Obama, shovel this
By JOHN CRUDELELast Updated: 1:21 AM, September 13, 2011
This is a shovel-ready column. And by that I don’t mean you should go in the yard and bury it immediately.
This column is about the notion that “shovel-ready” jobs really exist. That’s the infamous phrase President Obama used in 2009 when he pushed through a $787 billion stimulus package.
In March of that year -- only two weeks after the stimulus was passed -- the president said that jobs were already being created or “saved.”
The idea of “saving” jobs is, of course, a convenient dodge because it defies being verified -- just the kind of gobbledygook that politicians love.
The president put the saved-or-created total at 400,000 jobs.
Well, President Obama was wrong -- and he admitted it early this summer.
Speaking before the Council on Jobs and Competitiveness in Durham, NC, in June the president went off script and said “shovel-ready was not as... uh ... shovel-ready as we expected.”
Yesterday Obama sent another jobs bill to Congress. He didn’t use the words “shovel-ready” in a speech last Thursday laying out this bill.
Wise choice.
The latest bright idea to create jobs will be a bargain at just $447 billion. The president promised last Thursday when the bill was publicly announced that it would be paid for ahead of time and not add to the budget deficit
Back in 2009 I wrote about my gut feeling: if a project was truly shovel-ready -- meaning, on the verge of hiring workers -- it would already be funded. So federal money would only be replacing funds already allocated by the states for a project.
In the end, there would be no net gain in jobs -- just a shifting around of dough from state to federal budgets.
But let’s look at the 2009 stimulus in another way: did it create any jobs?
In 2010 we created 940,000 jobs. .
So far this year the number is 872,000.
So those 1.83 million jobs created in 2009 and 2010 ended up costing -- in stimulus terms -- about $430,000 per job.
Worse, this perpetually weak economy could cause companies to begin a new round of layoffs.
Bank of America, for instance, just yesterday announced that it would eventually let 30,000 workers go in order to save $5 billion. The troubled bank blamed over-regulation by Washington.
But we wouldn’t even be at this point if Washington had spent wisely in 2009. What’s the president shoveling these days?
john.crudele@nypost.com
Read more:
http://www.nypost.com/p/news/business/obama_shovel_this_hMNRlwAPfMUdladOsDYywI#ixzz1Xr8xZkJe