn't proof of manipulation, but pretending there's nothing unusual about the terrain is just as intellectually dishonest.


Griffith

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 10430
  • .......
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12951 on: November 04, 2026, 07:21:19 AM »
You're arguing against a point I never made. I'm not saying ETH is manipulated only when it goes down. I'm questioning the entire five-year price action — the peaks AND the valleys. Manipulation doesn't have to mean suppressing a price; it can mean pumping it just as easily. Calling out the volatility isn't the same as being upset about losing money. You're debating my portfolio, not my argument.

And just look at the five-year chart I've attached. Seriously, does that look like a healthy, organic price discovery journey to you? Look at those peaks and valleys. I'm not claiming the chart alone proves manipulation, but if that doesn't at least raise an eyebrow, I don't know what will. A mountain range isn't proof of manipulation, but pretending there's nothing unusual about the terrain is just as intellectually dishonest.



Take a look at the 1 minute chart for ETH today, a wick from about 2435 to 2310 (just under the low of the past few hours) for a few seconds with a sudden large spike in sell volume and then instantly back to the 2435 range.

Could have been market makers taking out people's stop losses, but there was nothing like that on BTC.

gib

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 5338
  • Getbig!
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12952 on: November 06, 2026, 05:53:30 AM »
Eth dropped 50% to BTC last 4 year cycle, and then 50% to BTC the prior 4 year cycle.

Its a terrible performance, (and I have explained why this would happen many times throughout this thread).

Griffith

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 10430
  • .......
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12953 on: November 06, 2026, 05:56:16 AM »
All that matters is how much you make after you've bought and sold.

obsidian

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 9077
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12954 on: November 06, 2026, 12:07:12 PM »
Take a look at the 1 minute chart for ETH today, a wick from about 2435 to 2310 (just under the low of the past few hours) for a few seconds with a sudden large spike in sell volume and then instantly back to the 2435 range.

Could have been market makers taking out people's stop losses, but there was nothing like that on BTC.
Either way, I really don't want to be invested long-term in an asset that can't get its shit together and is so easily manipulated.

Right now, I recognize that I'm dealing with a sunk-cost fallacy when it comes to ETH. I'm disgusted by its price action, but I'm stubborn enough that I'd rather ride it all the way to zero than jump ship and move into another asset. I genuinely believe ETH is significantly undervalued, but markets can remain irrational for a long time, and there's no guarantee that the market will eventually recognize its value. If ETH reaches a price point where I feel I've been adequately compensated for putting up with all this drama, I will absolutely sell off 50% or more of my position.

Bitcoin has worked out great for Gib, but I think he's far too confident in the long-term sustainability of its proof-of-work (PoW) model. I just don't see how miners will continue securing the network if doing so becomes economically unprofitable. Meanwhile, AI is going to consume an enormous amount of energy, potentially competing with Bitcoin mining for the same resources.

On top of that, I think BTC is currently overvalued relative to the rest of the crypto market. Gib claims Bitcoin is the future of finance. Seriously? It can barely process seven transactions per second on its base layer. Meanwhile, JPMorgan and other major financial institutions are building blockchain-based financial infrastructure on Ethereum and other networks.

So how exactly does Bitcoin become the future of finance when its base-layer transaction capacity is so limited, and much of the institutional infrastructure being developed is happening elsewhere?

gib

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 5338
  • Getbig!
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12955 on: November 06, 2026, 12:31:29 PM »
All that matters is how much you make after you've bought and sold.

Well if you are a Bitcoiner, you don't actually "sell", so what what matters is how much your prevailing fiat currency has devalued to your BTC. But, I know what you mean...

gib

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 5338
  • Getbig!
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12956 on: November 06, 2026, 12:40:31 PM »
Either way, I really don't want to be invested long-term in an asset that can't get its shit together and is so easily manipulated.

Right now, I recognize that I'm dealing with a sunk-cost fallacy when it comes to ETH. I'm disgusted by its price action, but I'm stubborn enough that I'd rather ride it all the way to zero than jump ship and move into another asset. I genuinely believe ETH is significantly undervalued, but markets can remain irrational for a long time, and there's no guarantee that the market will eventually recognize its value. If ETH reaches a price point where I feel I've been adequately compensated for putting up with all this drama, I will absolutely sell off 50% or more of my position.

Bitcoin has worked out great for Gib, but I think he's far too confident in the long-term sustainability of its proof-of-work (PoW) model. I just don't see how miners will continue securing the network if doing so becomes economically unprofitable. Meanwhile, AI is going to consume an enormous amount of energy, potentially competing with Bitcoin mining for the same resources.

On top of that, I think BTC is currently overvalued relative to the rest of the crypto market. Gib claims Bitcoin is the future of finance. Seriously? It can barely process seven transactions per second on its base layer. Meanwhile, JPMorgan and other major financial institutions are building blockchain-based financial infrastructure on Ethereum and other networks.

So how exactly does Bitcoin become the future of finance when its base-layer transaction capacity is so limited, and much of the institutional infrastructure being developed is happening elsewhere?

Dude tried so many times to get you over. Remember, I was saying just to bite the bullet and at least move some over to BTC over time. Or, just pull the band aid off all at once.

You still really don't seem to get it -all this JP Morgan building on Eth etc. Eth is not used as a store of value - that was a deliberate affinity confusion from the outset. It is a transaction technology, which earns revenue, but also has many competitors. BTC, because of the energy correlation and Proof of Work is DIGITIZED SCARCITY. It is the base layer of the future financial system in terms of store of value. It IS THE LEDGER FOR ALL ECONOMIC ENERGY  - that its simple, but only function. Every thing else, and many things, will be done with blockchain technology, but BTC's role remains the same in all of that. Effectively any usefulness of ETH, or any other blockchain, are ultimately measured in BTC. This has always been clear to me, but it will become increasingly obvious to all over time.

gib

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 5338
  • Getbig!
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12957 on: November 10, 2026, 08:16:10 AM »
Eth getting absolutely raped today.

And what an absolute disgrace, Vitalik seemingly admitting "proof of stake" was an mistake, and that he wishes Eth could be repositioned as a store of value (seemingly admitting that real scarcity requires effort to achieve it - ie BTC Proof of Work), seemingly contracting the narrative of the so called "Ethereum foundation".

What an absolute dogs breakfast...

Mayday

  • Getbig IV
  • ****
  • Posts: 3174
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12958 on: November 14, 2026, 02:24:51 PM »
Eth getting absolutely raped today.

And what an absolute disgrace, Vitalik seemingly admitting "proof of stake" was an mistake, and that he wishes Eth could be repositioned as a store of value (seemingly admitting that real scarcity requires effort to achieve it - ie BTC Proof of Work), seemingly contracting the narrative of the so called "Ethereum foundation".

What an absolute dogs breakfast...

Iwe know what BTC prices in now so that much easier understood. But it's taken about 14yrs to actually find that out and even now,  the majority don't know what it prices, they buy on pure social media posts.

Can we also say the same for ETH? It's much younger so do we really know what it is pricing? I have some ideas but nothing I can support with numbers.

Loads of time for ETH anyway, years and years and years.  People going to get absolutely destroyed........

Mayday

  • Getbig IV
  • ****
  • Posts: 3174
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12959 on: November 14, 2026, 02:47:02 PM »

63.6k now.....

It'd be very cool if the lows hold. That gives us more time to destroy more people.


obsidian

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 9077
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12960 on: November 14, 2026, 04:55:28 PM »
Eth getting absolutely raped today.

And what an absolute disgrace, Vitalik seemingly admitting "proof of stake" was an mistake, and that he wishes Eth could be repositioned as a store of value (seemingly admitting that real scarcity requires effort to achieve it - ie BTC Proof of Work), seemingly contracting the narrative of the so called "Ethereum foundation".

What an absolute dogs breakfast...
BTC is also getting raped. Be careful gloating at other people's pain. It might come back to bite you in the ass. Ever heard of karma?

Vitalik did not admit "proof of stake" was a mistake. It is arguable better than "proof of work". We'll find out after a few more halvings how many miners will stick around to secure Bitcoin. They might have a lot of hashrate, but if it is only a few miners securing Bitcoin then it is not decentralized at all and can be taken down.

I am just wondering why it took Vitalik so long to finally say ETH should be a SOV. All the investors are sitting here saying WTF?! Ethereum cannot survive with a low ETH value because people will unstake and its security budget will collapse like Bitcoin's. All Ethereum developers should consider upgrades that will improve marketing ETH as an investment. Quantum resistance is a perfect example. People are now saying Ethereum should be quantum and AI ready by 2027. At the very least a few years sooner than Bitcoin. That could give an advantage over ossified Bitcoin.

Then the narrative should be ETH is the most secure, programmable,digital gold that's also quantum and AI ready!

obsidian

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 9077
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12961 on: November 14, 2026, 04:56:42 PM »
63.6k now.....

It'd be very cool if the lows hold. That gives us more time to destroy more people.
Send it lower. I don't care. I'll buy ETH if it goes below $500. One thing I won't be doing is sell - lmao! Nice try scumbags!

Mayday

  • Getbig IV
  • ****
  • Posts: 3174
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12962 on: November 14, 2026, 06:37:20 PM »
62.8k..... then a big buy the dip ....

Why would you buy more ETH?  Isn't there a point where after a decade of nowhere you say hey, I probably shouldn't be buying more of this shit? I mean, you might wait 20 years from. Here before an ATH to double your money. There is so much scammy grifting going on the alt space isn't going to go anywhere, anytime soon.

obsidian

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 9077
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12963 on: November 14, 2026, 08:52:28 PM »
62.8k..... then a big buy the dip ....

Why would you buy more ETH?  Isn't there a point where after a decade of nowhere you say hey, I probably shouldn't be buying more of this shit? I mean, you might wait 20 years from. Here before an ATH to double your money. There is so much scammy grifting going on the alt space isn't going to go anywhere, anytime soon.
If you look at ETH's chart it's gone from $1.5k to 4.5k many times now. You think the people manipulating it will stop that party now? They'll push it back up again. $500 to $4,500 is an 8x on your initial capital.

Yes, ETH's price action has been horrendous. The irony is people who traded that volatility the right way would have far outperformed just holding Bitcoin which has been less volatile.

Mayday

  • Getbig IV
  • ****
  • Posts: 3174
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12964 on: November 14, 2026, 11:30:02 PM »
If you look at ETH's chart it's gone from $1.5k to 4.5k many times now. You think the people manipulating it will stop that party now? They'll push it back up again. $500 to $4,500 is an 8x on your initial capital.

Yes, ETH's price action has been horrendous. The irony is people who traded that volatility the right way would have far outperformed just holding Bitcoin which has been less volatile.

People can't time.shit though.

8x is the price action, their gain is -50% because they bought at 3k, missed the top and then go underwater.

The gambler attitude is I lost a bunch, got it wrong therefore I should double down because next time will be the big one......  I can"t feel it, it just wasn't my day, the dog barked and put the market off....... Remember, people were cheering when price went to 1,300 and they wanted lower!   Every grifter and gambler will tell you they are ahead, they all lie.


Answer me this one. What does ETH actually price?  I believe I know. It isn't anything what the gurus and grifters tell you it is. Mind you, they don't know what BTC is either.

gib

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 5338
  • Getbig!
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12965 on: Today at 04:30:06 AM »
"People who traded that volatility the right way would have far outperformed just holding Bitcoin which has been less volatile."

Almost impossible in reality. If anyone could successfully do this, they would be infinitely wealthy.

Mayday

  • Getbig IV
  • ****
  • Posts: 3174
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12966 on: Today at 11:45:04 AM »
The Q4 event window has been pretty crap so far. I had Oc-Nov as the main period, we got Outlook and then the airports but nothing that was proper crazy. The shade market selloff so far doesn't even register as anything.

We have to see something snap. Until that happens, the event hasn't occured. It's hard to know "when" but we have now to April as an option, Q4 2027, Q4 2028.

gib

  • Getbig V
  • *****
  • Posts: 5338
  • Getbig!
Re: Bitcoins - about to hit $5,000 per coin today!
« Reply #12967 on: Today at 12:34:47 PM »

Answer me this one. What does ETH actually price?  I believe I know. It isn't anything what the gurus and grifters tell you it is. Mind you, they don't know what BTC is either.

Bro I explained this over a year ago, but not many people understood me or bothered to read. I came up with a "back of envelope" price of around $500 Eth. Obsidian will recall, as he told me I was being ridiculous at the time.

Again assuming: roughly 122 million ETH outstanding, 43.7 million ETH staked and ~2.6% staking APR.

1. The basic formula

VETH=∑t=1NCFt(1+r)t+CFN(1+gT)(r−gT)(1+r)NETHdiluted supplyV_{ETH} = \frac{ \sum_{t=1}^{N}\frac{CF_t}{(1+r)^t} + \frac{CF_N(1+g_T)}{(r-g_T)(1+r)^N} }{ ETH_{\text{diluted supply}} }

Where:

CFtCF_t = annual economic cash flow attributable to ETH
rr = required return/discount rate
gTg_T = long-term terminal growth
NN = explicit forecast period
supply = expected ETH supply

The hard part of curse is defining CF. Ie - What constitutes ETH "cash flow"?

CFt=StakingRewardst+MEVt+PriorityFeest−ValidatorCoststCF_t = StakingRewards_t + MEV_t + PriorityFees_t - ValidatorCosts_t

One thing (Obsidian has pointed it out in the past). ETH burned by EIP-1559 isn't literally a "cash payment" to holders. It's closer to a share buyback as it reduces token supply. I would therefore incorporate burning through the denominator/supply forecast rather than adding it to cash flow. That avoids double counting.

So, approximately 43.7m ETH, 35.8% of supply, is currently staked, at roughly 2.6% annual staking rewards.

That implies roughly:

43.7m×2.6%≈1.14mETH43.7m \times 2.6\% \approx 1.14m ETH

in annual staking rewards, broadly consistent with estimates of roughly 1.1m ETH annual issuance before burns.

Now, take 2026 starting cash flow

Using an ETH reference price of approximately $2,700 from the October data:

1.1mETH×$2,700=$2.97bn1.1m ETH \times \$2,700 = \$2.97bn

The $2,700 reference price and approximately 122m supply are consistent with the recent staking statistics.

So, say $2.97bn as an illustrative year-zero economic cash-flow base.

Then assume:

Variable   Base assumptionStarting economic CF   $2.97bn
Explicit forecast   10 years
CF growth   8%
Discount rate   12%
Terminal growth   3%
ETH supply   122m ETH
Stage 1
PV(CF1−10)=∑t=1102.97(1.08)t(1.12)tPV(CF_{1-10})= \sum_{t=1}^{10} \frac{2.97(1.08)^t}{(1.12)^t}

= $24.45bn

Terminal value
TV=CF10(1.03)0.12−0.03TV = \frac{CF_{10}(1.03)} {0.12-0.03}

Discounted back:

PV(TV)≈$23.63bnPV(TV) \approx \$23.63bn

Therefore:

Ethereum Network Value=24.45+23.63=$48.08bnEthereum\ Network\ Value = 24.45+23.63 = \$48.08bn

Divide by 122m ETH:

ETH DCF Value≈$394\boxed{ETH\ DCF\ Value \approx \$394}
Which creates an apparent problem

ETH is trading around the ~$2,700 reference level used in the underlying October data.

So a pure cash-flow DCF produces only ~$400 per ETH.

What that means, as I have said many times, is that most of ETH's market valuation cannot rationally be attributed purely to conventional distributable cash flow. Hence you see Vitalik's nonsense and desperate recent statement that "Eth could also be a store of value" which was widely rediculed, for obvious reasons,

Some assumptions:

My calculated values are:

Discount rate   5% growth   8% growth   11% growth10%   $415   $519   $648
12%   $320   $394   $487
14%   $259   $316   $385

So even using relatively bullish assumptions, conventional DCF struggles to get ETH anywhere near the price that Eth currently is.

Obsidian would likely point out we should also attribute value to things such as:

reserve/collateral within the Ethereum ecosystem;
settlement asset;
staking/security asset;
DeFi collateral;
liquidity asset;
store of value;
institutional crypto asset.

Ie - valuing Ethereum solely on L1 transaction fees substantially undervalues the total economic network. That is not a bad argument.

And I agree, if Eth does becomes substantially more important as the settlement and collateral layer for tokenized financial assets and stablecoins, then the monetary component would dominates the DCF component, and the price would be justified as being a lot higher.